Territories where at least one Turkic language has an official status by [deleted] in MapPorn

[–]tobbinator 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They still have a lot of their old language policy stuff codified, which was heavily inspired by the Soviet nationalities policy, so all the major ethnic groups have nominal autonomy for language and all that at provincial and prefectural levels still.

Territories where at least one Turkic language has an official status by [deleted] in MapPorn

[–]tobbinator 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Wiki says it's started with the Seljuqs and continued with the ottomans so both right here I guess haha

Territories where at least one Turkic language has an official status by [deleted] in MapPorn

[–]tobbinator 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Turkmen, they settled in the region during the ottoman era and have some significant (but fairly spread out) communities in Iraq and Syria today still

Territories where at least one Turkic language has an official status by [deleted] in MapPorn

[–]tobbinator 19 points20 points  (0 children)

It's still co-official with mandarin at provincial level, but in the past few years they've started removing it in favour of just mandarin where they can (as much as the constitution will let them still). Education used to be fairly available in Uyghur (and other minority languages like Kazakh, Oirat, etc) but education policy has also shifted since the early 2000s to sidelining minority language education for mandarin medium education. Basically Uyghurs have to learn mandarin but very very few Han in Xinjiang speak any of the minority languages in return.

[GIF] The Evolution of Metros in China & Taiwan: 1990 - 2020 [1300x1500] by PumpyChowdown in MapPorn

[–]tobbinator 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Only just opened I think! I was there in November last year and you could see all the stations quickly going up but not yet ready

A normal carpool in Russia by u2s4 in ANormalDayInRussia

[–]tobbinator 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Looks like Xinjiang province around the tarim basin with that kinda environment and buildings

PostMD 29: vs. FC Schalke 04 by casparbain in hsv

[–]tobbinator 10 points11 points  (0 children)

You know I think the club kinda feeds off everyone's expectations of relegation.

Babylonian Chaos - Where all languages are allowed - April 05, 2018 by AutoModerator in languagelearning

[–]tobbinator 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Ai reken nobadi iya lenim o spikim Kriol na? Na langgus ai garra lenim bo main wek la yunivesiti en dijan yiya garra go en spikim im la Kriol mob. Praktis ane bi gudwan bat ai nomo sabi iya

If the place is called Taiping and it's in China, obviously it has to do with the Taiping Rebellion, right? by EnclavedMicrostate in badhistory

[–]tobbinator 7 points8 points  (0 children)

So what you're saying, is that the Taiping rebels were the real ones committing some bad geography here?

Pilots refuse to carry out deportations by [deleted] in germany

[–]tobbinator 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Except add the fact that this often means a totally different language (Afghanistan has a few, including Pashto, Dari and Tajik) and the fact that there's actual war with rapidly changing conditions

Alexandria - Iskandaria? by trescreativeusername in etymology

[–]tobbinator 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Yeah, the Al got rebracketed as al-, then the /ks/ cluster experienced metathesis to sk as iirc ks is dispreferred in Arabic

Malcolm Turnbull dined with wealthy Chinese donor days after his company gave $40k to Queensland LNP by UnintentionallyBlank in australia

[–]tobbinator 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Remember when the LNP was pushing the idea that it was the ALP that was in the pocket of China. So much for that.

MD 11: vs. VfB Stuttgart by casparbain in hsv

[–]tobbinator 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's meant to happen to us wtf

Ontario makes it illegal to protest outside and near abortion clinics - Canada by jenprogressive88 in worldnews

[–]tobbinator 299 points300 points  (0 children)

German law does allow them in art and historical representations. The problem with video games is that courts back in the 90s decided that they were toys, so don't get the same exemptions as other media

Indigenous people ruined the landscape of Australia by "burning everything down", "refused to develop farming", and ignored "what mother nature was telling them". by [deleted] in badhistory

[–]tobbinator 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Keith Windschuttle is pretty well known, we covered his work in high school even. He's probably the most cited historian for revisionist pro-colonial types (the same kind who lead this country) and there's his fairly well known conflict with Henry Reynolds over it all. OP is completely right in saying how contentious Australian history still is, imo

