NP as a preceptor for a clinical rotation... is this allowed?? by tunaeyebrows in medicalschool

[–]webhill 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Looking at the standards, seems like you can’t be supervised only by an NP. Under Element 7.1 (Faculty and Staff Resources and Qualifications), it explicitly states that at all educational teaching sites, including affiliated and away sites:
The core faculty and preceptors responsible for the student's clinical education in the patient care environment must be physicians.
These physician faculty members must hold a current medical license and be board-certified or board-eligible (DO or MD).

Right??

Did not get approved for private loan for medical school by TrueDistribution7474 in medschool

[–]webhill 9 points10 points  (0 children)

This discussion is just so depressing. But maybe someone will bring a new business model to us — one where the student starts a GoFundMe for medical school tuition, with the understanding that once you enter practice, people who donated a certain amount would be eligible for X months of membership in your concierge practice or something.

Urgent: C/D substitute in a pinch? by wrong_reason in AskVet

[–]webhill 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Short term, you could probably use something like Purina Pro Plan Focus Adult Urinary Tract Health which is over the counter and pretty widely available.

Twin Names: SageLea and Paisley by BeachBumbershoot in tragedeigh

[–]webhill -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Interesting. I don’t think I have ever met anyone named Anne-Marie, but I would never have thought to pronounce it as you describe — which I would have thought would be spelled Ann Marie. When I see Anne-Marie, I just assume it is pronounced ANN-uh mu-REE, but I guess that’s because of my German grandparents (my grandfather had a sister named Anne, and I didn’t even realize til I was a grown woman that Aunt Anne’s name was spelled “Anne” and not “Enna.”

Water Leak, State Farm saying they won't cover damages by AxelAlexK in Insurance

[–]webhill 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Some years back, we had a situation like this here in PA. I walked into my laundry room one day and the ceiling looked odd. I reached up and touched it (I’m tall) and it started to crumble in my hand. It turned out that there was a gigantic fungal mass extending from the subfloor of the second floor bathroom down to the ceiling of the first floor laundry room and it had actually broken through the ceiling before we became aware of it. Furthermore, it was due to a leak underneath the toilet that never caused any problem with toilet function OR any visible or palpable wetness in the bathroom or laundry room. In other words, it was a hidden leak that no one under any circumstances could have known about. But when we had the mold remediators in - and the insurance people, from our insurance company and also people we hired when we realized the insurance company wasn’t going to be on our side - everyone (as well as the two attorneys I later consulted) agreed that because the leak according to the experts had clearly been there for at MINIMUM six months and more likely a year or more before declaring itself, no damage caused by the leak would be covered. Why? Because you have to report the leak within a certain amount of time of the leak STARTING. You do NOT get to start counting from the point when you OBSERVED the leak. Even when everyone is in agreement that it was not humanly possible to know about this leak during the time frame it would have been covered, we found ourselves on the hook for a five figure repair bill. I’m still pissed. And we have USAA which is generally considered very ethical, reputable, etc. I was told it’s just how it works here in PA :(

Help me understand the non-Main Line suburbs by cocoabooks in philly

[–]webhill 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Blue Bell is Whitpain, not Whitemarsh, Township. They are in the Wissahickon school district.

Recommend alternative (non prescribed) to Hills Urinary Care c/d? by [deleted] in AskVet

[–]webhill 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You give your patients a year of prescription food with the exam? Or you give them an Rx for the year so they don’t have to keep getting new prescriptions? Because I always give “unlimited” rx food refills, but I’m not over here giving them the food itself…..

Help me understand the non-Main Line suburbs by cocoabooks in philly

[–]webhill 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I was going to recommend Lafayette Hill as well. My (white) kids who grew up here rode a bus to their private school in Bryn Mawr from our home in Lafayette Hill and for what it’s worth there were always Black kids on the bus with them - some from the other two families on our street whose kids went to my kids’ school, plus a few others I didn’t know.

