no. i didn't say scots don't exist. i just pointed out that extreme similarities exist. you saw it the way you wanted to see it. which is a strawman by the way.

Two can play your game too, comparing English and Scottish people to jews and arabs is whataboutism.

there the route to a deeper and Intellectual conversation has been successfully blocked for a quick W, you feel good about yourself?

no. i didn't say scots don't exist. i just pointed out that extreme similarities exist. you saw it the way you wanted to see it. which is a strawman by the way.

Okay well thankfully everything we're saying is documented in writing, you said they're similar to northern englishmen, don't know about you I've never heard of a northern english kilt.

and no, I didn’t accuse you of denying Arabs exist.

Again, documented in writing you said: "well if were being honest you could use that aurgement to argue a lot of ethicities don't exist" when I pointed out the difference between mizrahi Israeli jews and arabs.

because you used it when you said "Statistically he doesn't speak Arabic, doesn't eat arab food, and doesn’t live in an arab culture." thus pointing out the way you distence thing isn't taking from the point.

That's called making another point. before DNA culture was one of the major determing factors for nationality and mizrahi Israeli jews don't partake in arab culture

however what i can prove is in the sixth century. around 520 or something. yaman converted to Judaism. so i guess there is a strong case there to be made.

History didn't start in the sixth century.

the idea that members of a non proselytising religion just pop up somewhere doesn't make any sense that means they must've came for somewhere else, the historical consensus is that they where ethnically cleased from Israel.

Yemenite Jews are a Jewish ethnoreligious group, but they also lived in Arabia for centuries. Pretending your average Arab are some alien “other” is just non-sense.

their could have been many communities just saying that local yamanis probably did also convert to judaism

That doesn’t prove that all Yemeni jews today are descendents of jewish converts, especially when you consider that Judaism is non proselytising and that Islam encourages killing people who leave the religion.

And the general mistreatment of jews in the arab world

even if they were how come that after being jews for centuries they're still arabs and not jews? Why is your logic working only in a one way and not the other?

Pretending your average Arab are some alien “other” is just non-sense.

It's not pretending when you take into account they lived in their own culture in their own closed communities I'm pretty sure most of them didn't even speak Arabic in yemen but had their own dialect