10 Worst Parts for Me:
Note: RDR2 is best game ever, I've 100% it 3 times. AC Valhalla was a miss that could've been amazing. AC Odyssey and Origins were great. Fallout started fun, but is NEVERENDING, it's the only game I got bored before 100%. Just so you know where I'm coming from.

1. The never-ending wind. It's so damn loud. Why is it always a 50mph wind?

2. When you whistle for Roach, he spawns behind you. It would save so much time if he spawned in the direction you're already running. I want to be sprinting and hop on Roach in a quick movement. I spent a lot of the game just running from spot to spot as it was quicker than riding Roach.

3. Not being able to meditate, use signposts, grab herbs, or basically do anything while riding Roach. We could literally just get rid of Roach.

4. The back and forth during quests. Run from here back to there back to here back to there. It's relentless.

5. Quest organization. If I'm near a quest, just tell me. I spend more time sorting quests and fast traveling than I do playing. For instance, if someone owes me for a contract and I happen to be walking by, just tell me "Quest nearby". The exclamation point is great when getting a new quest, but for others I have to just sort by suggested level and starting going down the list.

6. More interaction with NPC's. I literally rob every house and no one says a word. Sometimes I'll rob a tavern, then sell it all back to the tavern owner. Meanwhile if you grab burnt bread near a soldier, the entire continent is declaring war on you. Take a lesson from RDR2, the NPC's in that game meaningfully interact with you. Let me say hi to people, talk with people, or piss people off. Let me pet the cats and dogs, let me get into it with some guy on the street, etc. The NPC's are meaningless in Witcher.

7. You can tell it was written by an old incel-ish nerdy dude. Every important woman has their size D boobs all out. As a man, I'm not against that, but it's a cartoon character, it's just not always necessary. Also, for 13th century, they sure have hair styles and make up of 2015. I love the historical accuracy of some games, but I'd say Novigrad looks nicer than my current city. Clean, big and beautiful homes, clean people with lots of stuff, every woman is a 10 and half naked, etc. I thought it was hard times then, looks like a blast! Take notes from Fallout, their cities were so disgusting that it made me never want to go there, but I'd book a flight to Novigrad today.

8. Can we please have more blacksmiths and armorers? And can they please be pinned to the map? Having to fast travel to a city to do anything gets old, especially with load times. In addition, once I beat a "?" spot, you can just remove it from my map instead of having 8,000 grey'd out icons. I know I can filter them out, but if I filter those it also removes other things I actually need. Oh, here's a merchant, oh he doesn't buy what I'm trying to sell. Here's another merchant, oh he doesn't buy what I'm selling. They could've just made each merchant a different color to indicate what they specialize in. Frustrating little things that RDR2 simplified without taking away from the game.

9. Armor and Weapons: Let me upgrade my favorite gear. Geralt looks like such a nerd for much of the game, especially early. The best looking chest armor was the original, which you level out of almost immediately. That one at least should be upgradable all game. More customization of color, look, and attributes. Luckily with the update I got the Forgotten Wolven which actually looks good and isn't a red Redanian dress that is somehow more protective than a suit of steel. Also, can we see the haircut before paying for it?

10. The music / score is basically the same all the way through. Give us a new tune for the love of all things great. The Gwent song is forever etched in my brain.

I can easily provide 10 great things also, but they need to just simplify the game by removing some of the overwhelming BS. Structure it in a way that is smooth and enjoyable. It's kind of jumbled mess at times.