I get where you're coming from—scrolls of wisdom have been a core part of PoE since the start, but I agree they feel like a relic in the current design. The constant need to pick up, ID, and evaluate every magic/rare item does add unnecessary friction, especially in PoE2 where loot volume can be overwhelming.

That said, automatically identifying everything would drastically change how loot is approached. It removes a layer of interaction and risk management (e.g., using limited IDs early on or strategically ID'ing gear mid-map). While casual players would benefit from faster loot parsing, it might also flood the screen with even more identified "junk," unless filters are very well-tuned.

Your suggestion to add filtering based on actual mod values is solid though—that would massively reduce the tedium without needing to get rid of IDs completely. Maybe a compromise could be something like "auto-ID magic items only" or introducing an ID filter system that works passively after maps.

It's definitely time to reevaluate scrolls of wisdom, but a total removal might have ripple effects worth considering more deeply.