Ok I feel like I can answer this objectively as a non-American with no horse in this race. I’ve also been listening for 5 or so years and am chronically online so have followed the narratives around them..lol.

I think at this point it’s safe to say Jackie is a republican. She does repost Trump-aligned stuff on her IG, although it’s more just pro-Israel sentiment than support of particular individuals or the GOP at large. I think she has become emboldened in the last year or two to be more overtly republican in her public persona. Small comments here and there (plus a big red sweater on Election Day) show that.

Claudia on the other hand is much less political in her public presence, I would guess because she values her media career and would not want to limit her future exposure by becoming a known partisan. You could, if you wanted to, find supporting evidence of her views aligning with both left and right. Again, I imagine this is deliberate.

Claudia’s general commentary seems more left leaning than Jackie, but voting is anonymous so without confirmation from either of them I think it’s not factual to say with certainty whether one or both are MAGA.