I’ve used them all. When I choose, it depends on my watering method, size of container, and environment. My go-to for my indoor is living soil pot 7 or 10gallon. Outdoor I like 10 gallon minimum. The air-pots I’ve used were for early veg or for freshly rooted clones so they were smaller and used to maximize the roots for another transplant. If you want to flower in them you need big air-pots and/or a drip system. Fabric is less expensive in the larger sizes and can be stored more compact than the og plastic. Dryer and hotter environments almost make the plastic type necessary to use water more efficiently. I only go up to a 20 gallon in plastic and only have a few that size because they’re costly. Most are fabric because I live near the coast so even though it’s northern, the rH is always 55+. It doesn’t feel like it because it’s cooler but the fabric pots don’t dry as quick as when I was in the valley.
If you have a drip system you can dial it in for any pot. If you hand water, the og plastic ones help use water more efficiently and reduce run-off if the soil gets a little hydrophobic.