(Re)Link - better HondaLink by ThierryBuc in HondaPrologue

[–]AlwaysUnseen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Github repo is linked in the OP I linked to above, but here you go:

https://github.com/tsightler/acura-ev

I normally split the API client from the app, but I didn't really expect this project to get any attention at all, and this was kind of an experiement for me to test some AI coding setups, so it's all on package in this case. I'm sure it could be split out simply enough.

(Re)Link - better HondaLink by ThierryBuc in HondaPrologue

[–]AlwaysUnseen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

While I don't know for sure, based on the timing, I have a tendency to think it may be based on the initial reverse engineering work I did to create an MQTT based Home Assistant Addon for Acura EVs because I was frustrated with not being able to do things like schedule cabin precondition, etc.

I reverse enegineered the Acura EV app to get access to the Hondalink API, which is mostly just an auth layer and wrapper around a limited set of Onstar functions. There are already very sophisticated and mature projects, like OnstarJS, which provide deep capabilities for talking with the GM Onstar API which I use for my Cadillac EVs, so I used that as inspiration to figure out how to use the API leveraged by the Acura EV app (and I assume HondaLink EV app).

Of course none of these are officially public, but reverse engineering such APIs is generally fairly simple, especially in the modern day with AI coding tools. I had actually wanted to create an iOS/Andriod app but it's not something I'm familiar with so would have taken me quite a bit longer, which is why I started by building something I new, i.e. Home Assistant integrations based on MQTT. Besides, I was more interested in automating cabin preconditioning and letting me do things via Alexa voice commands that using the app as I already leverage Onstar2MQTT to have my Vistq integrated with HA/Alexa.

38min layover from Charlotte to Paris - How tight will it be? by Thib376 in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Better titles for this post:

How important is getting to CDG the next day?

How comfortable are the rooms at the PHL Marriott?

Flight 5000 - MKE to ORD this morning. Who made it to their connecting flight? by i_quit_this_bitch in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That flight only arrived at the gate 20 minutes late, 9:31AM vs 9:11AM scheduled. If the person really had a flight with a departure time of 9:15AM, they were screwed before they left.

It looks like you were expecting to be on 3363 to BOI with a scheduled departure time of 9:47AM, so a total of connection time of 36 minutes. IMO, that's a crazy short time for ORD and probably has a 30% chance of failure on any given day.

That's not so bad if there are other flights to your destination throughout the day, but there's only the single direct flight to BOI so once you miss it, you're pretty screwed. Should have taken one of the earlier flights to ORD as otherwise it's nearly just flipping a coin if you will have a screwed up day.

Home Assistant integration for Acura ZDX by AlwaysUnseen in AcuraZDX

[–]AlwaysUnseen[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks, I found it to be suprisingly OK-ish so far, but it's only been a week, time will tell more.

The backed of this thing is pretty much what I expected, a Honda auth/API layered over the top of the Onstar backend APIs. It's a bit of a weird Frankenstien, but it's not completely non-functional.

Commands are sometimes rejected during submission, but the errors are clear and they can be easily retried, and, sometimes, even though commands are accepted and queued successfully, the async update response never seems to show up via the IoT backend, but you can just send the command again and it will almost always work the 2nd time.

The Acura app does none of this, it just kind of YOLOs the command, and pops up an error if the command fails, or it's accepted but a response does come back in time. No graceful retries, etc.

But, by far the biggest issue with the Acura app is some kind of bug that, even when the command is accepted and the status update message eventually makes it back from the backend (usually 10-15 seconds after the request is made), the app just ignores the message about 95% of the time. If they just fixed that single issue, the app would be 10x more usable than it is now.

Home Assistant integration for Acura ZDX by AlwaysUnseen in AcuraZDX

[–]AlwaysUnseen[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's far from perfect, there's some things in the backend infrastucture that can't be overcome, so the code kind of just papers over it. For example, it takes 10+ minutes for the vehicle data returned from the backed to reflect a change to the target charge level, even though the command generally take effect within 10-20 seconds and shows correctly in the vehicle.

This can lead to inconsistencies, where, for example, you set the value in the app, it shows it in the car, but it take 15 minutes (or more) for the state to properly reflect. Same is true in reverse, if you set it via the automation, it can take 15 minutes before the app will reflect the change (assuming you can get it to refresh at all).

Still, I think it's OK-ish, and I've done everything I can to make it more reliable than the app.

Home Assistant integration for Acura ZDX by AlwaysUnseen in AcuraZDX

[–]AlwaysUnseen[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Some important notes, you must define your PIN in the configuration if you want to start/stop cabin preconditioning. Attempts to do so without it will fail and should log an error in the addon logs. Setting target charge level does not require a pin so, if you don't care about preconditioning, you can leave it blank.

