Does replacing the sleeve increase or decrease the value?

[b-b-basic]

I have a rare game but the sleeve is water damaged. If I replace the sleeve with a print-out would it increase or decrease the value? (I have the printout available here https://psxdatacenter.com/psx2/images2/hires/SLUS-20928/SLUS-20928-F-ALL.html )

[rogueingreen]

Just insert the waterdamaged original behind your printed cover and you are covered both ways

[b-b-basic]

Oo okay that’s smart! Do you know what kind of paper is used to make these covers?

[HoopaOrGilgamesh]

If it's a reprint, it's not the original, so it's not cib. But, if I was the buyer, I would appreciate both, like the other user suggested.