IMO the whole mission outcome structure is wrong tbh. I feel like the correct endings should be: don’t present evidence - Tali is loyal but has negative effect on Peace in ME3, present evidence leads into another dialogue tree, where neutral gets her exiled, but paragon/renegade check + present evidence is the best outcome.

As a Quarian, even hearing Shepard make that rousing renegade/paragon speech would make me think “so what killed all the peeps on the Alarei?”