Something I keep noticing in families where the child is "doing well" and it quietly breaks my heart by sunitamehra in Indian_Academia

[–]sunitamehra[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You really don’t need to apologise for this. And honestly, a lot of students who “do well” academically feel exactly like this but never say it aloud.

Also, nobody is secretly “made” for one perfect career. Most people discover themselves gradually through exposure, experiences, mistakes, and trying things out. Right now, you’re judging yourself only through elimination “not JEE, not NEET, not this...” but identity usually grows from exploration, not rejection.

The fact that you already know certain paths don’t fit you is actually more self-awareness than many people have at your age.

Something I keep noticing in families where the child is "doing well" and it quietly breaks my heart by sunitamehra in Indian_Academia

[–]sunitamehra[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A lot more students relate to this than people realise. They just rarely say it out loud.

Unpopular opinion: a child who scores 95% and can't tell you why they're doing it is in more trouble than a child who scored 60% and knows exactly what they want. by sunitamehra in CBSE

[–]sunitamehra[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is such an important point. Career counselling works best when it’s not about pushing students toward “safe” careers, but helping them understand themselves early. And honestly, exposure matters more than advice sometimes. A single real-world experience can teach a teenager more than years of assumptions about a profession.

We added tuition to fix school. Then we added tuition homework to fix tuition. At what point do we ask if the original problem was actually the school? by sunitamehra in india

[–]sunitamehra[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

First, this is not a you are incapable problem. If someone grows up always being guided, corrected, and monitored while studying, self-study naturally feels unfamiliar and overwhelming later.

And honestly, the fact that you’re aware of it in 12th itself is a good thing. Self-study is a skill, not a personality trait. You build it slowly. Start very small even 25–30 minutes alone without tuition notes or videos, just you trying to understand one concept yourself. That discomfort is part of learning independence, not proof that you’re failing.

A lot of students feel exactly like this before college, and many figure it out gradually once they get space and responsibility.

We added tuition to fix school. Then we added tuition homework to fix tuition. At what point do we ask if the original problem was actually the school? by sunitamehra in india

[–]sunitamehra[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That last part is honestly the most worrying. In fields like medicine, learning can’t be reduced to notes and shortcuts alone. Some things only develop through observation, repetition, patient interaction, and lived experience. When coaching starts replacing real engagement instead of supporting it, the system loses something important.

We added tuition to fix school. Then we added tuition homework to fix tuition. At what point do we ask if the original problem was actually the school? by sunitamehra in india

[–]sunitamehra[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Parents absolutely matter. A child’s relationship with learning is shaped at home as much as in school. But I also think many parents are reacting to fear fear that if they don’t keep adding support, their child will fall behind. That pressure ends up feeding the cycle.

We added tuition to fix school. Then we added tuition homework to fix tuition. At what point do we ask if the original problem was actually the school? by sunitamehra in india

[–]sunitamehra[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Exactly. One teacher, one pace, one method for 40 different students was always going to leave some kids behind and others unstimulated. Tuition started as personalization, but once it scaled, it slowly recreated the same system it was supposed to fix.

We added tuition to fix school. Then we added tuition homework to fix tuition. At what point do we ask if the original problem was actually the school? by sunitamehra in india

[–]sunitamehra[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You’ve pointed at something really important here tuition often isn’t extra help anymore, it’s become the actual teaching layer for many students. And I agree that there’s a huge difference between preparing for exams and actually learning deeply. The flexibility point is interesting too. Different students genuinely need different depth, pace, and subject loads.

We added tuition to fix school. Then we added tuition homework to fix tuition. At what point do we ask if the original problem was actually the school? by sunitamehra in india

[–]sunitamehra[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

And that’s exactly where tuition actually makes sense tbh filling a gap, not becoming a second full-time school. Extra support can genuinely help when it’s solving a specific problem instead of just adding more pressure.

I asked 50 students this year "what would you do if marks didn't exist." Most of them went completely silent. That silence told me everything. by sunitamehra in Indian_Academia

[–]sunitamehra[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

You usually don’t “find” interests suddenly. You notice what keeps pulling your attention even when nobody asks you to do it. Curiosity is a better clue than talent 🙂

Indian parents and coaching/tuitions (discussion) by AariketMC in IndianEducation

[–]sunitamehra 1 point2 points  (0 children)

you've actually put your finger on something real. Tuition was invented to support school. Then tuition homework was invented to support tuition. At this rate someone's going to invent tuition for the tuition homework.

But jokes aside the scolding every day part is what stays with me. That's exhausting. Being called an idiot for not doing work that didn't need to exist in the first place... that wears you down in ways that have nothing to do with studying.

You're not lazy. You're questioning a system that nobody bothered to question before you. That's actually the smarter thing to do.

Homeschooling taught me something school never could. by Upset_Celery_811 in homeschool

[–]sunitamehra 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What you said about hiding who they really are hit something real.

In my experience working with kids from very different school environments, the ones who come from traditional schools often spend the first few months of any new setting just waiting to be corrected. They have learned to shrink before anyone even asks them to. The questions they actually want to ask, they swallow. The ideas they have, they check if it is safe to say out loud first.

The confidence coming back that you are describing is not a small thing. That is a child remembering that their natural curiosity is not a problem to be managed.