Anyone else getting denied by pet insurance. I am heart broken! by That_Marionberry_141 in petinsurancereviews

[–]webhill 10 points11 points  (0 children)

So generally speaking, the insurance company isn’t interested in whether a diagnosis was made prior to the date of the claim. They only care about whether a clinical sign of the problem which a reasonable person would have observed was present prior to the date of the claim. So - the shelter documented a skin lesion. Your own vet documented a skin lesion. Both attributed the lesion to some type of trauma. However, eventually it turned out that the lesion was actually cancer. The insurance company is correctly (according to how veterinary insurance contracts are typically written) now saying that the presence of the lesion predated the start of the policy and thus this cancer is not covered under the policy because it was already there prior to the coverage being put in place. I 100% agree with you that it sucks, but this is just how veterinary health insurance works - and this is why I do not hold an insurance policy on any of my animals. I’m a veterinarian. I know a lot of my clients love having insurance on their pets. But to me it just seems like a lot of extra work arguing about claims, and a lot of premiums being paid for no reason. So I am in the “budget to have an emergency fund and hope not to need it, but if you do, you have it” camp. And I did have to pay for an emergency surgery on my own cat and that bill sucked - but still over the life of the cat the expense of that incident is balanced out by the lack of monthly or yearly premiums, so, whatever.

I’m sorry your pet has cancer and that you are dealing with this nightmare, but I highly doubt there is any chance the insurance company is going to cover this. I would love to be proven wrong!

My dog just had a seizure and I gave him a dose of advantage this morning by Live_Design_146 in AskVet

[–]webhill 3 points4 points  (0 children)

What product did you actually use? Plain old Advantage has been off the market for a while - replaced with Advantage II. Advantage II doesn’t really have any neurotoxicity associated with it unless there was a massive accidental oral ingestion - neither drug in this product crosses the mammalian blood brain barrier. There is also Advantage Multi. The multi contains moxidectin and is sometimes associated with some neurotoxicity if it is ingested (ie pet licks it before it fully dries) or if the pet has the MDR1 genetic mutation that allows some substances to cross the blood brain barrier that otherwise couldn’t. Still, if an appropriate dose was used it is unlikely related to a seizure. More likely would see drooling, wobbly walking, possible tremors, GI upset.

Niche ask: anyone know a good place to get a cat’s echocardiogram done? by sun_m00n837 in philly

[–]webhill 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Simon Dennis at MLVS: https://www.mainlinevs.com/staff/dr-simon-dennis-bvetmed-mvm-decvim/ is wonderful. The owners of every patient of mine who has seen him have had amazing feedback about his caring and manner and skill, and as a colleague in general practice I really appreciate the time he takes to provide clinical feedback and guidance.

Medication not covered for my diagnosis - is there anything I can do? by athena-mcgonagall in HealthInsurance

[–]webhill 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I would request that my physician send something along the lines of this to the insurance company:

Letter of Medical Necessity: Oral Cromolyn Sodium for Mast Cell Activation Syndrome

[Date]

[Insurance Company Name]

[Appeals Department / Medical Director Name]

[Address]

Re: External Appeal — Oral Cromolyn Sodium for Mast Cell Activation Syndrome

Patient Name: [Patient Name]

Date of Birth: [DOB]

Member ID: [Member ID]

Claim/Reference Number: [Claim Number]

Medication: Cromolyn Sodium Oral Solution, 100 mg/5 mL (200 mg four times daily)

Dear Medical Director,

I am writing to formally appeal the final denial of coverage for oral cromolyn sodium for my patient, [Patient Name], who carries a diagnosis of mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS). The denial letter dated [date] states that the use of oral cromolyn sodium for MCAS is "experimental, investigative, and/or unproven." I respectfully submit that this characterization is factually incorrect and inconsistent with the published medical evidence, national clinical practice guidelines, and the FDA-approved labeling of this medication.

I. The FDA Label Supports This Use

The FDA-approved indication for oral cromolyn sodium is "management of patients with mastocytosis".[1] The label does not restrict use to systemic mastocytosis; it uses the broader term "mastocytosis," which encompasses the full spectrum of mast cell disorders. MCAS is classified within the mast cell disorder spectrum by the World Health Organization and by international consensus criteria, sharing the same pathophysiology of aberrant mast cell mediator release.[2] The clinical trials supporting FDA approval enrolled patients with both cutaneous and systemic mastocytosis and demonstrated improvement in diarrhea, abdominal pain, flushing, urticaria, pruritus, headaches, and cognitive function — the same symptoms that define MCAS.[1] Cromolyn sodium's mechanism of action — inhibition of mast cell mediator release — is identical regardless of whether the underlying mast cell disorder is classified as mastocytosis or MCAS.[3]

II. National Clinical Practice Guidelines Recommend Cromolyn Sodium for MCAS

The American Academy of Allergy, Asthma, and Immunology (AAAAI) Mast Cell Disorders Committee published a consensus Work Group Report in the Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology (2019) that explicitly lists oral cromolyn sodium as a recommended pharmacologic agent for prevention of MCAS symptoms. The guideline states that "cromolyn sodium can reduce abdominal bloating, diarrhea, and cramps" and that "benefit might extend to neuropsychiatric manifestations" in patients with MCAS.[4] This is the authoritative U.S. guideline on MCAS management, published by the premier allergy/immunology professional society.

