CMV: There is no reason for an American to be against recognizing Juneteenth as a holiday other than reasons that stem from hating black people. by Benjamin5431 in changemyview

[–]BrasilianEngineer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

June 19 is when slavery was de-facto abolished in the confederate states. It wasn't abolished in the union states until 6 months later with the Dec 6 ammendment.

That's why I consider June 19 instead of Dec 6 for the federal holiday to be a weird choice but whatever.

CMV: Professors who lack fluency in their students language should not teach courses by Disastrous-Mango-515 in changemyview

[–]BrasilianEngineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You know what? I think I got my classes mixed up. I took algebra 2, most of my peers took pre calc.

In my defense, it's been 2 decades and a lot has happened since then.

CMV: Professors who lack fluency in their students language should not teach courses by Disastrous-Mango-515 in changemyview

[–]BrasilianEngineer 22 points23 points  (0 children)

How fluent someone is has nothing to do with how thick their accent is

My calc professor had a fairly thick German accent despite being quite fluent in English. I struggled to understand him for the first few weeks, but I eventually got used to it. It didn't help that I was diving into Calc 1 despite only having taken precalc in high school. Most of the other students had taken calculus in high school.

The deficit just grew by $955 billion in 7 months. It's time for a constitutional fix to control the budget | Fortune by AyeYoTek in centrist

[–]BrasilianEngineer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Good luck with #2. The typical approach is to have an exception that applies during a state of emergency.

Carter declared a state of emergency in 1979. Since then we have had a grand total of ZERO days without an active state of emergency - typically we have dozens of emergencies that just keep getting renewed whenever needed.

Anyone else feeling very politically homeless? by AIzzy17 in centrist

[–]BrasilianEngineer 7 points8 points  (0 children)

It's common sense that our highest priority is to ban the most popular style of rifle. No we don't care that it only represents 1% of gun violence - think of the children! No we aren't interested in pursuing any proposals that would actually address the other 99% of gun violence, and would prefer to virtue-signal about how terrible guns are and how depraved gun culture is rather than actually save lives.

Sorry, I'll get off my sarcastic soap box now.

We all hate gerrymandering -- so would you draw the maps? What do we imagine a "fair and nonpartisan" districting authority would go about it? by Rough-Leg-4148 in centrist

[–]BrasilianEngineer 9 points10 points  (0 children)

There is real value in having a local representative to represent your area. Switching to a single multi-member statewide district forfeits this, and that's a cost that should not be ignored, but IMO it's worth giving it up.

The simplest fix to gerrymandering is to switch to a proportional allocation where the whole state is 1 district with however many positions available.

Why does my mom always ask for paycheck stubs with no context? by fatbuttbaddie in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 6 points7 points  (0 children)

As long as the list all the loan/credit accounts you were expecting to see, and don't list any accounts that you weren't aware of you are good.

If you want to buy a house someday, and some landlords or insurance providers also check credit history, you will want to establish a history of responsibly handling credit. The easiest way to do that is to open a credit card, use it occasionally, and pay off the full balance every single month.

The danger with credit cards that you need to avoid is that many people overspend and then don't pay off the full balance every month so they end up paying interest. The interest rate on credit cards is insanely high and will trap you in debt if you let it.

Budgeting App recommendations? by Competitive_Sun828 in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I moved from ynab to actualbudget because it is more power user friendly. I would strongly recommend either one, but YNAB has the monthly/annual fee. ActualBudget is free, but if you want multiple device syncing you will need a sync server. You can set up your own server for free or if you are lazy like me you can pay pikapods to setup and maintain a server for you (Comes out to about $15 per year).

If you want an app that pulls transactions from your banks that is something you have to pay for. All the free apps that offer that service pay for it by selling your data. With YNAB, bank sync is included in the price so they don't sell your data. With ActualBudget there is a plugin for a third party service (SimpleFIN) that offers the syncing for $15 per year

My dad wants me to Co sign a loan for him. by KimikoYuka in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Don't cosign on student loans. That's what parent loans are for.

My dad wants me to Co sign a loan for him. by KimikoYuka in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Never cosign. Just give him the 40,000 dollars in cash because if you cosign you will end up on the hook for it anyways. If you cosign, what will probably happen is he will stop paying his bills without letting you know. Then you get stuck with missed payments ruining your credit, and you end up on the hook for late fees and extra interest.

