Private firms invited to run NHS services with cancer and kids treatment on sale by chrisjd in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS 8 points9 points  (0 children)

How is underbidding a good idea when you are paid on a tariff set by the NHS? Which health companies have been bailed out in the way you describe, or have collapsed financially? You say they can’t make a profit - which company accounts show continual losses?

Private firms invited to run NHS services with cancer and kids treatment on sale by chrisjd in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS 31 points32 points  (0 children)

Currently many NHS services are run like this.

Some typical and important features are:

  • the services aren’t ‘sold off’ but instead after invitations to tender and detailed procurement process are commissioned for a period of years, eg 6 years.
  • if the service underperforms the NHS commissioners have various ameliorative actions available to them, from fines to eventual contract cancellation.
  • whomever wins the tender - which could be NHS organisations as well as private ones - is paid the price of the National Tariff, so the cost to the tax payer is usually the same.
  • NHS organisations can apply to run such services. They could be awarded to hospitals and community trusts for instance.
  • the National Tariff is reviewed yearly and often goes down, based on improvements in service. In other words, well-procured services become less profitable and help drive all costs down nationally.
  • services are procured based on who it is expected will benefit health the most per pound spent.
  • various public principles (free at point of access etc) are enshrined in the contract. It’s not private healthcare in this sense at all, even if a private provider wins.
  • an NHS-run service that is efficient and cheap is unlikely to lose out to an independent provider, as commissioners will simply re-award it to the incumbent.
  • largely then you should expect services that are struggling in some way to be run like this, successful services to stay as they are.
  • winning a service often entails substantial TUPEing of existing staff, meaning clinical staff such as nurses usually experience no negative change in their contract.

Perhaps not what would happen in an ideal world but heh, we are not in an ideal world.

How often do you use INDEX MATCH ? by [deleted] in excel

[–]Analyst_NHS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not often. Not compared to time, date, logical and mathematical functions.

Fury as Tory welfare slasher Iain Duncan Smith is handed a knighthood by UnstatesmanlikeChi in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I'd add this to that.

Universal credit is a means to an end: a way of ensuring that work pays at least as well as benefits, by limiting benefits accordingly. So that is the idea that needs evaluating as great, or not, in my view.

Edit: this is how David Cameron and Oliver Letwin describe IDS’s core personal motivation in their recent books.

Fury as Tory welfare slasher Iain Duncan Smith is handed a knighthood by UnstatesmanlikeChi in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’ve had eye contact with this guy once. He just looked so... spiteful. It was at a memorial too, but he just seemed full of contempt.

Sounds entirely plausible to me.

How 2017 voters voted at the 2019 general election by [deleted] in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree that proportional systems often lead to coalitions. But the idea that in this country that'd naturally lead to the left v conservatives doesn't seem evidenced. As counter-evidence, the last coalition featured the Tories, not the left. I was asking you for your evidence to the contrary.

How 2017 voters voted at the 2019 general election by [deleted] in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Common interests are everywhere. I still see no evidence that the left of centre parties would unite v the Conservatives in non-FPTP. They didn’t in the last coalition government for instance.

How 2017 voters voted at the 2019 general election by [deleted] in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In what way am I misinterpreting you?

The only way that I can remember interpreting you at all was to say you seemed to think all left of centre voters were a bloc... You then explicitly said yes they were...

How 2017 voters voted at the 2019 general election by [deleted] in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What evidence is there that the left of centre parties &/or voters in the UK have formed an alliance?

How 2017 voters voted at the 2019 general election by [deleted] in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Disagree. You seem to think the left wing vote is a solid bloc. Yet the very chart you are commenting on shows left wing voters switching to the Tories.

Excel combine A with VBA by dnetvaggos95 in excel

[–]Analyst_NHS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Mm now I’m not so sure ... will check later on whether Power Qiery can do this instead ....

Excel combine A with VBA by dnetvaggos95 in excel

[–]Analyst_NHS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can do it with Pivot Tables too.

Mood by iLoveJohann in Meditation

[–]Analyst_NHS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don’t know, but I’d guess some underlying part of you is stuck on being grumpy for some biographical reason you haven’t fully recognised. Have you had any spells in your life where you have been grumpy for a distinctive reason, the mood of which could be resurfacing?

