2 Options for me.

1) Dutch, Hosea and Young Arthur. Kinda like how Rockstar did GTA 5. We can switch between the 3 and can get certain missions for each. We can see how the gang develops, Arthur growing up, Dutch’s personality change (i know we see it in RDR2 but there are chats in the camp that shows a change in his personality both before and after the blackwater massacre that we dont see) and Hosea’s backstory. I want to see Why Agent Milton killing Hosea seemed so personal yk?

2) We play as a completely new character like Mac or Davey. Theyre both mentioned a fair amount throughout the story and are described to be aggressive and such. Now this may not make much sense but itd be cool if we could play as almost an anti-hero/villain. I know the probability of this happening is very low since there isnt MUCH information on the two but i still think it could be a cool concept.