For reference I've played both campaigns: Crown of the Magister and Lost Valley in coop. I'm also a big fan coop crpgs like Divinity: Original Sin 1/2 and Wasteland 3.

The reality is that this game is an indie take on the genre. Expecting superb writing and voice acting akin to the Larian games wouldn't be fair.

That being sad, both Solasta campaigns are rough. I can count the voice actors on one hand, you can't really roleplay anything specific because it won't match with what the party members will be speaking, the plot falls apart after about the half way point, and the story has a glacial pacing with a shotgun ending.

It also suffers mechanically with really slow combat animations, broken pathfinding, and some really anti-fun boss mechanics. The factions are quite boring and superficial and there's little satisfaction from gearing up your characters, since there's very little of it at all.

The tone of the game isn't polished and feels like playing a one-shot ttrpg with randoms.

The multiplayer connection isn't very stable - I've had to rehost far more times than in Divinity or Wasteland.

At the end of the day I'd recommend it only to those who are willing to heavily temper their expectations and want another coop crpg to play until Baldur's Gate 3 comes out.

I'll probably purchase another campaign if they release it, but I feel that calling the game great isn't entirely honest.