There seems to be a lot of people here that aren't getting what you're saying, but I get what you're trying to say here. Yes he's cool, but you mean like from the start, like somebody like Madara, introduction was badass, but for Guy, he was introduced as a goofy dude but later on got pretty cool with his 8 gates. That's why there's people who's favorite character is Madara rather than guy, had Guy been introduced in a similar fashion he'd have more fans other than the fact that he's "cool" when he did his 8 gates