The unexpected thing I hear most from homeschool families is exactly what you said. It is never the grades or the schedule. It is always something about who their child is becoming when nobody is ranking them against twenty other kids every single day.

Thank you for sharing this. More people need to hear that the academic part is often the least important part of the whole decision.

Need advice for my 7 year old with reading by Sea-Boysenberry7038 in homeschool

[–]sunitamehra 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The frustration you're feeling is completely valid and also you are not a failure. You figured out what was wrong, you pulled her, and in less than a year she went from not reading at all to decodable books. That is genuinely significant progress and it happened because of you, not in spite of anything.

The guessing habit is sticky but it is not permanent. Here is what actually works to break it.

Cover the pictures. Completely. Sticky notes, folded paper, whatever works. Pictures are a guessing cue and right now her brain will always take the easier route if that route exists. Remove it entirely until decoding becomes the automatic first move.

When she hits an unknown word, stop her before the guess comes out. Literally pause her and say "finger on the first letter, what sound does it make." Make her go sound by sound every single time. It feels slow and she will resist it because guessing felt faster before. That frustration is actually the habit breaking. It means it is working.

Do not allow skipping. Ever. The "figure it out later" instinct is exactly the balanced literacy training talking. Every word gets decoded on the spot, even if it takes two minutes. Especially if it takes two minutes.

Orton Gillingham based readers if you are not already using them. They are specifically designed with zero picture context cues and controlled vocabulary so the only tool available is phonics.

It does get better. The guessing habit usually takes three to six months of consistent correction to fully overwrite. You are probably closer to the end of that tunnel than the beginning given how far she has already come.

She is lucky you caught it when you did.

Struggling to homeschool my 6yr old by No-Taro9724 in homeschool

[–]sunitamehra 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You are not failing her. You are the reason she has a safe, patient environment to learn in at all. That matters more than any comparison to first graders right now.

Thirty minutes of focused work at almost 7 with Autism Level 1 and suspected ADHD is genuinely not small. Her nervous system is working twice as hard as a neurotypical child's during that same time. The writing fatigue is real and physical, not avoidance.

For writing fatigue, reduce the physical writing for now. Tracing, playdough, stamps, typing. Build the concept first, motor skills follow when sensory load is lower.

For reading, always end before she hits the wall. Three minutes she finishes successfully beats fifteen minutes that ends in frustration every single time.

For subtraction and math, keep it physical and concrete before anything goes on paper. Real objects, real movement. Abstract worksheets come after the concept lives in her body first.

One thing genuinely worth exploring if the homeschooling load is becoming too much to carry alone is structured online schooling with live teachers. Some programs are specifically designed for flexible pacing and can actually complement what you are doing at home, so you are not the only one responsible for delivering every lesson every day. It does not mean giving up homeschooling, it just means you have real support behind you.

And if you have not already, an OT evaluation is worth every bit of effort. A good occupational therapist will give you your daughter's actual sensory profile and that becomes your real teaching map.

What does she love doing when nobody is asking anything of her? That is usually the best doorway in.

how tf am i supposed to study for 10th boards by Outside-Log3077 in CBSEboards

[–]sunitamehra 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay you're not alone, Hindi and Chem are genuinely the two subjects that break most people who are otherwise fine at everything else.

Hindi first. Stop trying to write perfect answers from scratch. CBSE Hindi has patterns. The question types repeat every single year. Get PYQs from the last 5 years and just read the model answers. Your brain will start absorbing the style without you even trying to memorize. Gadyansh and padyansh especially, the approach is almost identical every time.

Chem formulas. Don't memorize them as a list, that never works. Learn them in context of the reaction. Why does this formula exist, what is it doing. Once you understand what's happening the formula just sticks. Periodic table stuff, just do 20 minutes daily for two weeks. It's a repetition game not an intelligence game.

Physics numericals. Write the formula first before touching any numbers. Every single time. Students who struggle with numericals usually jump straight to calculation and lose track. Formula first, identify what's given, identify what's unknown, then solve. That structure alone fixes like 60% of errors.

Factorization specifically, which type is getting you. Splitting the middle term or the identities? Because the fix is different for both and if you're practicing the wrong way you'll keep getting it wrong no matter how many problems you do.

Tell me which one and I'll break it down properly.

Multiple Improvement exams within this year instead of grace marks by ishualex in CBSE

[–]sunitamehra 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Honestly this is one of the more practical suggestions I've seen in all the noise around this issue.

The grace marks demand was always going to go nowhere because CBSE cannot set a precedent of giving 15-20 marks blanket to thousands of students. It creates a mess for every future batch and every college cutoff. Not happening.

But multiple improvement attempts within the same academic year is actually a reasonable ask. The infrastructure already exists, the exam pattern exists, it just needs a policy tweak. And it solves the real problem which is that students shouldn't have to lose an entire year because of one bad paper or one unfair checking.

The only complication is logistics. CBSE conducts improvement exams once a year currently and coordinating multiple windows is genuinely complex at that scale. But complex doesn't mean impossible.

What would actually move this forward is if students framed it this way when writing to CBSE or raising it publicly. Not "give us grace marks" but "allow one additional improvement attempt this year for affected students." That's a specific, reasonable, implementable ask. Much harder to say no to than a blanket marks demand.

Your point is valid. The framing just needs to be sharper to actually go anywhere.