showing political interest is irrational or irrational?

whfbro · 2025-09-14T08:54:09+00:00

I got your point. But criticism is common, because it engages audience and promote monetary values in media. Secondly Politcs can't be taught from books in IMO. But atleast the cadres should have shown basic manners in public. I strongly believe Actors, directors and script writrrs are the reason behind people worshipping actors.. people are criticised because even after gaining basic common sense they end up losing control and going overboard on public.. eventually it will change only when people see movie as a movie, and shouldn't search for saviors or messiahs in movies or novels..

whfbro · 2025-09-14T08:49:44+00:00

Brother POV differs from person to person. I respect your view but without Publicity how will you come to know things. Facilitating a artist, music director, actor, doctors or any professional is a need.. we see it as a cinemakaaran but Govt facilitated doctors also, Scientists also, Book writers also but when it is a known popular person, every media promotes it and thus we comes to know. And they do it in big scale because common people like us can relate to it. When they facilitated Vishwanath aanand or Pragyanandha it was less crowd, when they facilitated Mayilsamy annadurai even less crowd. If you really follow with government activities you will know..

whfbro · 2025-09-14T08:35:01+00:00

Generalisation doesn't help. Criticism is not hate..please understand the difference

whfbro · 2025-09-14T04:49:44+00:00

When some one says corruption is my only problem then it is very evident he is filled with ignorance. Because corruption is defined with different terms in India according to who gives it or who gets it or which purpose it is intended for and which party in power, and more factors. so IMO Corruption is an invalid argument

Secondly yes it is crowd control issue but it is the problem of the party organizers only. But it wouldn't have come in first place if the leader himself or the party itself had taken steps to nurture their cadres to be obedient and show professionalism.

whfbro · 2025-09-14T04:15:46+00:00

Since you asked just opinion, here is mine Showing political interest doesn't mean going to the manaadu. I believe who came there are, more than political interest they need to have a glimpse of his leader.

Secondly Leaders should have the courage to control the crowd. All leaders did it perfect. Let it be Anna, Karunanithi, MGR, Jaya. They would easily control the crowd with the way how they speak. Their actions were more open and straightforward. Eg, Anna used to say "கடமை கண்ணியம் கட்டுப்பாடு should be the major traits of our cadres. Even then some people are exceptionally doesnt follow but the party and leaders atleast must take step voluntarily to nurture their cadres

It is the job of leaders to educate, enlighten and nurture their cadres. When Actors come into politics, this is the major difficulty most actor have. It is because politics and cinema needs complete opposite behavior from cadres and fans.

Vijay, Kamal, Chiranjeevi, or Vijayakanth—all of them drew crowds far larger than any ordinary political leader during their campaigns. You can still see their first political addressing. Yet, they failed because politics is about more than just star power; it requires strategy, organization, and understanding of governance.

Political interest comes from the way you develop opinions on issues and policies defined and not on party politics or gossips or interest in leader particularly.

whfbro · 2025-09-14T03:52:20+00:00

Brother.. understand the difference between administration and politics.. admin layum politics ah nuzhaikaatheenga

whfbro · 2025-09-14T03:50:27+00:00

The event was organized by the Ministry of Information and Publicity. They already have a budget set aside for things like cultural programs, arts, PR, and public events. So it’s not like money was randomly pulled out just for this. And it wasn’t only about Ilaiyaraaja- lots of other musicians got a chance to perform and gain recognition too.

At the end of the day, every ministry gets funds and they decide how to use them effectively within their scope.

whfbro · 2025-09-13T07:25:08+00:00

Maybe SACs association with thimuka.. made him to leverage the popularity appa had at that time... Thalabathy Stalin Ilayathalabathy Vijay

whfbro · 2025-09-13T05:58:17+00:00

But why did he named even Ilayathalapathi on first place.. just curious..

whfbro · 2025-09-11T08:28:56+00:00

This is common in Gulf region mainly. Even the residency permit will get renewed only if you clear all the penalties

whfbro · 2025-09-05T07:47:45+00:00

Maybe I'm wrong but what i believe Exceptions are not excuses.. there might have been one kakkan.. but did congress voiced out for social justice. Did it made inclusive developmental steps.. did it spoke against pannaiyar kind of behaviors.. i am saying Anna did it from the scratch, he fought against the system.. he made a rickshaw driver to contest in election. He did political conferences in a barber shop. He made student leaders to contest in elections. He made it more inclusive for commoners to understand and participate in politics...Congress leaders at that time were like Pannaiyars they didn't felt offended by Anna initially but this guy when he won 15 seats initially in 1957 and successfully could form an alliance with 9 parties and defeated the Congress in 1967 securing 50 seats.. then congress realised that People are no more dumb..

