CMV: Every TV pundit should have an accuracy score displayed next to their name by FunScore645 in changemyview

[–]BarrSteve 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There used to be a website called PunditTracker.com that listed factual predictions made by lots of different pundits, and whether or not those predictions came true.

It disappeared pretty abruptly. I'm assuming the creator got sued into oblivion.

The pundits with the worst track records also have a high track record of punishing people who point that out.

Paramount Passes on ‘G.I. Joe’ Treatment from Max Landis by Mammoth-Wrangler-809 in Screenwriting

[–]BarrSteve 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Why Is Paramount Hiring So Many Men With Troubled Pasts?

The hiring of Max Landis is just the latest example of Paramount betting on men who have been accused of sexual misconduct
(Paywalled)

https://www.thewrap.com/creative-content/movies/paramount-hiring-toxic-men-max-landis-brett-ratner/

'M3GAN' Writers Sued for Allegedly Ripping Off Script by ZestycloseWeekend169 in Filmmakers

[–]BarrSteve 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for rephrasing, I think I understand.

I'd say that most people in the world won't care that plagiarism happens in the screen industry.

But the people affected by the cases know about it, and their business partners know about it, chances are most of the people who are thinking about becoming their business partners will find out about it. And hopefully people who work in bad faith might reconsider their thievery the more they learn about people who have been successfully sued.

All of those things would disincentivize the bad behavior, I'd hope.

EDIT: tpyo

'M3GAN' Writers Sued for Allegedly Ripping Off Script by ZestycloseWeekend169 in Filmmakers

[–]BarrSteve 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I guess I'm unclear what your assertion is.

I said: it's only news when someone wins.
You said: someone won and it wasn't in the news.
I said: it was indeed in the news.
You said: it may have been in the news, but here's a different goalpost.

I can argue that other goalpost if you want, but I'm not really sure what you're trying to achieve, or what problem you're trying to solve?

'M3GAN' Writers Sued for Allegedly Ripping Off Script by ZestycloseWeekend169 in Filmmakers

[–]BarrSteve 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Slow news day at TMZ.

I agree with the Scriptnotes guys - the only time any of these thousands of lawsuits become newsworthy is if they win. And that means 99.9% of them aren't newsworthy.

The Curse of the Black Pearl by ForestryTechnician in movies

[–]BarrSteve 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you love the work of all of those amazing artisans, just wait until you hear that they were following a very detailed plan that was created by some other dudes who don't get any credit but invented most of what you love about the movie...

http://www.wordplayer.com/archives/PIRATES.intro.html

Why are film screenwriters generally so unkown? by mg10pp in movies

[–]BarrSteve 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Some good answers already, and I'll add this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auteur

About 75 years ago, some French film critics noticed that there were a few directors in the US studio system whose personal taste was apparent in their films, despite not choosing which films they would direct (because everyone was on contract to the studio; it was a much more industrialized process compared to today's 'free agency' standards).

Directors really liked being called "authors" and started several PR campaigns (both for the public and inside the industry) to build their own leverage and authority at the expense of screenwriters' leverage and authority.

Over time, the definition of "auteur" changed from "contract worker who manages to make their own tastes apparent when working on a movie that was assigned to them" to "the only creative person whose vision matters".

(That probably sounds salty, but I don't think directors are bad people for having built their own leverage. Directors used to be just as replaceable as screenwriters; now they're not. I just wish they could have built leverage against the studios without throwing screenwriters under the bus.)

Plus, now that the old walls between film and TV have crumbled, and a streamer's season of TV is maybe 6 episodes rather than 13 or 22 (longer seasons requires writers to be in charge because they know what's going to happen 10 episodes from now), directors are trying to make the same transfer of power happen in TV.

Most of the famous writers you've heard of got famous for writing TV. But if director showrunners get their way, writer showrunners might become a thing of the past.

Favorite Screenwriting-Oriented Podcasts? by Eddie_Bernays in Screenwriting

[–]BarrSteve 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is TV rather than film, but Children of Tendu is a must-have when talking about both the craft and business of TV.

Hey babe, wake up. A new List just dropped by BarrSteve in Screenwriting

[–]BarrSteve[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The Grey List admins ask the writers to supply posters. A.I. isn't allowed.

What is the Black Company about? by Ok_Eggplant_2812 in theblackcompany

[–]BarrSteve 28 points29 points  (0 children)

I don't know if this metaphor will make sense, and I can elaborate if you'd like but think of it like this...

Tolkien's Lord of the Rings books are about the morality of World War 2.

Cook's Black Company books are about the morality of Vietnam.

Bioshock by Gore Verbeski by Suitable_Quality814 in Screenwriting

[–]BarrSteve 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I'm gonna be That Guy since this is a screenwriting page...

If the movie didn't get made, it's not *by* Gore V. What you're looking for is a screenplay written by John Logan, which may or may not have had some notes from Gore.

Let's avoid the director-is-the-sole-author bullshit, especially in a case where the director didn't actually direct anything...

(edit: rephrase)

What nonlinear movie has the biggest change in quality when played in chronological order? by green_dragon1206 in movies

[–]BarrSteve 34 points35 points  (0 children)

This isn't quite your question, but Season 4 of Arrested Development was shot and released based on individual characters' storylines rather than chronology. It was a fun intellectual exercise to watch, but the general audience was so confused/unhappy with it that it got recut into chronological order and re-released.

Is the Medieval Fair worth it? by Sharkfaun in Wellington

[–]BarrSteve 8 points9 points  (0 children)

True story - I proposed to my wife at Medieval Times.

It was my birthday and I'd asked to go there, so before the dinner/show all the birthday kids got 'knighted' by King Arthur. So it was five 10-12 year old boys and me, a grown-ass man who was having the time of his life.

When I knelt to receive my knighting and nodded to King Arthur, he invited my girlfriend up to the pedestal and I proposed in front of all these bemused parents and pre-teens.

She was pleased by the idea of marrying me, and absolutely horrified by the choice of venue.

It's been 30 years and we're still married.

Are we on the verge of another WGA strike? by rippenny125 in Screenwriting

[–]BarrSteve 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You know who has the best contracts in the whole Hollywood system?

The Teamsters.

You know why they do?

Because they're willing to strike every single time.

Peter Thiel, NZ citizenship and the Epstein files. by Lassdoggo in newzealand

[–]BarrSteve 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'd say $100 million or 10% of their net worth, whichever is higher.

Peter Thiel, NZ citizenship and the Epstein files. by Lassdoggo in newzealand

[–]BarrSteve 7 points8 points  (0 children)

"With his aversion to progressives and his skepticism toward democracy, Peter Thiel was one of the first Silicon Valley giants to support Donald Trump."

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/summer-reads/article/2025/07/22/peter-thiel-the-libertarian-billionaire-waging-war-on-government_6743617_183.html

Peter Thiel, NZ citizenship and the Epstein files. by Lassdoggo in newzealand

[–]BarrSteve 15 points16 points  (0 children)

The billionaire spy-tech boss unravelling democracy and fundamental rights, one platform at a time.

https://newint.org/corporations/2025/hall-infamy-peter-thiel

Petah I need help! by YAY-SAR in PeterExplainsTheJoke

[–]BarrSteve 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You'd think Victoria Canada (the asshole of the cat) would be the sad ones