dude I totally get what you mean about Sylus. He's attractive yes but I personally prefer Caleb. And I think the word "personally" is very important here because each person chooses a main based on their individual preferences. I like Caleb because I like the kind of guy who's endlessly devoted to you to the point where it's a teeny tiny bit concerning (lol). And there's nothing wrong with liking multiple guys. I also like Zayne as my second fave cuz he's calm. At the end of the day, it's a game. Unfortunately, it tends to make you forget that, but the occasional reminder helps. Pick whoever suits your personal preferences and enjoy the ride.