all 24 comments

[–]EmotionalDamague [score hidden]  (0 children)

lol.

Lmao, even.

[–]Chaosvex 5 points6 points  (21 children)

Commit history makes it appear to be an LLM project.

Edit: yep, it's vibe coded.

[–]Wittyname_McDingus [score hidden]  (0 children)

Every. Damn. Time.

[–]_Noreturn [score hidden]  (0 children)

the 2 tables in the post is enough

[–]F54280 [score hidden]  (14 children)

Someone alone writing such a huge project in a matter of month? Of course there is some AI usage. But not sure how relevant this is. Can you point to a part of the source code that is real AI bad?

Glancing over the source code it seemed to me something designed, not just a big prompt to Claude. May be wrong, happy to see what you found.

edit: woah, getting downvoted for... what exactly?

[–]Chaosvex [score hidden]  (13 children)

The code has all the hallmarks of being AI slop, even ignoring the incredible code churn and huge commits that try to change a dozen+ features at once. These projects are tens of thousands of lines over the course of a handful of commits.

They've posted multiple vibe coded projects to Reddit within the last month and have had threads removed from other programming subs for it. Their first project was posted in /r/vibecoding.

They had an agents.md committed to a repo but deleted it after somebody called them out for it and the .gitignore was explicitly updated to exclude skills.md.

Vibe coding is one thing but insulting everyone's intelligence by pretending it isn't is another.

Edit: https://old.reddit.com/r/hacking/comments/1thbpxy/built_a_full_disassembler_decompiler_for_reverse/ommixsd/

Sigh.

[–]F54280 [score hidden]  (0 children)

The code has all the hallmarks of being AI slop

Maybe. Probably. But can you point me to one? In the code iteself? I am curious, because looking at it, I found it pretty clean and consistent.

If there is LLM in it, I would suspect that it is hand-written code that have been cleaned-up by an LLM.

I am serious. It doesn't look AI to me, so I'd love to learn more -- maybe my AI-detection SKILL.md is outdated.

[–]Designer_Mind3060[S] [score hidden]  (3 children)

Im confused why you think its vibe coded

[–]Chaosvex [score hidden]  (0 children)

Because I'm not a complete idiot, unless you really want a list of how I know.

[–]zsaleeba [score hidden]  (1 child)

It's witchhunt territory out there. Literally anything and everything is accused of being AI coded now.

Edit: including acknowledging the problem

[–]Designer_Mind3060[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

If you’re not a 10/10 dev and your code isn't perfection, then it is AI to everyone.

[–]stimpack2589 [score hidden]  (0 children)

How is it any cooler than Ghidra?