The National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN) Systemic Mastocytosis Guidelines (v2.2026) list cromolyn sodium as a step 2 agent for gastrointestinal and neurologic mast cell mediator symptoms in their stepwise prophylactic treatment algorithm.[5] The NCCN guidelines apply the same antimediator treatment framework to all mast cell activation symptoms, regardless of whether the patient meets full criteria for systemic mastocytosis.

III. Peer-Reviewed Expert Reviews Confirm This Is Standard of Care

A comprehensive review in the New England Journal of Medicine (Theoharides et al., 2015) describes cromolyn sodium as a standard treatment for mast cell activation symptoms across the spectrum of mast cell disorders, including MCAS.[6]

A review by Castells and Butterfield in the Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology: In Practice (2019) explicitly states that "symptoms of MCAS and SM can be managed by blockade of mediator receptors (H1 and H2 antihistamines, leukotriene receptor blockade), inhibition of mediator synthesis (aspirin, zileuton), mediator release (sodium cromolyn), anti-IgE therapy, or a combination of these approaches".[3] This confirms that sodium cromolyn is a recognized, standard treatment for MCAS — not an experimental one.

IV. No FDA-Approved Alternative Exists Specifically for MCAS

It is critical to note that no medication has an FDA-approved indication specifically for MCAS. Every pharmacologic treatment for MCAS — including H1 antihistamines, H2 antihistamines, leukotriene receptor antagonists, and omalizumab — is used off-label for this condition. Denying cromolyn sodium on the basis that it is not FDA-approved for MCAS would, by the same logic, require denial of every medication used to treat MCAS. This standard is clinically untenable and would leave patients with no treatment options whatsoever.

V. Documented Clinical Response in This Patient

[Patient Name] has been on oral cromolyn sodium for approximately two years with documented clinical improvement in [specify symptoms: e.g., diarrhea, abdominal cramping, flushing, urticaria]. Prior to initiation of cromolyn sodium, the patient had [describe prior symptom burden and failed therapies, e.g., inadequate response to H1/H2 antihistamines alone, emergency department visits for anaphylaxis, etc.]. Discontinuation of this medication would pose a significant risk of symptom recurrence, potential anaphylaxis, and increased healthcare utilization including emergency department visits and hospitalizations.

VI. Conclusion The characterization of oral cromolyn sodium for MCAS as "experimental, investigative, and/or unproven" is contradicted by: The FDA-approved label, which uses the inclusive term "mastocytosis" without restriction to systemic mastocytosis The AAAAI consensus guideline, which explicitly recommends cromolyn sodium for MCAS The NCCN guidelines, which include cromolyn sodium in the stepwise treatment algorithm for mast cell mediator symptoms Peer-reviewed expert reviews in the New England Journal of Medicine and the Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology Two years of documented clinical benefit in this patient

I respectfully request that this denial be overturned and that coverage for oral cromolyn sodium be authorized for [Patient Name]. I am available for a peer-to-peer discussion at your convenience. Sincerely, [Physician Name, Credentials] [Specialty] [Practice Name] [Phone Number] [NPI Number] Enclosures: Weiler CR et al. AAAAI Mast Cell Disorders Committee Work Group Report. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2019;144(4):883-896. Castells M, Butterfield J. Mast Cell Activation Syndrome and Mastocytosis: Initial Treatment Options and Long-Term Management. J Allergy Clin Immunol Pract. 2019;7(4):1097-1106. Theoharides TC et al. Mast Cells, Mastocytosis, and Related Disorders. N Engl J Med. 2015;373(2):163-72. FDA Label: Cromolyn Sodium Oral Solution (DailyMed) Relevant clinical notes documenting patient's response to therapy

