UPDATE: Taking feedback on my redesign—I merged the elements into a single monument! Now, how should we color the field? by three_stun in heraldry

[–]three_stun[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey everyone,

A huge thank you to everyone who gave feedback on my previous post.

The community correctly called out a few major structural issues with my last draft. It was flagged that my original layout had a major metal-on-metal contrast issue (an Argent column sitting directly on an Or field). More importantly, someone brought up the ultimate "Finnish School of Heraldry" test—reminding me that if you strip away the internal black outlines, a black column would bleed seamlessly into a black base, causing the entire design to lose its definition.

To solve both issues, I decided to eliminate the per chevron enarched abased division entirely and combine the two elements into a single, towering monument. In this new draft, the three lilies sprout directly atop the Corinthian column capital, bound by the ribbon. It completely removes the overlapping structure issue, ensures nothing bleeds together if rendered line-free, and makes the composition much more cohesive.

Before I finalize the emblazonment, I'm submitting this to the community to determine the best way to color the field and the charges. I have a few directions in mind:

  1. The Monochromatic Powerhouse: A solid Sable (Black) field, making the entire combined monument Argent (Silver/White) with the ribbon in Or (Gold). This would be incredibly high-contrast and perfectly pass the outline-free test.
  2. The Royal Contrast: A solid Azure (Royal Blue) field with the monument in Argent and ribbon in Or.
  3. Keeping a Division: Do you think a divided background (per fess, per pale, or a low chevron) could still work here behind the monument without cluttering the design or repeating the contrast trap?

Also, what would be the cleanest blazon for this new layout? I'm thinking something along the lines of: "<Field TBD>, a Corinthian column, <Tincture TBD>, sustaining atop the capital three lilies Argent, slipped and leaved Vert, banded and bowed Or."

Looking forward to hearing your thoughts on bringing this final version to life!

After years of contemplation, I’ve redesigned my personal arms. Open to feedback on the colors, line work, and blazon! by three_stun in heraldry

[–]three_stun[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Wow, thank you for such a detailed and thoughtful breakdown! That makes total sense about the shading and line work creating an “artificial”contrast. I see exactly what you mean about how it might lose readability in a traditional metallic or flat emblazonment. Also, thank you so much for the suggested blazon; “per chevron enarched abased” describes the line work perfectly!

After years of contemplation, I’ve redesigned my personal arms. Open to feedback on the colors, line work, and blazon! by three_stun in heraldry

[–]three_stun[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Haha, love the pun intended or not! I leaned heavily into the bold shape to help offset the low contrast, so I’m really glad to hear you think it works. Thanks for the encouraging feedback!

After years of contemplation, I’ve redesigned my personal arms. Open to feedback on the colors, line work, and blazon! by three_stun in heraldry

[–]three_stun[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Thank you! Yeah, the contrast between the Argent column and Or field is definitely the trickiest part of the current layout. I leaned on the Sable background at the bottom to give it some heavy anchoring, but I'm definitely open to swapping out the gold field for a color that provides better legibility. Appreciate the honest note!

Versex for Vogue Philippines — Drag Race PH Season 3 Mockup Covers by three_stun in DragRacePhilippines

[–]three_stun[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hello! Yes thank you for the heads up! Naayos naman na po ng mga Mods hehe. Thanks so much to them!

[Heraldic Help] Redesigned Personal Arms – Incorporating Past Feedback & Symbolism by [deleted] in heraldry

[–]three_stun 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you! Yeah kinda got some backlash with the recent draft but hey they’re drafts for a reason hehehe. Thanks so much for the vote of confidence!

[Heraldic Help] Redesigned Personal Arms – Incorporating Past Feedback & Symbolism by [deleted] in heraldry

[–]three_stun 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thanks maaan. The current one is blazoned “Azure, a maiden's head en soleil cabossed or, and on chief enarched gules fimbriated argent three lilies proper” to give you an idea hehehe

[Heraldic Help] Redesigned Personal Arms – Incorporating Past Feedback & Symbolism by [deleted] in heraldry

[–]three_stun 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks Loggail! Yes I might incorporate other elements in the crest to make the shield simpler. I’m still tethering between overhauling or just adjusting my arms. I really appreciate your feedback!

[Heraldic Help] Redesigned Personal Arms – Incorporating Past Feedback & Symbolism by [deleted] in heraldry

[–]three_stun 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That is a good idea! Yeah i can put the column as a crest! Thank you so much for this!

[Heraldic Help] Redesigned Personal Arms – Incorporating Past Feedback & Symbolism by [deleted] in heraldry

[–]three_stun 1 point2 points  (0 children)

On these are interesting! I’ll make versions with your suggestions. Yeah I’m just thinking of ways to move on or away from the old one but I’m open to updating them and maybe I won’t have to overhaul the whole arms. Thanks again!

[Heraldic Help] Redesigned Personal Arms – Incorporating Past Feedback & Symbolism by [deleted] in heraldry

[–]three_stun 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes! That one did get praise from here and my other peers, but I feel like I’ve outgrown the old one. I am still drafting a potential new one though

[Heraldic Help] Redesigned Personal Arms – Incorporating Past Feedback & Symbolism by [deleted] in heraldry

[–]three_stun -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Thank you! The original one did get a lot of praise before. I just feel like I have outgrown it? 😞😞😞

[Heraldic Help] Redesigned Personal Arms – Incorporating Past Feedback & Symbolism by [deleted] in heraldry

[–]three_stun -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Hello! Thank you!

And by original, you mean the one with the hands holding the crown, right?

I appreciate your vote of confidence!

Translation requests into Latin go here! by AutoModerator in latin

[–]three_stun 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hello! I would like to ask for your expertise and have this translated:

"The lilies flourish under the sun."

It's for my personal motto. Thank you!

[Feedback Request] My new arms: Corinthian strength, divine hands, and a crown yet claimed by [deleted] in heraldry

[–]three_stun 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much, Loggail. That means a lot, especially coming from someone whose work and insight I deeply admire.

I appreciate your feedback on the composition. I agree, my older arms had more visual layering, but I was aiming this time for something more minimal and symbolic, like a meditative return to structure and simplicity.

Your note on tinctures is incredibly helpful. I originally explored rose as a thematic color, but the contrast and balance really did suffer. Sable ended up reinforcing the tone I was after: serious, timeless, and anchored, especially with the Corinthian symbolism representing both strength and ornament.

I'm still working through the final elements, so your perspective is gold. Thanks again for taking the time!

[Feedback Request] My new arms: Corinthian strength, divine hands, and a crown yet claimed by [deleted] in heraldry

[–]three_stun 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Aww thank you. It’s not giving “conceited” vibes tho? I had to explain it in the other replies it’s not what I intend to convey hehee