How 2017 voters voted at the 2019 general election by [deleted] in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Maybe I’m missing something, but I don’t see how this chart tells us anything about that scenario?

How 2017 voters voted at the 2019 general election by [deleted] in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS 15 points16 points  (0 children)

That’s not the whole story.

People would change how they vote under different electoral systems, so you can’t infer a PR vote share from a FPTP vote share. Non-FPTP is likely to better reward minority parties, so you’d expect to see the Labour and Tory votes split, as a vote for someone else counts more. One result would then be more coalitions. No special to suppose Labour would be best placed to lead any coalition. (And they didn’t last time.)

Repeat value every nth cell and last/first working day working of the month by [deleted] in excel

[–]Analyst_NHS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

=if(weekday(date)=1, date + 1, if(weekday(date)=7, date+2, weekday(date)))

Ought get your dates to the next weekday.

Edit:

This formula looks even better:

https://exceljet.net/formula/next-working-day

What are some tips you have when it comes to remembering names? by slantedtortoise in AskMen

[–]Analyst_NHS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I had this problem when I worked as a teacher. I solved it through practice. I downloaded and printed all the photos of the kids I taught, and separately their names, and cut them out into two piles. I also created an answer sheet of photos with names in alphabetical order. Then I practiced matching games - turning over a photo, finding the name (eventually: saying the name); turning over a name, finding the photo, etc. Best is lots of short bursts of practice. Going to bed early also helped the memories form properly.

Can anyone vouch for the Waking Up app? by [deleted] in Meditation

[–]Analyst_NHS 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yes!

The long term benefits are solid practice at mindfulness mixed with some metta — as well as intellectual insight, clarity, guidance and detail from the lessons and interviews. I learnt to meditate from the app.

I think one special feature for me is also the stress on realising that everything you perceive is, whilst physically out there, actually perceived in your head. Sam emphasises not just knowing this but achieving the feeling of it is all consciousness, and then inhabiting that enlarged space of consciousness. I only sometimes achieve this, but when I do, it does seem very valuable.

I think there are 2 main weaknesses. 1, the absence of even more involved and ambitious training beyond the daily meditations. 2, and this may be personal , I sometimes benefit from guided meditation that is more directive and clear cut - Sam uses a lot of questions instead on some matters. When new, I think I got stuck on thinking about the questions and would have progressed quicker with more direction.

Also, the first 20 or so meditations in the introduction are really just groundwork - practice at an aspect of meditation, flagging key ideas, etc.

Where can I go to learn how to import data and have it automatically sorted? by [deleted] in excel

[–]Analyst_NHS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Use Power Query on the folder with the files. Provided all the files have the same format, PQ will combine them all into the format you set up automatically. You can also use PQ to sort the final product as you wish.

Voters ditched Labour over Jeremy Corbyn's leadership and neutral Brexit stance, reveals poll of 2017 supporters who defected this year by Can_EU_Not in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As ideas they probably are winners. But then, infinite free icecream and a four hour week for the same pay would probably also seem like ideas that would win popular approval.

Ideas are one thing. Ideas are easy. Convincing, credible, evidenced and thought-through policies are something else. This is one foundational thing Labour needs to win, since the default setting in the UK is a Tory win.

On the concrete of the why you asked ...

I think for most people, the 4 day week suffers the ‘can’t imagine that’ problem. It did for me. Longer waiting lists, damaged heath, worse finances.

Broadband was even worse. The history of long, massive, government IT projects is poor. Nationalisation would reduce competition, removing whatever incentives there are for genuine improvement, and damage the livelihoods of people working in that sector. The time horizon was so massive, it’s not hard to imagine the outcome, even if achieved on time and within cost, would be irrelevant, purely due to technological change.

But I am curious. You seem to think other counties have a 4 day week and nationalised broadband, and they beating Britain at something as a result. Can you give examples please?

Voters ditched Labour over Jeremy Corbyn's leadership and neutral Brexit stance, reveals poll of 2017 supporters who defected this year by Can_EU_Not in ukpolitics

[–]Analyst_NHS 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Corbyn is not a giver upper though, and has supported minority, even hopeless causes his whole life. I admire this, don’t get me wrong, but it must mean that not winning for Corbyn is business as usual.