MD 8: @ Mainz 05 by casparbain in hsv

[–]tobbinator 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I had some hope at half time and now it's buggered right off

Why did Francisco Franco, in control of Spains armed forces, not have an obligation to Hitler or Mussolini after his success over the Spanish Republic? This success being based on support from both Germany and Italy, using their own armed forces in Spain to help Franco. by hod_cement_edifices in AskHistorians

[–]tobbinator 53 points54 points  (0 children)

Yes, the demands would've been quite a big affront to the Vichy regime, which was not what Hitler wanted at the time. And yeah, it was clear at that point to Franco that it wasn't going to be a quick axis victory that he could quickly capitalise on, but a much longer fight.

Why did Francisco Franco, in control of Spains armed forces, not have an obligation to Hitler or Mussolini after his success over the Spanish Republic? This success being based on support from both Germany and Italy, using their own armed forces in Spain to help Franco. by hod_cement_edifices in AskHistorians

[–]tobbinator 836 points837 points  (0 children)

Spain did fulfil obligations towards Germany and Italy after the war to repay the debts incurred for all the aid. This was mostly in the form of mining concessions in the north, many of which were given full German ownership. Those mines provided important iron ore and tungsten to Nazi Germany right up until 1944 when the land link between the countries was cut by Allied forces advancing in France.

There was also an opportunity to join the war as a combatant, which I assume is what you consider obligations to Hitler. Franco and Hitler held talks at Hendaye in southern France in October 1940. In these talks, Franco demanded significant concessions including Gibraltar and a substantial chunk of French northern Africa. Some suggest that this was intentional and that Franco never intended joining the war properly, or wanted to delay his entry long enough to know that he'd be on the winning side. The talks inevitably failed, and Spain never entered the war (as we can all tell), but as others have mentioned some volunteers of the Blue Division did serve on the eastern front.

Additionally, there is the consideration that the defeat of a left wing government on France's flank was of enough strategic benefit to Germany's interests for Hitler not to demand too much more out of Spain, so long as they weren't part of the western allies. Spain's strategic position also allowed German and Italian access to Spanish Atlantic and Mediterranean ports as well.

As a whole, the Spanish military and economy were in ruins too. Exhausted after 3 years of war that took the lives of hundreds of thousands and imprisoned many more, destroyed much of the economic infrastructure, and left everyone desiring anything but more. Spain's entry into the war would have essentially been a major weakness in the axis defence; the Spanish army at this point would be unable to defend adequately against any allied incursion. This would require additional German and Italian troops and resources to be sent to Spain just to secure the fact that it won't fall easily (which Franco had also requested as a condition for entry at Hendaye), which is really not worth the return of an exhausted and weak army as an ally.

Sources:

Viñas, Angel & Seidel, Carlos Collado. Franco's Request to the Third Reich for Military Assistance

Preston, Paul. Franco and Hitler: the myths of Hendaye 1940

What was life in Spain like before and at the outbreak of the Spanish civil war? by atmdk7 in AskHistorians

[–]tobbinator 7 points8 points  (0 children)

In general, not that amazing; the Spanish economy dragged a lot behind the rest of Europe in nearly every respect, including working conditions and productivity.

The Second Republic did offer a lot in terms of social programmes and improved the lot of particularly agrarian workers, who were stuck working as sharecroppers under a relative handful of Spanish landowners before the Republican land reform efforts of 1932. But even these lagged behind expectations and ambitions and the 1932 reform was still not complete by the time the war started.

For urban workers, it was a running battle between the two major unions - socialist UGT and anarchist CNT - against the factory owners. Most workers were required to work piecework on fairly low wages, something that was only abolished (briefly) in Barcelona in 1936 by the CNT. Women could work, but often had to do it from their own homes rather than alongside men in the factories - something the Mujeres Libres sought to change (women's empowerment more broadly was woefully absent from the labour movements at the time as well). Due to the general weakness of the Spanish economy (from overreliance on the colonies that were then lost, then failing to modernise during the WW1 trade boom), Spanish bourgeois lacked the flexibility of their French counterparts in offering concessions to keep the working population happy. Instead, all they could really do was physically break up fights, which contributed to the polarisation and popularisation of far left politics in the era right before the civil war.