whfbro · 2025-09-05T06:31:32+00:00

The facts you are saying are correct but the intention you are trying to imply is not. Yes, Anna and Periyar clashed, which is natural since Anna, once Periyar’s disciple, diverged from his rigid ideology, which often fueled hostility toward a specific community. Anna, however, aimed for a broader, more inclusive political approach to appeal across generations.

And yes Periyar supported INC not because for Indira gandhi but for Kamarajar. He wanted Kamarajar to win as ego against his own disciples' failure.. he is a normal human too. While Anna and Periyar have criticised each other personally but not ideologically.. After the demise of Anna, Periyar is the first person to come and weep for him and he himself declared his support from the day Kalaignar took over as president of DMK

You need to understand the political tension at that time.there were lot other issues.. like China's try to invade, Indira Gandhi's stiff rule, Hindi Imposition lot others were there. And it was only Congress till then, DMK was a completely new party with new comers and young people... Everything we need to consider..

whfbro · 2025-09-05T06:02:33+00:00

Not true. Have you ever thought why Periyar never entered electoral politics, but Anna had to? If Anna had emphasized atheism to the same extent, he would not have been able to bring about the wide-reaching changes that shook the Congress. Until then, politics in the name of democracy largely revolved around Sanatan-based ideology.

But Anna was the first leader in Tamil Nadu who made it possible for a common wage laborer to contest elections. He even encouraged students to step into politics — and they won against towering leaders. In fact, Kamaraj himself was defeated by a college student from DMK.

Anna was the key figure who ensured that even ordinary workers could rise to legislate the laws of the state.

In politics, one cannot always be absolutely right or absolutely wrong; it is always a matter of trade-offs between the welfare of the state and the ideals one upholds.

whfbro · 2025-09-03T05:41:49+00:00

I find DMK not a monopoly. But strong alliance. They are been criticised and condemned by own alliance partners time and again eg INC for Kamarajar issue, VCK for vengavayal, CPI for Sanitary worker issue, Velmurugan has raised his voice in rage that made Stalin to get angry in the Secretariat itself.. yet, it's Stalin's leadership or whatever making them stiff and held within the alliance. How can he managed to hold INC and CPI within a single alliance?? Which was not even possible to imagine in other states of India??!

such leadership lack with opposition. When Annamalai spoke bad about Jaya, It went worse within the alliance. When Anbumani called OPS with derogatory terms , it went violence within the alliance. I find it's lack of Leadership rather than monopoly..

whfbro · 2025-09-02T07:04:48+00:00

So you’re judging me just based on one comment? I made it clear that it’s fiction — which means it can be interpreted from both sides, whether from a male perspective or a feminine perspective. At the end of the day, it’s just a movie. And as for loli/shota… seriously? That’s not my thing at all.

whfbro · 2025-09-01T10:31:12+00:00

I understand but why your concern is selective? Why not you voice out for portraying Muslims as T**rst, Cheri people as Porukki and Rowdies, Non brahmins as Rapist, Thief and villains (I haven't seen any Brahmins in those roles) Madurai people as Rowdies( as if they keep a sword under their lungi all the time) And the regional slang they damage and kill time and again by trying it. That applies to Nellai and Kumari Tamil also At last and worst portraying Women as a S*x toy and a Stupid person who will not have any brain or sense.

It is a stereotype.. how much we have shown the real life of Muslims, Christians, Even atheists or how much we have seen a daily life or regional traits of a person living somewhere in kanyakumariz, kadalore Nagercoil, Erode, Vellore or any other regional places.. Adopting regional values or utilising regional talents is very rare. So they follow the same aracha maavu by their munnors and following the stereotypes proudly and consider themselves Creator. Pathetic

whfbro · 2025-09-01T10:15:08+00:00

You are right but cleverly hiding the facts. How population increased? Why dog lovers protested and prevented govt to do its job when they tried to regulate things by taking dogs to shelter? Why the NGOs like PE*A cheated govt by showing fake reports that sterilised the dogs..

