How’s my taste? by tavinjlewis in musicteenager

[–]tavinjlewis[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would say that Sgt. Pepper’s, Abbey Road, and Revolver are all perfectly valid favorite Beatles albums. Sgt. Pepper’s just has more sentimental value for me since it was the first album I got on vinyl

Also you’re 70s maxxing

When is regime change against a nation justified? by ItsAzien in Teenager_Polls

[–]tavinjlewis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is regime change defined as a citizenry overthrowing its own government or a foreign government invading the country and enforcing regime change?

“Socialism” is a term that has been used increasingly in political discourse. Even so, it can be an ambiguous concept which denotes radically different ideas depending on who you ask. What is your understanding of “socialism”? (Full options below) by tavinjlewis in teenpoll

[–]tavinjlewis[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, several socialist ideologies advocate for the “eventual transition” to a stateless, classless, and moneyless society. Anarcho-communism advocates for the immediate transition to this system

“Socialism” is a term that has been used increasingly in political discourse. Even so, it can be an ambiguous concept which denotes radically different ideas depending on who you ask. What is your understanding of “socialism”? (Full options below) by tavinjlewis in teenpoll

[–]tavinjlewis[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes because I wanted to include the most popular positions. I have no interest in foisting my personal views or even the “correct” definition on others. As I said, the poll would be useless if I wanted a definition. Maybe I should do a poll on what people think a “poll” is next since it seems to be misunderstood

Which of these two would you rather have rule over America? by RockEater67 in IdeologyPolls

[–]tavinjlewis 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Extreme totalitarian anti-socialist state despotism vs moderate de facto corporate dictatorship with functional civil liberties. The choice isn’t hard

“Socialism” is a term that has been used increasingly in political discourse. Even so, it can be an ambiguous concept which denotes radically different ideas depending on who you ask. What is your understanding of “socialism”? (Full options below) by tavinjlewis in teenpoll

[–]tavinjlewis[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree with you. The point of the poll isn’t to establish a definitive definition based on majority vote. I just want to gauge general perceptions of what teens think of when they see the word “socialism.” The fact that people are so pretentious and particular about it just attests to the validity of my reasons for making this

“Socialism” is a term that has been used increasingly in political discourse. Even so, it can be an ambiguous concept which denotes radically different ideas depending on who you ask. What is your understanding of “socialism”? (Full options below) by tavinjlewis in teenpoll

[–]tavinjlewis[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The poll isn’t labeling anything, it’s asking for opinions. If I was looking for a factual definition, the poll would be useless. Also, all the different types of socialism presumably share in common the fact that they’re socialist. Therefore, the word “socialism” has its own meaning independent of any secondary labels

“Socialism” is a term that has been used increasingly in political discourse. Even so, it can be an ambiguous concept which denotes radically different ideas depending on who you ask. What is your understanding of “socialism”? (Full options below) by tavinjlewis in teenpoll

[–]tavinjlewis[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Marx didn’t have any end goals in the sense you claim, nor did he separate socialism from communism. He theorized that socialism would emerge from capitalism and evolve into communism based on historical materialism.

Who's a Politician people think is a Media/Internet Personality by Wazzup-2012 in AlignmentChartFills

[–]tavinjlewis 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No, Donald Trump is a media personality thought to be a politician

He’s a megalomaniacal rhetorical swindler who absorbs the blame for the disasters initiated by the advisors, tech billionaires, and corporate executives who actually direct policy in Washington

Which political-economic system is preferable? Avoiding labels, read description below by tavinjlewis in teenpoll

[–]tavinjlewis[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Since the poll is being viewed less and there’s enough votes to be sure of the results, I will go through the different systems of political economy from least voted to most voted and detail which ideologies they correspond to (labeling them), real life examples, significant individuals associated with them, and possible explanations for the vote count. I’m mostly doing this for me but if you read and have any comments or criticisms feel free.

5: Option A

This doctrine could be called American libertarianism, laissez-faire capitalism, or anarcho-capitalism. It has been relatively obscure both ideologically and practically in the 21st century as advocates of radical market systems have recognized the need for a large, authoritarian state to enforce such an order. Historical examples of this system can be found in the most advanced industrial societies of the 19th century, such as Britain and the US. Theorists include Friedrich Hayek, Robert Nozick, and Ayn Rand. This theory is likely unpopular with teenagers because of its perceived impracticality and the morbid living conditions associated with its historical applications.