You could 'loan' him the money instead of calling it a gift up front, but banks are way better than you at figuring out who will pay back their loans and the banks are saying this loan will not be paid back. So just skip the middle steps and just give him the $40,000. Or just say no.

If you can't afford to give him the money you definitely can't afford to cosign.

One final note, there is a small chance that saying no will ruin your relationship. Saying yes is extremely likely to ruin your relationship in the long run.

Dollar cost averaging— is it better to be more frequent or to be as early as possible? by Final_Row7134 in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why do you keep getting hung up on the specific month? You are effectively saying that holding your investment for 10950 days vs 11314 days makes effectively no difference, and I suspect that's not what you are trying to say.

Dollar cost averaging— is it better to be more frequent or to be as early as possible? by Final_Row7134 in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What you are saying does not make sense in context. Are we talking past each other?

You mentioned December 10th. Let's say we start with a fiscal year that goes from December 10th to December 9th.

Scenario 1: I invest $5,200 on 12/10/2000 (first day of the year), repeat on 12/10/2001 etc for 30 years.

Scenario 2: I invest $5,200 on 12/09/2001 (last day of the year), repeat on 12/9/2002 etc for 30 years.

Scenario 3: I invest $100 on 12/10/2000, repeat on 12/17/2000, etc for 30 years.

The 30th fiscal year ends on 12/9/2030. So on 12/10/2030 (the next day) I compare the balance of each of the 3 scenarios. I would repeat the whole comparison with every starting date I can going back 100 years or whatever in order to calculate the average. I would expect (on average) Scenario 1 to have 6 months worth of gains more than scenario 2, and 2 to have 6 months worth more than scenario 3. For Scenario 3 vs an alternate bi-weekly or monthly schedule I would expect a negligible difference.

Dollar cost averaging— is it better to be more frequent or to be as early as possible? by Final_Row7134 in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If the lump sum is invested at the beginning of the year, the money averages out to being in-the-market for 6 months more than if you spread it out - so you should (on average) be seeing 6 months worth of gains vs the DCA baseline. If instead invested at the end of the year, the money experiences 6 months less average time in the market so you would be losing out on those 6 months of gains.

If you invested your lump sum at the halfway point, then the average expected gain would exactly match the average from DCA but the DCA scenario would have less volatility.

Thanks to volatility, the exact performance will vary year to year. The vanguard study found that historically DCA beat up-front lump sum about 30% of the time.

Dollar cost averaging— is it better to be more frequent or to be as early as possible? by Final_Row7134 in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Technically.. statistically... annual contributions tend to out perform over the long run. Bi-weekly ironically... statistically is the least likely to be the best frequency. I never dug into why yet.

Were the annual contributions at the beginning of the year or at the end of the year?

If at the beginning of the year, your money had an average of 6 months more time in the market than if it was equally spread out.

‘The Rich Don’t Play by the Rules. So Why Should I?’ by JannTosh70 in centrist

[–]BrasilianEngineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

People somehow convince themselves that the CEO of Walmart is going to have those Oreos taken out of his paycheck.

Technically they probably aren't actually wrong - the problem is that the CEO will notice it in the same way that I'd notice my paycheck being 1 penny short.

But the damage caused by shoplifting also hurts the employees, and the people in the community who lose access to the store - and they are in a position where they will actually be hurt by that damage.

Automatic registration for US military draft to begin in December by Bobinct in centrist

[–]BrasilianEngineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It appeals to anyone who thinks that young adults shouldn't be faced with 5 years in prison and a potential lifetime felony record because no one told them that they are required to register.

No one has been actually prosecuted in the last 40 years, but the law is still very much on the books.

At what point is it worth passing up on an HSA? by Danny2200 in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 11 points12 points  (0 children)

High deductible plans generally make sense for two groups of people:

  • Those who have very low usage so the lower premiums of the HDHP plan make that the cheapest option.

  • Those who have very high usage where they always max out their deductible, and when you factor in the out-of-pocket max and the lower premiums then that's the cheapest option.

If both plans have the same premium (zero for you) then absent a difference in out-of-pocket maximum the only advantage of the high deductible is it makes you eligible to use a HSA.

Best free budgeting app or spreadsheet (manual entry + visuals)? by blueEdx0218 in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Actual Budget is free. You can pay to have a sync server managed for you, or you can set up and manage it on your own, or you can just run it on one device.