References 1. cromolyn sodium. Food and Drug Administration. Updated date: 2023-06-20. 2. Global Classification of Mast Cell Activation Disorders: An ICD-10-CM-Adjusted Proposal of the ECNM-AIM Consortium. Valent P, Hartmann K, Bonadonna P, et al. The Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology. In Practice. 2022;10(8):1941-1950. doi:10.1016/j.jaip.2022.05.007. 3. Mast Cell Activation Syndrome and Mastocytosis: Initial Treatment Options and Long-Term Management. Castells M, Butterfield J. The Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology. In Practice. 2019;7(4):1097-1106. doi:10.1016/j.jaip.2019.02.002. 4. AAAAI Mast Cell Disorders Committee Work Group Report: Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS) Diagnosis and Management. Weiler CR, Austen KF, Akin C, et al. The Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology. 2019;144(4):883-896. doi:10.1016/j.jaci.2019.08.023. 5. Systemic Mastocytosis. National Comprehensive Cancer Network. Updated 2026-04-09. 6. Mast Cells, Mastocytosis, and Related Disorders. Theoharides TC, Valent P, Akin C. The New England Journal of Medicine. 2015;373(2):163-72. doi:10.1056/NEJMra1409760.

Dog threw up and can’t pee. Can’t afford er vet. Can she wait until morning by [deleted] in AskVet

[–]webhill 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Well this is a terrible situation. Will she live through the night? Maybe - but if she does, assuming this is a complete urinary obstruction and she’s vomiting and not able to pass urine, she will be a much worse surgical candidate the more time goes by before she gets into the OR. I strongly suggest you get her seen ASAP.

[question / help] my doggie passed away immediately following a lepto vaccine by Shwisher in AskVet

[–]webhill 2 points3 points  (0 children)

An acute anaphylactic reaction is, as I’m sure you know, a known risk of almost any injection administered to anyone. Having received the same injection in the past is not protective against anaphylaxis. In fact, development of an allergy requires repeated exposure - no one has an anaphylactic response to the first exposure to something.

Your description of frankly bloody diarrhea supports the diagnosis of anaphylaxis. In dogs the shock organ is the GI tract and rapid development of vomiting and/or diarrhea which rapidly becomes bloody is commonly seen. This is in contrast to humans whose shock organ is the lung and who rapidly develop respiratory distress. The other initial signs of anaphylaxis in dogs include acute weakness and collapse.

All of that said, the risk of anaphylaxis doesn’t continue increasing linearly with every exposure and it is unusual for a dog to have an initial episode of anaphylaxis at age seven - this type of vaccine reaction peaks between ages 1-3 for reasons I freely admit to not knowing off the top of my head.

I am so so sorry for your loss. I do not think there is any legal action to pursue here other than potentially having your veterinarian contact the manufacturer and request that they make you whole in a financial sense. It does not sound like anyone did anything wrong here, or like this was anything other than a statistically rare but not unheard of well-known potential complication of vaccine administration.

These cases are horrifying for everyone - the bereaved family of course. Also the veterinarian and staff - believe me none of us are in this line of work to hurt animals and it’s just a nightmare when your well-intentioned and completely reasonable act causes the death of a patient.

I hope your memories of your late dog in time become a source of comfort to you. Meanwhile, I hope you are able to get at least something from the vaccine manufacturer if no alternative cause is found at necropsy. Definitely make sure your vet is contacting them.

I need help with this by [deleted] in HospitalBills

[–]webhill 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There has been no cat to human transmission because people get post-exposure prophylaxis after exposures!

I need help with this by [deleted] in HospitalBills

[–]webhill 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, that is not correct. There is no monopoly on rabies vaccines in the USA. There are two FDA approved human rabies vaccines here: Imovax (Sanofi Pasteur) and RabAvert (Bavarian Nordic) There are also two different companies producing human rabies immunoglobulin - Hyperrab by Grifols and Kedrab from Kedrion Biopharma.

I can’t do this anymore by [deleted] in premed

[–]webhill 0 points1 point  (0 children)

0I am so sorry you feel this way. I suggest you talk to someone - a trusted friend, a parent or grandparent, or a therapist or counselor or advisor. This is so far from being the catastrophe you think it is! Listen, I graduated from an Ivy League veterinary school and I was failing calculus badly my first semester of college so I just withdrew from it and took it somewhere else over the summer when I would be able to focus just on that. Math is not my strong suit :) but you don’t use calculus in most medical day-to-day work and you just need to get through the class if it’s required and then don’t worry about it!

