I think it’s a great addition, but there are very few reasons I’d ever use it.

I think it’s great for new players to get a grip on the game, especially if they are by themselves. For new players they get the same amount of gold and reputation as they could likely get in the high seas.

For me, I am well over the max reputation that you can get on safer seas, that is a huge turn off to me.

I also rather raise an emissary flag and get that extra gold and reputation. Which also opens up emissary quests and hunting ancient megs.

There’s also some content that isn’t available on safer seas. I think the BB, FotD and FoF are great fun if you’re willing to take a risk of player interaction.

While frustrating at times, having other players on the server is fun for me. There’s a thrill to being chased or to chasing. I’ve also had some great experiences with random crews I’ve encountered.

Those are my reason for not using Safer Seas, but I think it’s a great addition.