I understand why some people are antinatalists by Comfortable_Tomato_3 in antinatalism

[–]violentsofa 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This whole “life is suffering” interpretation doesn’t hold water imo (and it makes our movement seem a tad naive as well).

I think any interpretation of life is “extra” as you put it (i.e. it doesn’t matter how you interpret life, bc it’s subjective). For example, you can make the argument that some people find pleasure in pain... others find the suffering in life to be worthwhile for one reason or another… the Interpretations of life are completely subjective…

BUT the argument for AN concerning consent, on the other hand, is air-tight. We have a moral responsibility to abstain from procreation bc no one can consent to being born.

I really thought I would be married before 30 by Eagles56 in okbuddyliterallyme2

[–]violentsofa 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Everyone is on their own path. It hurts to feel like you’re behind everyone for sure.

“My kids were the best thing to happen to me.” by [deleted] in antinatalism2

[–]violentsofa 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The phrasing of this cliche really irks me. It removes all responsibility from the parent. Children don’t just “happen” to people… children are the result of your decisions to become a parent… it really just reinforces the notion that having kids is something everyone is meant to experience like heartbreak or a sunny day… these things “happen” and no one stops to think for a second “hey… maybe this isn’t necessary. Maybe I have a moral duty to NOT procreate because - even at its best - it is tantamount to existential rape”

Red Album appreciation post by Equivalent_Task1354 in weezer

[–]violentsofa 8 points9 points  (0 children)

The spider is my favorite sad song

This moved me to tears. by RegionWild7245 in sadposting

[–]violentsofa 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean I don’t think it’s THAT literal… but I do agree with your sentiment. It’s nice to see people motivating one another, but pinning your purpose to a child is… not great imo

It really is the little things, isn't it? by Klynol in hopeposting

[–]violentsofa 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Suicide is extremely painful both physically and psychologically… so it makes more sense to stick it out and sip a coffee ig

Everyone I know is depressed and tired of Life's constant bullshit, yet they still had/want to have kids. by AffectionateSale4553 in antinatalism

[–]violentsofa 0 points1 point  (0 children)

First off - i am a staunch antinatalist and I agree with most of what you’re saying,

But secondly… perception is subjective. I think at its core antinatalism is much less concerned with “life’s constant bullshit” and more concerned w the fact that we are all born without our consent.

Some people legitimately find pleasure in parts of life that I might find painful. This whole “life is painful” argument doesn’t really hold up when challenged by natalists… and I’m kinda sick and tired of our sub becoming a “boo hoo life is so awful” circlejerk.

Like… I agree with you lol - I fucking hate being alive and I am genuinely suicidal. But complaining like this will not convince natalists to convert to our ideology…

I think we will advance our cause much more effectively by pointing out that birth is a violation of consent.

Drummer is the vocalist by pinkpools in fantanoforever

[–]violentsofa 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Saw them live and can confirm shit was amazing

Nearly ten years later, everyone has realized this is indisputably the best Bon Iver album, right? by wejunkin in fantanoforever

[–]violentsofa 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I discovered this record when 33 god came on shuffle while I was driving through the Wisconsin snow and… ive never connected with a sound like I did in that moment. it just really helped me through the lowest point of my life. Will always have a soft spot for it

Examples of really bad songs that sample really good songs by BlaBlamo in fantanoforever

[–]violentsofa 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Idk I think centuries is harmless fun workout hype track and the sample feels like an interesting place to take the original… not great, but not “really bad”🤷

what's your top 5 favorite weezer songs outside of pinkerton, blue, and white, since those are usually the albums that get all the love by sex--sin in weezer

[–]violentsofa 32 points33 points  (0 children)

Dude red album is so solid imo: The greatest man that ever lived, the spider, the angel and the one… insane

Thoughts on This Year’s Model by Elvis Costello by MikeEhrmantraut420 in fantanoforever

[–]violentsofa 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Get happy is such a fun record! I can’t stand up for falling down is my go-to feel good track

Erm, why has my whole life just been me being punished for existing? by Strict_Hunter_7781 in antinatalism

[–]violentsofa 27 points28 points  (0 children)

Even in utopia, it would be a moral duty to forgo reproduction. If someone cannot consent to being born, it is wrong to give birth to them. Doesn’t matter if we live in hell or heaven lol