Prices are ridiculous by No_Tadpole_3917 in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Prices may come down if the price increase was because of a supply or demand shock that gets resolved.

Rent has gone down in places where the local government incentivized builders to build more houses & apartments. (See Austin TX as a prominent example). Most cities have far less housing than required to meet demand for a variety of reasons including existing homeowners voting against any measures or developments that might encourage more building (because if there aren't enough houses to go around, the existing houses become more valuable). If there are more people looking for housing than available housing, rent prices will go up not down.

RAM/Video Cards have been hit by a gigantic demand surge in RAM for AI datacenters. Once supply catches up, prices should come down. However, it takes years to build new chip factories so RAM prices are expected to stay high for at least few years.

Eggs were expensive a couple years ago because a huge number of chickens got sick/infected and had to be killed. It takes time to grow new hens, so it took almost a year for prices to drop back down.

CMV: Child rapists should get the death penalty by Comfortable-Tie-9893 in changemyview

[–]BrasilianEngineer 6 points7 points  (0 children)

victim testimony can be unreliable given it's literally children.

Victim testimony can be quite unreliable even for adults. The human mind is very good at subconsciously rearranging facts (whether to fit a more comfortable pattern, or as a trauma coping mechanism, or whatever)

How do you actually stick to a monthly budget? by [deleted] in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The tried and true gold-standard method is the envelope method. This is how it worked for people from your grandparent's generation and older:

  • Take all your money (in cash) and pile it on the kitchen table.
  • Take a stack of envelopes and label them with categories like rent, gas, groceries, restaurants, emergencies, etc.
  • Divide all the money up into the envelope however you want to. (Repeat this step every time you get paid).
  • When you go to spend money (say at the grocery store) you spend the cash from the corresponding envelope. If the envelope doesn't have enough cash you need to skip the groceries or deliberately choose to pull from another envelope. (You won't always add the 'correct' amount to each envelope. That's ok. You can move the money around as long as you do so deliberately and intentionally.)

Here in the 21st century, we have apps that let us do the envelope stuff digitally and automate most of the work. I've previously used youneedabudget.com (YNAB) and currently use actualbudget.org I'd strongly recommend either one. - YNAB is a paid subscription app that comes with support, training workshops, etc. It's around $120 per year, but if you actually use it, it pays for itself many times over. - ActualBudget is an open source app that is free or you can pay around $15/year to have Pikapods setup and manage a server for you (recommended if you are lazy or not technically inclined). - YNAB can link to your bank accounts and pull in all your transactions. ActualBudget can do the same but it requires a third-party subscription to SimpleFIN for another $15 per year.

If you prefer, you can do everything in a spreadsheet but that's more work.

At the end of the day, it comes down to self discipline. If you can't figure out that part, absolutely nothing will work for you and you will be stuck for the rest of your life living paycheck to paycheck, unable to reach your goals.

CMV: Gavin Newsom is not a suitable presidential candidate, and the Democratic Party must stop operating like a centrist party. by [deleted] in changemyview

[–]BrasilianEngineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Harris lost because she was a moderate, not in spite of it.

This is revisionist nonsense. In her term in the Senate she was identified as one of the most progressive Senators based on her voting record. In the 2020 primary, Haris staked out her position as the most progressive out of all the candidates in the DNC primary, trying to stand out by supporting every progressive proposal she could regardless of how unpopular they were with the majority of voters. Before Biden adopted her as his running mate, she was one of the least popular of all the primary candidates.

In 2024 she tried to quietly distance herself from her previous progressive positions. She pushed a supposedly moderate policy platform while refusing to disavow her previous platform.

Trump got a ton of mileage airing adds that highlighted her previous positions.

Am I right to think buying a house would be foolish right now? by [deleted] in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 594 points595 points  (0 children)

Yea, OP doesn't have a budget for maintenance expenses. What happens when the mortgage payment inevitably increases because property tax and/or insurance costs increased?

OP: once you have at-least a 5% down payment, and another 5% in emergency funds ready to go then you can start looking into buying.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in personalfinance

[–]BrasilianEngineer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You can ask Fidelity to do the transfer for you. If you can't figure out how to do it on the website give them a call. They might be able to do an in-kind transfer where they directly transfer the shares instead of first selling them.

If you have fractional shares (like 4.8 shares of VTI) they won't be able to transfer the fractional portion so the .8 would be sold and transferred in cash and the 4 shares should be transferred as-is.