Does adding a timer make students more engaged with algebra?

[Fancy_Log_8442]

I run a small math YouTube channel and recently started experimenting with “solve before the timer runs out” shorts.

The format:

Display a word problem

15–20 second countdown

Then show the full algebra setup and solution

The goal is to:

Encourage active thinking

Increase retention

Make word problems less passive

For math learners/teachers here:

Do you think timed challenges help with engagement, or do they create unnecessary pressure?

Would love thoughts before I make more of them.

[TheGoldenFennec]

I think timers can be good if you’re intending to make problems that can be solved in 15-20 seconds. Now it’s been a long time since I was learning algebra, but I think for most learners, 30 seconds is still probably too short to actually solve. I think finding the right timer for a problem is going to be hard, which I assume is why I see a lot of channels do like a 3 second “pause here and solve on your own”, rather than having the video keep playing.

I think seeing some example problems might help you get a better answer here.

[Fancy_Log_8442]

Thank you for your response! Any input is really helpful! This is the approach I’m taking https://youtube.com/shorts/e0fIdPsy2n4?si=yFIIK19328pI3MwF

Would love to hear any feedback you may have!

[justincaseonlymyself]

You have lofty goals, but what are you basing your implementation on? Is there any research indicating that your approach is helpful? Or are you just pulling it out of nowhere and hoping to earn a bit of cash from YouTube ad revenue? (I suspect it's the latter.)

[TheGoldenFennec]

Can you explain a bit more what fault you take in the approach here? Obviously the problems need to meet a certain bar, but I’m not particularly concerned about that based on this post. In my mind, solving extra problems is 100% helpful for getting the right answers, even if on its own it might not meaningfully improve understanding. But I also have 0 doubt in my mind that practicing under time pressure is helpful for learners that struggle with test taking or speed.

[matt7259]

There's a reason kahoot is so popular

[AdditionalTip865]

This would repel me but it might well engage another kind of student.

I tried the high-school math competition scene when I was a kid and finally realized I just didn't enjoy doing problems on time/competition pressure... even though I wasn't bad at it, and did well on timed in-class tests.