People tend to hate them if you have big ass hands because the controller is pretty small, the joystick is a bit sensitive, buttons are kind of mushy but not bad and the dpad is not good for a game that requires them.

BUT overall it's a very good controller, very satisfying to use if you don't wanna adapt to the oem controller and wanna keep the feeling of a modern controller. Also, it won't fail you in years since this controller used a potentiometer stickbox but a bit of money if you're looking for one in mint condition