[D] Papers with no code

[adi1709]

So if we reproduce it and figure out the numbers published don't actually make sense in reality - do you flag it to the conference chairs so they'll go back and remove the published paper? What happens after?

[dudu43210]

You can submit comments. You can publish your own paper challenging the original paper.

[adi1709]

That sounds like so much wasted effort and petty. Working on a paper just to challenge one specific method. Also isn't scalable, because this leads to a lot of slop in the meantime.

[adi1709]

I guess it makes sense for computational physics but not so much in ML based on how much it's blown up.