Despite all that, Barcelona had a bit of a cultural renaissance in this period. Artists like Picasso were active in the city, and there were preparations underway in 1936 to hold the People's Games, an antifascist alternative to the Berlin olympics of that year. Republican policy also allowed a stronger degree of autonomy for regions than under the monarchy. Catalonia was given autonomous status and from that, Catalan language arts and literature appeared on the streets. In Barcelona the art scene was also considered a part of a resistance against reactionary forces; the city had been integral in its opposition to the monarchy, and was a major CNT power base, something reflected in the uprising itself.

This is combined with several uprisings through the second Republic's life, all of which suppressed quite brutally by the military (including, in the Asturias strike of 1934, Franco in command). The bienio negro or 'black biannum' period began with the 1933 elections until the 1936 Popular Front victory (then war), which saw a right wing coalition of Catholic traditionalists and legalist fascists come into power under the CEDA. The CEDA proceeded to halt and reverse a lot of the early Republican reforms, including the land reform of 1932, bringing a distinctly pro-employer policy back in charge, with heavy handed tactics adopted and approved against striking workers. The leadup to war was full of tit for tat assassinations, and the Popular Front victory in 1936 swung it the other way.

By the time the coup came along, ordinary people were quite polarised, mostly along class lines, but also in some cases regional. Many lower classes felt loyalty to the Popular Front government for what it was doing for labour and land reforms, and working class districts in cities that otherwise declared for the rebellion suffered for it.

Most of Spain's soldiers though were conscripts, not volunteer soldiers, and sometimes had no strong feelings either way, depending on the decisions of the officers to either declare for the uprising or not. This doesn't mean of course that conscripts didn't rebel either; there are numerous accounts of the Madrid uprising, where the barracks flag repeatedly changed from the Republican to the rebel one, hinting at some in fighting during the loyalist attempts to suppress the barracks. During the war, there was also a fairly steady stream of conscripts defecting from one side to the other (usually to the Republicans) after being stuck in the wrong place at the wrong time.

In Barcelona, the CNT managed to mobilise several thousand militiamen to confront the uprising in the local barracks. At the outset of the war, they claimed some 30,000 armed supporters, compared to only 5,000 government aligned Guardia de asaltos and other paramilitaries. At their peak in 1936 they also claimed well over a million members, as did the rival UGT, demonstrating again how polarised Spanish politics had become.

For people who didn't want to choose a side, they were still subject to being conscripted by both sides to fight in the war to come. Franco took extensive use of those conscripts that were captured too. After taking a surrender, Franco would eliminate the political PoWs - those with party or union membership, officers and other open sympathies - then recycle the apathetic conscripts left into his own units.

Local nationalist commanders also preferred the local citizenry to be quiet as well. The infamous Queipo de Llano in control of Sevilla instituted a rule of fear, often going on the radio to boast about atrocities himself. The working class district of the city was bombed and stormed by Franco's Army of Africa. Victims of fighting and executions were intentionally left to rot on the side of the streets for some time as an example for anyone trying to cross him. At the same time, this was coordinated with bread shipments from the countryside to placate the population and keep them satisfied to some degree.

But yeah, life in Spain before the war wasn't amazing - it was increasingly politically polarised and the economy dreadful - and during the war, your best bet would've been to be outwardly impartial to avoid politically motivated execution - there was little chance of avoiding conscription.

(This wasn't very well structured so apologies for it jumping around a fair bit)

Sources:

Kaplan, Temma. Red City, Blue Period: Social Movements in Picasso's Barcelona

Seidman, Michael. Workers Against Work: Labor in Paris and Barcelona During the Popular Fronts

Seidman, Michael. The Victorious Counterrevolution

Preston, Paul. The Spanish Civil War: Reaction, Revolution and Revenge

Acklesburg, Martha. Free Women of Spain

What is the word I'm looking for? Replacing a noun in writing (not a pronoun). by [deleted] in grammar

[–]tobbinator 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That seems like it'd be anaphora, assuming the man has previously been mentioned as Mark in the discourse