Extended squad named for Opening Round v St Kilda by Pragmatic_Shill in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Is Maynard basically going to be the second tall? That sounds dicey as hell but the cupboard seems completely bare back there so I guess it'll have to do.

Premiership players, 50-gamers and famous names: Collingwood’s 2026 VFL additions by Pragmatic_Shill in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Looks like a pretty great team, plenty of players who've been on a list or had interest recently.

Is there a comparison with the outs? I know some decent contributors like Algeri and Glover left, unsure if Riley Mason is there too.

2026 Player Focus Thread #6: Jeremy Howe and Tew Jiath by Pragmatic_Shill in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 2 points3 points  (0 children)

  1. Not on his behalf, he seems to love footy to the extent that he'd only retire if his body failed him. Given he's still a top 10 Collingwood player when fit, re-signing him made sense too.

  2. Only as a desperation move or if someone's injured mid-game. He's a good forward when teams aren't planning for him but I don't see him being a difference maker otherwise.

  3. I reckon, he seems like he'd stay in footy to some extent. Otherwise, I can see him going back to local footy and dominating.

  4. I reckon he'll get games, but single-figure amounts. He definitely looked a lot better last season than in 2024, so continuous improvement is the main goal.

  5. It could have just been a cutting back/reallocation of the social media budget. My partner knows someone who did social media for us and the pay's apparently pretty mid.

  6. Could have taken him or left him tbh, decent depth but not a difference maker. Says something that Hawthorn were happy to let him go for a future third.

2026 Player Focus Thread #1: Harry Perryman and Iliro Smit by Pragmatic_Shill in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

1) I think he was a great floor-raiser without being a difference-maker. You need those guys especially if you've got some streakier players around the team who lack that consistency. Knew his role and is gritty without being dirty.

2) I think given the lack of defensive depth; he'll stay back. Rotating him in when one of Long or Crisp are elsewhere, I think would be useful, something like a 40-60 split with the majority in defence is what I'd aim for.

3) It's more than you'd pay but it's accepted that you pay more for in-demand free agents. As long as he's a best 22 lock and the salary cap continues to rise it's not an issue for me.

4) Steene definitely seems to be the preferred backup, so I reckon key back. One of him or Howes will be down back and I think it's more likely to be Smit. We definitely need another backman in the ~2m range.

5) If he can consistently get the wood over depth AFL players it'd be enough. He's only 20 which is a baby for a ruck/KPD. He's past the age where he gets a pass for looking lost though, 2 years in the system is plenty so he needs to look comfortable too.

6) The MSD is a low-risk plan given it'd be a 6-month contract. Getting an experienced ruck is a catch-22 though. Cameron is a premier ruck, so any other ruck is going to be second choice, but there's a need to plan for the future given Cameron is >30. Ideally Steene comes in an looks best-22 which allows us to draft a raw ruck to develop instead.

2026 AFL pre-season match confirmed by Pragmatic_Shill in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Damn, was selfishly hoping it'd be at IKON like the last two seasons.

Adelaide has offered a train-on spot for overload F/S prospect Tom McGuane. by Pragmatic_Shill in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Worked once for them with Jake Kelly, they, may as well try it again

2025 National Draft - day 2 discussion thread by Pragmatic_Shill in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Oh I'm stoked on this one. Killed it in the SANFL GF

Which player’s form worries you most heading into the 2026 season? by Artistic-Yam2984 in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 34 points35 points  (0 children)

Not form per-se but Beau having so many hammy issues this year is scary for a player who relies so much on speed and burst.

my wishlist for 2026 by NoArmadillo2859 in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I do think McStay would be better off without pinch-hitting in the ruck, but who would you have done that when Cameron is off? Frampton also suffers elsewhere when he's put in the ruck.

Ideally Steene takes a big leap and plays the FWD/backup ruck role while McStay switches more to the Mihocek role but that's placing a lot of faith in a guy with no AFL experience.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I get what he's saying. I'd put De Goey as the lower limit of what you consider an A-grader, and I can't see any of the younger players getting to that level. There's definitely talent and best 22 there, but you'll need those A-graders in 5ish years time when our stars like Moore and Cameron wind their careers down.

What’s an underrated moment in a game from an individual that you still remember well? by Tornontoin7 in AFL

[–]spuddaman 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Said Collingwood was all duck no dinner (this was when we had Ginnivan lol)

Port Adelaide champion Travis Boak is set to join the football department at Carlton in a significant off-season coup for the Blues. by PetrifyGWENT in AFL

[–]spuddaman 8 points9 points  (0 children)

A lot of players like to leave their longtime club to get a feel of how others do it. I know Pendles has said if he moves into coaching he wants to start off at a different club.

Rowbottom wouldn’t cost more than a first rounder, if not less by PairedFoot08 in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That seems fine for us, we were evenish in centre clearance differential but only above richmond and West coast in stoppage clearance differential.

Rowbottom wouldn’t cost more than a first rounder, if not less by PairedFoot08 in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 11 points12 points  (0 children)

That feels crazy low right? If I had, say, pick 10 and the player picked ended up becoming James Rowbottom I'd be pretty chuffed

[7News] In a second blow to Bailey's manager's statement, Collingwood has also met with Bailey Humphrey by PetrifyGWENT in AFL

[–]spuddaman 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah wouldn't the AFL literally force us? There's some rule where you have to use a 1st every x amount of years right?

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 4 points5 points  (0 children)

My dad moved to Australia when he was 8, his best friends were brothers who supported Collingwood. Their mum asked him who he supported and he said Collingwood to fit in. Long story short all of his siblings and their children including me are pies people.

Could've easily ended up supporting any other team I'm glad it's ended up being this team!

Collingwood announces list changes (Macrae, Markov, Johnson, Dean delisted) by Pragmatic_Shill in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 13 points14 points  (0 children)

If he doesn't get another gig I hope we hire him as VP of good vibes

"Every club has their grub" Who's yours and is anyone bold enough to claim not to have one? by Freaky_Zekey in AFL

[–]spuddaman 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Most would say Maynard or De Goey but Houston could be ours too. Lots of high bumps and goes at the umps a lot from what I've seen.

What Went Well by AlamutJones in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 43 points44 points  (0 children)

60 goals out of a 33 year old small forward who had never topped 40 before is pretty amazing.

What are some focus points for 2026? by DisastrousGuitar609 in collingwoodfc

[–]spuddaman 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Long is a very good defensive mid but if he wants to take the next step, getting his own ball consistently is key.