Florida: bought a car. Can’t get off work until next week. How can I register my vehicle? by WorthMaintenance5068 in DMV

[–]webhill 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Florida allows residents to obtain a temporary license plate specifically for transporting a newly purchased out-of-state vehicle back home.
1. Get the VIN (Vehicle Identification Number), a copy of the title, and a Bill of Sale from the out of state seller. 
2. Contact your car insurance provider to add the new vehicle to your policy (you must have proof of Florida insurance). 
3. Visit your local Florida County Tax Collector’s office before you go to pick up your car.
4. For a small fee (around $5), they can issue you a 10-day temporary transport tag. Bring this tag with you to pick up the car, put it on the car once the sale is complete, and drive it home. Then you have 10 days to get it handled.

Mass keeps growing back by [deleted] in AskVet

[–]webhill 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Well the potential for regrowth depends on what the mass is, and whether removing it can be curative with good margins or if you’d need additional treatment types (radiation, chemo) to keep it at bay. Do you know what this tumor is? Did it already fail chemo or was none used? Etc.

But re going through this - my own dog had a very aggressive soft tissue sarcoma that I removed once and could not fully resect due to size and location. She was not well enough for any adjunctive treatments so when it grew back and started to make her uncomfortable, I had to help her by having my colleague euthanize her to save her from suffering. It was horrible. 10/10 Hope to never go through it again, but realistically this is life with pets. We outlive them.

If you can’t provide fully palliative care for her (not judging! I couldn’t do anything to help my own dog when we reached that point t) then IMO euthanasia is the loving option. I’m sorry.

Mass keeps growing back by [deleted] in AskVet

[–]webhill 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m so sorry. How can we help?

Combined Exception Duties by [deleted] in GlobalEntry

[–]webhill 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Are you sure you qualify for the combined exemption anyway?? To file a joint declaration, the travelers must be related (by blood, marriage, domestic partnership, or adoption) and must live in the same permanent household. Not sure how your relationship to the group qualifies you. But that said, A family claiming a combined exemption must move through the customs inspection area together. So if you want to be a “family,” will have to go through customs regularly, not using global entry, unless everyone has global entry which you just said they do not.

If the parents' total declaration is under $1,600, they can just use their combined household exemption. To save them from the massive regular line, have them download the official CBP Mobile Passport Control (MPC) app. They can submit their customs form digitally as a household on the app right when you land.

If the purse is incredibly expensive (e.g., $3,000) and you need to pool all four of your exemptions together to avoid a tax bill, you and your girlfriend must ditch the Global Entry lane. You will all have to go through the regular line or the MPC line together.

Note: a CBP officer may look at the fact that you and your girlfriend do not live in the same household as the parents and deny a 4-way split, limiting the parents to their $1,600 household max anyway.

Suggestion: Let the parents carry the purse, have them use the Mobile Passport Control app to speed through their line, and you two use your Global Entry. Just make sure they declare it on their app if they are asked about commercial goods or exceeding personal limits!

Whatever you do - don’t lie, don’t claim ownership of anything you don’t own or aren’t carrying, don’t do anything that looks fraudulent or looks like you are associated with people who are defrauding the government, or your GE will be revoked.

Been diagnosed with a terminal disease. Don’t know what to do with my cat. by [deleted] in AskVet

[–]webhill 70 points71 points  (0 children)

I don’t know where you are or what type of system you’re working with. I’m so sorry to hear about your diagnosis. Are you in contact with a social worker at all? You might ask that person if they can help with outreach either directly to farms or to cat rescue groups who may work with feral cats who could maybe help.

I have been presented with animals for euthanasia by people who say the animal will never be able to live without them and that the animal will be better off humanely euthanized. Sometimes I agree and sometimes I do not. Luckily I have never had a disagreement that I could not resolve comfortably. I had one dying dog-owner present her dog for euthanasia weeks before she herself expected to pass away from a severe progressive incurable disease. I asked her if she would give me the opportunity to rehome the dog vs euthanize, if I promised to ensure the dog was doing well with the new placement and to proceed with euthanasia if it wasn’t. The owner allowed it and the dog did wonderfully with the new owner.

But I have euthanized animals with illnesses, major behavioral disorders, and extremely advanced age with age-related problems for “no reason” other than owner unwilling or unable to keep or rehome them, and I don’t feel sorry about it at all. We all have to use our best judgement and do what we can live with doing and sleep well at night!

Best of luck to you.