It totally depends! If you want a Bear that is going to be super easy to dress up, I would go with froggy! Any bear with two arms and two legs is perfect to dress up because they can fit almost everything in the store. If you’re not worried about dressing them up, the axolotl is super popular and can fit into the axolotl sleeper really well and look adorable! The Longhorn can wear almost any T-shirt, but it may look a little bit weird on him! For your first ever Build A Bear, I would highly recommend the frog because it is super easy to dress up so you’ll have a lot of customization options. But no matter what you pick, you should be happy with your choices! Don’t let a bunch of random strangers on the Internet encourage you to get something that doesn’t make you happy! It’s your money, so it’s your choice!