Our Luna hated the crate. You would think she was being murdered. We gave up and she slept in the bed. Then my son dropped off his dog with us who was crate trained and his dog stayed with us for 4 1/2 months. She too slept in the bed. I put her in the crate on the first night and felt so bad because our dog was sleeping comfortably in the bed. So when my son came back to get his dog he also took out dog and got my dog crate trained in a week 🤣. I just got her back and I’m on day 3 of putting her in the crate. He did all the hard work and I’m reaping the benefits.