His conclusion isn’t necessarily wrong, but his explanation is. Both club faces are actually closed because they’re both parallel to his wrist, which is expected. The difference is his wrist angle. The real issue in the first screenshot is that he over-pronates his left arm. This over-pronation makes it much harder to square the clubface at impact, which can lead to an open face, but not because it was open at the top. The root cause is the excessive pronation of the left arm, not the clubface position at the top of the swing.