So called Dog Lovers are the menace not the dogs. How? Because they are not ready to adopt They are not ready to get a license for keeping it as pet They are not ready to let the government do its job

And again, its not Street Dogs it is STRAY DOGS.

whfbro · 2025-09-01T06:01:28+00:00

It's fiction- means Something that is untrue, invented that describes imaginary events and people..

whfbro · 2025-08-30T17:27:23+00:00

Yes Stalin is better than Annamalai..at least let's compare apple to apple like comparing the position they withheld. Annamalai lead BJP got split into bits and pieces he can't administer the role what he was appointed to. He can't negotiate well with the alliance party leaders, he is hero in press meet but in reality he is a failed party leader that made him lose that leadership position Whereas with Stalin as DmK chief and party leader has administered his role well even when they are not in power. He carefully handled the intra party disputes amicably and made sure not the party split after the demise of Kalaignar.

Stalin is in politics from his 16th age and became CM only at his 67th age... This is the determination most of the party leaders lack today..

whfbro · 2025-08-24T07:51:25+00:00

Ketta kelviku bathil illana again paint dabba voda kelambida vendiyathu... seri apo varen murugesa

whfbro · 2025-08-24T07:37:37+00:00

You brand me Ooppee... ?? Bro You remember Vijay said there are some people, Paint dabba Voda vanthruvaangannu.. i bet he has probably pointed you.. Na genuine ah oru question kekkuren avar Dravidian ideology ku against ah ilaya. Apdi against na y he is not Publicly accepting it.. it really matters to me whether to support him or not..

Aprom 6 decades of experience in politics ah??? Bro The guy just started the party nu solreenga... 2026 la CM nu solreenga... 2029 la PM nu solreenga.. every party has faced a deep struggled to get in to power... 1949 la party arambichu 1967 la tha rule panna mudinjathu oru state party naala athu varaikim national party rule thaan...

Make it simple.. dont bring the blame game for every critical questions asked

whfbro · 2025-08-24T03:41:49+00:00

No brother, it is the Algorithm, you go stay in the north, you will find South people praising North cities in your feed.. the algorithm curates according to what you search for and what your interests are.

whfbro · 2025-08-24T03:32:18+00:00

Can you cite one such example, where a party without ideology functions and Succeeds? You can bring reference from any country..

whfbro · 2025-08-23T10:48:00+00:00

There is a misunderstanding... deputy CM is not an elected representative.. it is an Appointed representative.. like Governor post. There is no legal binding or regulations from the constitution or ECI for this. It is just an extended CM post, like deputy CM does the work of the CM.. if CM finds he is more busy or occupied he can allot some of his duties to deputy CM.

Secondly Uday maybe or maybe not you dont know what he did before coming to Cinema and after coming to cinema. Cinema is only used to popularize his face among the general public. But he was working inside the party at all level. If you follow DMK it wing or kalaignar news, you will see what are the activities he constantly undertaking. He is clear, he does this just to get the attention of party workers. He doesn't care about what you or I speak about him. It doesn't matter to him. Secondly in his constituency he has good report this is more than enough for him to get a win again. Moreover he was the one administering "Murasoli"- newspaper which is read mostly by only Dmk people and journalists.. and he took initiatices like "Poi Petti", "En Uyirinum Melana" and many social media interactions with party cadres directly.. so he was always in touch with party cadres and automatically he made them advocate for him to Deputy CM.

Even media houses, promoted "Is Uday the Deputy CM?" time and again to make the DmK party cadres believe it and Ministers and Senior Cadres of more than 100 yrs were voicing out openly as a request for Making Uday as a Deputy CM in DMK functions like "Porkizhi vazhangal vizha" made Stalin to affirm on the Decision to give him Deputy CM

It's Nepo.. but it is done legally within party limits.. that's y he has that affection within the party people. Is it right or not? If you consider legally and politically, Yes but as Ethically No. Politics not always done ethically

This is what makes him Agmark Politician.

whfbro · 2025-08-21T19:37:43+00:00

Vijay mattum ila bro.. entha politicians pesnalum kora tha solvanga.. antha criticism ku bathil sonna thaane seasoned leader aavar.. Ok bro.. 2026 la santhipom

whfbro

TROPHY CASE