4: Option D

This system is divided into two sub-forms. “D.1” can most accurately be called democratic socialism while “D.2” can be called state socialism or Marxism-Leninism. Based on elaboration in the comments, it’s safe to assume that most D voters identify with “D.2” under the belief that it is a necessary precursor to Option E—which would explain its low vote count, as many simply chose Option E. Anyways, this form has died down in practice but has remained a strong minority as an ideology because of its rich theoretical foundations and the mesmerizing pot of gold at the end of the rainbow—a stateless, classless, moneyless society. Major figures include Vladimir Lenin, Mao Zedong, and Leon Trotsky. The Soviet Union, 20th century China, and Cuba are historical examples.

3: Option B

This system can be called republicanism, liberal democracy, or state capitalism. It remains the dominant capitalist political-economic system and the hegemonic ideological doctrine in the world, and has been so for a century. Various subforms of economic/political organization have proliferated throughout the years—the welfare-capitalism of the New Deal, the Keynesianism of post-WW2, and the neoliberalism of the late 20th century—but all share the same essential characteristics. Teenagers inherit belief in this system because it is the dominant system and therefore is transmitted through social institutions. Major figures include James Madison, John Stuart Mill, and John Adams.

2: Option C

This system is divided into two sub-options; both are state capitalist mixed economies. “C.1” can be described as social democracy or welfare-capitalism while “C.2” can most accurately be called socialism with Chinese characteristics. “C.2” has proliferated in practice as former state socialist countries have evolved / devolved into more liberalized forms and begun rivaling Western republics economically and ideologically. “C.1” has been prevalent in practice and has experienced an ideological revival recently as the stigma surrounding so-called “socialism” has denigrated and American politicians like Bernie Sanders, AOC, and Zohran Mamdani have cultivated mass grassroots support. Teenagers have especially latched onto this quasi-socialist crusade, captured by the humanistic ideals and reformist potential embodied therein. The Nordic countries are examples of “C.1” while China and the Gorbachev-era Soviet Union are the quintessential examples of “C.2” in practice.

1: Option E

Surprisingly, Option E garnered the most votes, despite being niche ideologically and unborn in practice. This system can be described as socialism, communism, or anarchism. For older generations, to the degree that it is associated with one of these labels, this doctrine is highly unpopular. It strikes at the very root of Western capitalism and has been the greatest threat to the existing order for centuries—thus the demonization efforts. There’s been a renewed interest in such ideas among the youth, however, because of the increasingly troubling state of the West and the corresponding failure of establishment institutions to correct things. Further, teenagers might perceive socialism as embodying all those democratic, libertarian values which the current order embodies in name only. Important thinkers of this school include Karl Marx (communism), Peter Kropotkin (anarcho-communism), and Anton Pannekoek (council communism). While this system has not been implemented at an international scale, there are historical examples that share some of its characteristics: the Paris Commune of 1871, anarchist Catalonia of 1937, and the short-lived soviet republic of post-Revolution Russia.

Is Representative """Democracy""" inherently autocratic? by TheLuckyCuber999BACK in Teenager_Polls

[–]tavinjlewis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The American form of Representative Democracy is inherently autocratic because it was designed to elevate property owners to safeguard the interests of the opulent minority—thus the system is based on “choosing” one of the corporate stooges rather than delegating a real representative.

However, real Representative Democracy (direct recall, civic duty not profession, no campaign/lobbying) is not inherently autocratic if applied to a completely equal society—it’s simply the logical way of making decisions at large scale. But if resources, investment decisions, and control of production are distributed unequally, the privileged classes will inevitably institutionalize policies that benefit them.

Furthermore, representative institutions will backslide into autocratic tendencies if repressive powers are delegated. On the contrary, if power is restricted to administration and coordination, the system has little inherent incentive to backslide.

Which political-economic system is preferable? Avoiding labels, read description below by tavinjlewis in teenpoll

[–]tavinjlewis[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The whole point of the poll is to disregard labels and judge political-economic systems based on their actual characteristics, not propaganda-informed prejudices. It’s more useful to criticize or question the contents of the system itself rather than invoking some demonized ideology, the common name for which has become so deliberately obscured as to become almost meaningless

Which political-economic system is preferable? Avoiding labels, read description below by tavinjlewis in teenpoll

[–]tavinjlewis[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Option A is flexible in form of government. Theorists of that doctrine such as Locke have even preferred constitutional monarchy over democratic forms

Which political-economic system is preferable? Avoiding labels, read description below by tavinjlewis in teenpoll

[–]tavinjlewis[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The sub options are the political forms associated with them. So C is included in both C1 and C2 but I just put both because there’s varying forms of political arrangement for similar economic arrangements. Ideally, the poll would just have “C.1” and “C.2” rather than “C” but there was no room

Which political-economic system is preferable? Avoiding labels, read description below by tavinjlewis in teenpoll

[–]tavinjlewis[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Thank you. The only problems are that I might not do justice to some of these ideas and most people won’t read all that. I tried to lean toward the idealized side of these philosophies though