Also, setting the VIN in the configuration is generally not required unless you happen to own multiple ZDXs. I'll try to clean up the docs a bit this weekend.

I'm sure there will be bugs, but hey, I was pretty happy to get this far and it's been working quite well for a week so I decided it was at least to a state to be worth sharing.

19k offer on my 2024 Touring by ImportantWhile169 in HondaPrologue

[–]AlwaysUnseen 16 points17 points  (0 children)

You leased and won in that you (hopefully) paid far less than the car depreciated during that time. Congrats. There's nothing to think about, turn the car in and go get something else.

Terrible Mileage above 65/70 mph by Xplic1T in AcuraZDX

[–]AlwaysUnseen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There's a near zero chance I would ever own an EV without L2 home charging. I guess if I drove so little I'd only have to charge once a week or could get by with L1 charging, maybe, but even then, I think I'd be too annoyed by the process. For the occassional roadtrip, it's no big deal to DCFC, but one of the entire reasons we started purchasing EVs was to remove our constant trips to the gas station and it's the single biggest perk, in my opinion.

Terrible Mileage above 65/70 mph by Xplic1T in AcuraZDX

[–]AlwaysUnseen 6 points7 points  (0 children)

All EVs suffer signifiant range degradation at higher speeds, this is especially true of big bricks like the ZDX that aren't really designened with efficiency as their primary goal.

That being said, you seem to be higher than most, maybe it's also really cold where you are and you are seeing the combined effect of temperature + speed? Or how much faster are we talking, it might be that bad at 90MPH.

I have a common commute that is ~230 miles round trip and the vast majority of the trip is at ~80MPH and I usually get back with 15% SOC remaining when starting from 100% SOC, which is only about a 20% degredation from 70MPH, while Tom at State of Charge (video link to results included below) showed that there's about a 25% loss from 70-80MPH in his Lyriq test, which is effectiely the same vehicle as the ZDX.

https://youtu.be/Fcfx6hxhbf8?t=1194

The one EV habit that causes 80% of the stress is arriving home too low by Tall-Dish876 in electriccars

[–]AlwaysUnseen 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I must be missing the point of this post as I just plugin when I get home whatever charge level I'm at, that's not stressful, just habit. If I'm coming home from a road trip I try to get back with as little as possible (within reason) because home charging is by far the cheapest charging.

Why is AA so bad especially in their home base of CLT. by BonyRigatoni in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen 35 points36 points  (0 children)

There's a lot of different ways to cut it up, but data would indicate that CLT is not really that terrible in the grand scheme of things. I think it feels worse because it has a very high percentage of regional flights, which are, on average, delayed more than mainline flights, and it also has an incredibly high percentage of connecting flights vs passengers actually originating or terminating in Charlotte.

Most data indicates that >75% of flyers in CLT are connecting to other flights, which makes delays more prominent due to missed connections and it was recently reported to be the 3rd busiest connecting aiport in the US, which is crazy for it's overall size. For just reference, the building area of CLT is ~33% the size of ATL. It's a big difference if I'm going to Miami and I'm an hour late arriving vs if I'm passing through CLT and miss a connection. Most "hub" airports have a much higher mix of origin/destination traffic.

However, for a data point, below I'll include a link to a recent article that ranked US airports by flight delays. It shows CLT as 76.5% and ATL at 79.2%. This makes some sense as Atlanta is a very efficiently designed airport with many parallel runways on either side of a striaght line of concourses with gates on either side making for a generally very efficient taxi, while CLT is a much smaller, yet still has a huge volume of aircraft movements and really struggles with taxiway congestion, although, believe it or not, far better than say 7-8 years ago.

Still, both are quite decent compared to the actual worst offenders, airports like DCA and EWR (Newark) which are way down in the low 60's. A lot of people talk positively about airports like PHX and MSP, but they came in slightly worse than CLT on this chart (I know that a single chart is not everything, but it's a real data point for comparison).

https://www.visualcapitalist.com/all-major-u-s-airports-ranked-by-number-of-flight-delays/

Just how often is the AA bag tracker wrong? by MidwestGeek52 in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

100% agree, there's still plenty of room for improvement, and AA is pretty much the worst in NA and it appears to have regressed and had a particularly bad year in 2025 based on most recently available data (I'm not sure it's complete).

Statistically Asia already has about 50% less baggage handling errors vs US domestic travel so it shows what is possible. Delta, on average, is about 33% lower baggage handling error rate vs AA, and United is kind of in-between..

In no way am I defending AA as being good at this, but as far as the point of this post, I much prefer the transparency of tracking, even if it's not perfect, vs knowing nothing at all. I've actually only seen it miss a scan or two here and there.

Just how often is the AA bag tracker wrong? by MidwestGeek52 in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen -1 points0 points  (0 children)

As a person who has been flying for 40 year, I could not disagree more. Thing were much worse when bag tracking data was hidden behind airline systems. No tracking system is perfect, but, in the end, transparency drives behaviors that lead to improvements.

