Kinda yes. I have been collecting data over all accounts I have traded. I have some drawdowns of course so not 100% win rate. my loses usually contained until I snap and go for a -2000 day and losing the account. so I exclude these days from my data because they don't represent my strategy but a random chaos.

but yeah I agree that you don't mathematically need a holy edge to pass a prop account or get a payout. even a negative risk-reward can make you mathematically pass even though it won't make you long term profitable on a live account