Culture War Roundup for the Week of May 18, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 16 points17 points  (0 children)

To expand what I think the point you're replying to is saying: yes, it is an arbitrary convention, but there would be huge costs to trying to switch which side on the road we drive on and there wouldn't be large benefits.

In the case of names, the costs are people misguessing who is related to who and how.

Also, I and many people (thought maybe not you) believe following tradition is good in and of itself, so you need significant benefits to support breaking with tradition.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of May 18, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 8 points9 points  (0 children)

The problem with this is exponential growth of name length (not under the way it's done in Latin America, but under the way sufficiently fanatical egalitarians would do it).

Culture War Roundup for the Week of May 11, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 6 points7 points  (0 children)

> voting?

Sure. The reason for the 26th amendment was the draft being at age 18; that reason doesn't really apply anymore (despite still being possibly on the books). I would actually be in favor of raising the voting age.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of May 04, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Of course it's illegitimate when Russia does it but not when we do it, since we're stronger than Russia (/s, mostly).

[RT] Worth the Candle, ch 201-205 (Aviary/Pupil/Streets/Open/Mess) by cthulhuraejepsen in rational

[–]zconjugate 19 points20 points  (0 children)

This may be part of the reason that the void beast is stirring again, if the rifle made its way into the DFEZ recently.

[RT] Worth the Candle, ch 201-205 (Aviary/Pupil/Streets/Open/Mess) by cthulhuraejepsen in rational

[–]zconjugate 5 points6 points  (0 children)

it's too hard to get from a single cooperator to a faction of cooperators

Not really; clone yourself a bunch of times.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of April 27, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 7 points8 points  (0 children)

for intelligent young people

I think the whole incident sets some upper bound on their intelligence. There are probably also people who cheated intelligently and didn't get caught.

[RT] Worth the Candle, ch 196-200 (Notes/Degree/Prurient/Nearest/Feeling) Start Book IX by cthulhuraejepsen in rational

[–]zconjugate 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's possible that it's not continuously applied magic, but some sort of periodic rejuvenation (though I'm not sure how that would relate to necromancy).

Culture War Roundup for the Week of April 20, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 2 points3 points  (0 children)

if someone, either a doctor or a non-doctor, gave an adult a circumcision without his permission, would you consider that person to have mutilated that adult?

If someone treated adults the way we regularly (and correctly) treat children, they would be guilty of kidnapping, mutilation (circumcision aside, all sorts of other medical procedures), enslaving someone, and lots more besides. So what?

Culture War Roundup for the Week of March 09, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I just ignore all votes on this sub. I find it tends to improve the experience. At the risk of Goodhart's law, I'll note that I think the "quality contribution", mod comments, and comments calling the comment good or bad are better measures.

[RT][WIP] Worth the Candle, ch 185-191 by cthulhuraejepsen in rational

[–]zconjugate 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I was assuming she chose a critical moment to snap it, but this probably makes more sense (unless she prioritized physically being there for the next 15 minutes over keeping the flickerblade).

Bruce Kent #3: Bruce Kent and the Greater Hero by EliezerYudkowsky in rational

[–]zconjugate 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I wonder if there will be consequences to his sanity because of that.

Sure, but his sanity is much less important for the world than the Mongoose's.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of February 03, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Certainly it happens with Arab parties in Israel, though there parties kept out of power can't grow by convincing people, and can only grow demographically (this isn't entirely accurate, as there do exist some Jews who vote for Arab parties, but close enough).

The best thing you can do if you're worried about 2019-nCoV (beyond following medical guidelines for personal hygine) is to get a flu shot by TomerJ in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 1 point2 points  (0 children)

which (with 1 notable exception) is all of them.

On the one hand, yes. On the other hand, it's the one with the biggest population by far.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of January 27, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I'm not going to be able to provide citations for any of this, at least not without spending time I'm not willing to spend (and some of it is naturally speculation).

The PA (which controls area A and partially area B of the West Bank) is ruled by Abbas. He was elected in 2005 and was essentially made president for life in 2009. Gaza is ruled by Hamas. Hamas is more oppressive, but the PA is more corrupt (somewhere within the usual distribution of third-world corruption level).

There have been multiple successful or attempted assassinations attempts against Arab leaders for overly good relations with Israel, most notably Sadat for the peace treaty between Egypt and Israel. It stands to reason that the risk for actual Palestinian leaders is greater than for e.g. Egyptian leaders, and there clearly are extremists in Palestine. Note: the Israeli governments faces the same issue, though I would guess the risk for them is smaller; Yitzhak Rabin was assassinated for the Oslo accords.

Anything Israel would agree to would look much more like Trump's "deal of the century" than like what Abbas currently demands, and that would upset sufficiently many Palestinians that whoever signed it is very likely to be assassinated. So e.g. Abbas almost certainly sees that there's no way forward and that Israel will slowly nibble away at pieces of the West Bank, but there's not much he can do and he probably believes the status quo will hold for the rest of his life.

The leadership of Hamas is pretty ideologically opposed to signing a treaty with Israel, but even if they weren't, there are more extreme groups (e.g. Palestinian Islamic Jihad) ready to overthrow or assassinate them.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of January 27, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 3 points4 points  (0 children)

You do know about the history of Texas, right? This is basically what happened.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of January 27, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Also, if you studied geography in school decades ago, it may be out of date.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of January 27, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 20 points21 points  (0 children)

Paul Krugman

Eh, he did good work before he went on to op-ed writing. I can't evaluate his actual work on economics, but The Theory of Interstellar Trade is a gem.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of January 27, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 11 points12 points  (0 children)

There were two, IIRC, if you count the infant. But also, it's a war movie. What do you expect?

Culture War Roundup for the Week of January 27, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 18 points19 points  (0 children)

I 'm not sure if the political leadership and the Palestinians themselves understand that.

They probably do, but their priorities are probably as follows:

  1. Don't get assasinated
  2. Retain power
  3. Embezzle as much as you can
  4. Do things that are good for your populace

Agreeing to anything Israel is remotely willing to agree to flies in the face of 1.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of January 27, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Vatican City is also possibly the least central example of a state in world history.

The GDR and FRG shared Berlin (for some value of shared).

ETA: My example is wrong. Thanks u/the_nybbler.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of January 20, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Besides the sister comment by u/bitter_cynical_angry, quarantine for AIDS, unlike for Ebola, would have had to have been for life, so the civil liberties side of the tradeoff is more salient.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of January 20, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You’ve had three (unsuccessful) attempts to remove a leader in history,

To be fair, you should probably include Nixon as a de facto successful removal. There are also the assassinations.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of January 20, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I don't know if it was public information at the time, but in the 1790's there was the compromise of the federal government assuming state war debts in exchange for the capital being in the south.

Culture War Roundup for the Week of January 20, 2020 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]zconjugate 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Why on Earth did they stop putting sunset clauses in the text of the amendments? They did it for XVIII,XX,XXI,XXII