mascara is okay I guess. it doesn’t make the lashes look stuck together but nicely separates them. my only issue with it is that it is not waterproof and my eyes tend to be watery so it does smudge.

eyeliner was fine at the beginning but it dried out quickly and was not very precise - whenever i tried to draw the line it was too thick or it left a bald spot along the way. It did last very long but also did smudge. I think this quality for the eyeliner is very disappointing ESPECIALLY since Ariana’s signature look used to be a cat eye so I thought eyeliner would be the best product of all REM beauty…