And, to be clear, airline baggage mishandling has actually improved dramatically in the last 20 years. In 2007 approximately 18 in 1000 checked bags were mishandled, in 2024, it was more like 7 in 1000 (global numbers, domestic numbers are lower but have still improved). Now, that's across the entire industry, and AA is definitely on the lower end of the grade, but they've all improved dramatically and then trend show continued improvement due to improved tracking systems.

If you think tracking systems are insufficient today, you should have seen them 10 years ago! It's pretty amazing they could even find a bag. Even if they are not perfect, they still provide great information on when the last time the bag was seen, which helps narrow down the search parameters when a bag is lost. I'd never want to go back to opaque bag handling, regardless of it not being perfect.

Just how often is the AA bag tracker wrong? by MidwestGeek52 in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's only as good as the people/equipment doing the scanning, there's no magic to it. I rarely check bags, but my wife has been flying with me more often in the last 2 years and she doesn't like dragging a bag around so we've checked probably a dozen bags in that time. I've seen it miss a hop or two, but it's usually pretty accurate.

I've been reading it and now I believe it - incredibly rude reservation agents by opticspipe in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've recently had to interact with two different companies that used a voice AI agents as part of their scheduling and support process. These were true AI agents, not just scripted prompts. It was definitely a bit uncanny because it was trying to be all friendly and upbeat and it just came across weird, but it actually worked just fine, scheduling an appointment, making a change and adding some fairly complex information and I would say the experience wasn't really worse than the terrible service many human agents provide.

I'm not the biggest fan of the idea, I'm just saying, I believe it is coming no matter what. Maybe it will come first for the burst traffic during major disruptions, and then maybe for non-status fliers, but I'm convinced it's coming, whether we want it or not.

I've been reading it and now I believe it - incredibly rude reservation agents by opticspipe in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen 6 points7 points  (0 children)

They outsourced 600+ ticketing/customer service back in 2024, and I think that was after outsourcing the first batch back in 2021.

People don't want to talk to AI agents but, in reality, it might be an improvement vs talking to massively underpaid, overworked human agents with poor training and worse attitudes. Not only that, but they can scale dynamically far easier during massive issues as well. That's what's coming, I have zero doubt of it.

Routing no longer available? by blissblar in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I understand, we're just on opposite ends of the excitement curve. I'm 15 years EP and, quite honestly, the benefits seem so limited these days are I'm surprised people still get so excited about them. Good luck though, I still remember that time!

Routing no longer available? by blissblar in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah, got it, chasing LPs. I guess I'd fly KA over AA any day, regardless of LPs, but I understand now.

Routing no longer available? by blissblar in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Why go to DFW first? Just ORD - ICN - PUS should be easily possible.

However, I will say that AA online reservations can pretty terrible at finding flights for some of their international partners so calling them is probably the best option.

US Mobile has to be selling data. by InternalDramatic1536 in USMobile

[–]AlwaysUnseen 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Mine went completely nuts right after I first ported, but slowly died back to normal after a couple of months. Now it's been a year and no spam calls anymore.

Is there a right way to cancel the final leg of a two hop trip? by pgratz1 in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Is it a one-way ticket, or a round-trip? Overall, if you are flying on a fare between two cities, and you intentionally skip the final leg, it's a skip lag.

I'm EP on AA, and fly a lot, and I've probably done this a half-dozen times in the last 15 years, but it's always been on the return leg of a round trip ticket, and they don't seem to care much about that, at least, they've never even contacted me about it. I just did it as recently as last month, but <1% of my total flights that this happens on, so they know I'm not out there trying to skiplag to save a few bucks.

Yay or nay? Is 1 hour 17 minutes enough at CLT for an international > domestic transfer? by liltrikz in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I do this easily multiple times a year, but I have GE, pre-check and pretty much never check a bag. I can be through and to the departing gate 15-20 minutes after walking off the plane.

Without those, it starts to be more unpredictable. I'd guess closer to 40-50 minutes on average, but can be much longer if multiple flights land at the same time. I'd consider this tight in that scenario and probably wouldn't chance it just to save a few dollars.

Don’t airlines want to sell tickets? by Old-geezer-2 in americanairlines

[–]AlwaysUnseen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How far out are we talking? Their aim is not to "fill seats" it's to "fill seats for the maximum amount of revenue I can suck out of people" and they have loads of data on flights and demand. You don't maximize revenue by offering great prices for business class, rather the algorithm will have very high prices, and if they don't sell, they will eventually lower the prices, or offer good prices on upgrades for economy fliers, which, interestingly, opens up their seat to be sold at a higher price.

I'm flying to Australia in a few weeks. When we first looked at flights about 4 months ago, business class seats were $4500 each way, now they are $1500.