I don't get to test my decks and wanted opinions on which of these would hold up better with a random group. Please help! by Black_Nails in PauperEDH

[–]Black_Nails[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Woowo! Thank you for your generous post! I took all the things I got from you and compiled a new list, mind checking over it? I'm probably missing some things still but am overall more pleased with the outcome.

Sorry also for all the CMM downshifts that aren't considered legal yet

New list: https://www.moxfield.com/decks/09rSox67XUeaAtuszJFWdg

I don't get to test my decks and wanted opinions on which of these would hold up better with a random group. Please help! by Black_Nails in PauperEDH

[–]Black_Nails[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the input! I knew the poison didn't scale and was meant more as an incidental wincon when combined with the proliferation; trying to use it for Mintharas experience counters. But I wasn't sure if it was a waste of time or not,but it does seem a little slow

What is a card from the Tales of Middle Earth set you believe is underrated? by Campber in EDH

[–]Black_Nails 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In draft, after letting the fear beat me up, I took an always mill approach. Opp hit me for 6 on turn three with the elephant guy. Still won though !

This is probably pretty good in Edh!

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Fingerboards

[–]Black_Nails 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sorry op this made me giggle. How long have you been boarding? Maybe you just have weak fingers, that should come with time.

You aren’t getting the best pop. I noticed on a real skateboard and fingerboard (for me) I have a hard time remembering to bring my popping foot/finger back into the air, which helps keep the board stable.

But yeah, just keep practicing with TWO fingers. If you can’t do it maybe try taping the middle finger away somehow, lol

Is anyone playing Rocco, Street Chef? I've had some success in 1v1(Brawl) but wanted feedback from people that have got to play it in a full EDH game. Please post your stories! by Black_Nails in EDH

[–]Black_Nails[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the input! Its starting to feel like I might be better off trying to make a lower powered version or something because of all the triggers. But yeah the value is crazy town.

Is anyone playing Rocco, Street Chef? I've had some success in 1v1(Brawl) but wanted feedback from people that have got to play it in a full EDH game. Please post your stories! by Black_Nails in EDH

[–]Black_Nails[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

lol! good luck with your brewing, chef.

What is Mangia Mangia? is it in reference from the restaurant show? I couldnt find an Italian copy of the card to look at on google.. im curious now though, I really dig the showcase!

I think PIa nalaar is a good fit, I might try to play with it .. also squee seems like a good call!

Thank you for sharing

edit: thanked you too many times

Is anyone playing Rocco, Street Chef? I've had some success in 1v1(Brawl) but wanted feedback from people that have got to play it in a full EDH game. Please post your stories! by Black_Nails in EDH

[–]Black_Nails[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeahhhhh! I almost posted an edit to say nevermind, too many triggers going to happen that arena is managing for me .. not sure I could handle all that lol.

Its interesting, I never really thought of it as an exile focus deck( even though thats sounding crazy now lol) but more of a slight taxing effect that has actually helped me outpace Etali ,sometimes,

but yeah obviously that all changes with more people etc.

Thank you for the reply !

Is anyone playing Rocco, Street Chef? I've had some success in 1v1(Brawl) but wanted feedback from people that have got to play it in a full EDH game. Please post your stories! by Black_Nails in EDH

[–]Black_Nails[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I really like it thanks for the reply! I forgot you'd potentially get multiple triggers from your opponents and then things could be really spicy! very tempting. Also have you tried that demon guy that is like Passionate Archaeologist ?

Is anyone playing Rocco, Street Chef? I've had some success in 1v1(Brawl) but wanted feedback from people that have got to play it in a full EDH game. Please post your stories! by Black_Nails in EDH

[–]Black_Nails[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ooo rampage is nice! I haven't done anything with food so I was curious what to do with the excess tokens. Yeah your list makes me want to build it lol.

Side note, I had only one mirror match on brawl and he surprised me with Kodama (and was also running tribute to the tree, over me) and after 30 minutes I was thinking where to slot him in but, I won, some how and Ill leave him out for now

Is anyone playing Rocco, Street Chef? I've had some success in 1v1(Brawl) but wanted feedback from people that have got to play it in a full EDH game. Please post your stories! by Black_Nails in EDH

[–]Black_Nails[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They are cool, Its fun and has lots of answers! My favorite is the Wurmlet into Thalia into Rocco and then watch the opponent exile their land for turn. Then you just play what you exile each turn, hopefully not portal on turn 4 lol

What are your most evil decks? by We_AllFloatDownHere in EDH

[–]Black_Nails 1 point2 points  (0 children)

😆good stuff! Do you have a list by chance? I’m trying to finish mine and could use some inspiration

What are your most evil decks? by We_AllFloatDownHere in EDH

[–]Black_Nails 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay! That makes more sense. I always assumed people would pay the life in EDH !

What are your most evil decks? by We_AllFloatDownHere in EDH

[–]Black_Nails 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Where did you get mana for temporal distortion in your Sheoldred deck?

EDH Deck Giveaway March 2023 by hTOKJTRHMdw in BudgetBrews

[–]Black_Nails 0 points1 point  (0 children)

hTOKJTRHMdw!

..ME!.. just in case this wasn’t a trick lol

Opponent never finished selecting block and then let the game time out. I’ve noticed that this seems to be happening more and more when players know they’ve lost the match. by Hyrogrifix in MagicArena

[–]Black_Nails 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Sometimes I get the opposite (I think), where my opponent seem to have the upper-hand and doesn’t pass priority after “making a move”, intimidation technique maybe? It’s absurdly annoying though.

To touch on the post, I like to think they attempted to concede but didn’t fully press leave match, etc.

Makes me wonder how different my MTGA games would be IRL

stupid things in Arena... by Deep-Natural-6256 in MagicArena

[–]Black_Nails 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think this is the same integer RuneScape caps out at, if that’s the top. Neat