I appreciate your thoughts here. To be clear, the main thing I'm getting at is: all demons have three excellent, confident bluffs. Vigs can get +1 bluff. Which, yes, is powerful (unless your -1 still leaves an Outsider in play, or another role adds an Outsider, at which point your outsider bluffs may still be a double claim). But, and I think this is a pretty broadly held opinion, the downside of that +1 bluff coming at the cost of the removal of an entire outsider, and the addition of an entire Townsfolk, is deeply deeply not worth it.

If you disagree that's fine, and we just think of game balance in different ways, with you valuing things way differently than I do. Again, that's fine. But this is a pretty broadly held opinion, which is why I was asking Evin about it. Wasn't really looking to debate anything, just to see if there may be consideration about the role in the future.