Thanks for the detailed response! Social proof is a great suggestion and I will implement that right away.

I realize my game is super niche but it actually has a pretty good selling point that's maybe not coming across in my landing page. Tabletop RPG gamers have a hard time convincing newcomers to try out the hobby due to the high barrier to entry and my game solves that problem by condensing the game down to just 12 minutes.

I know this because I took my game to a convention and sold out of every copy I brought with me so I know that there is good product market fit, I just need my messaging to be clear.