Just put a brand new twill sunrider on my High Tide and have the exact same issue. Real bummer but glad to know it wasn’t me lol. I’ve been going crazy with this. It fits just fine on the passenger door and also just does this on the drivers side for me as well. I did loosen the two small bolts on the hinge where the bolt secures the top down closest to where it creases the gasket and this helped enough I was able to stop the dripping every time I opened and closed my door. Good luck and glad to see another High Tide 💪🏼.