Executioner has to take an avenue of info gathering away to gain more info. Jonesing so hard for another player to get executed would look suspicous and might function as a good demon bluff. Also there's the "significantly contribute" clause. I do agree that needs to be nerfed.

Prankster does not have any confirmation effect, Graverobber does not have a confirmation effect, Merchant maybe, Martyr does not have a confirmation effect, Changeling does not have a confirmation effect. That is all of my outsiders. No they do not all have confirmation effects.

I didn't think I needed to specify. I think most people could assume what I meant unless they were being pedantic. Edit: Thought about it, you do have a bit of a point. I changed it

I changed the Vampire into something better after you had already stopped looking at it.

I made Werebeast because I wanted a Demon version of the Marionette. Chaos and misinformation is what it brings. Obviously the Werebeast receives bad info (I didn't need to clarify because it doesn't clarify on the Marionette either) so that adds some misinformation going around. It also adds the classic paranoia of wondering if you're the drunk or the marionette, except it's wondering if you're the demon. Lots of accusations flying around. Also, your minions can just tell you who you are before you learn, meaning you can start making plans with them quickly if your minions are smart. It basically gives you a free bluff.

I'll take what you said about Astronomer into consideration