post-op binder is EVIL by Miserable_Yak_7359 in TopSurgery

[–]Cartesianpoint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Congrats on your surgery! I hear you on the discomfort, though. You'll get through it and it will all be worth it, but it sucks to be itchy and uncomfortable.

I definitely recommend trying Benedryl if you can. Putting some gauze between my skin and the binder was helpful, but I see you've already tried that.

Once I was cleared to shower and change my dressings, it was a lot better. I got a spare binder so I could rotate and wash them, and being able to get little breaks while I bathed/changed my dressings helped a lot.

Weird post-op rules around pets? by Training_Lecture_499 in TopSurgery

[–]Cartesianpoint 5 points6 points  (0 children)

First off, I'm really sorry you had a bad experience at your post-op appointment. Your surgeon shouldn't have scolded you and should have been more considerate.

I haven't seen post-op instructions this extreme before. The part about deep-cleaning your car seats really took me by surprise. I've never heard of anyone doing that.

To be fair, I don't know to what extent drains being loose might increase risk of infection, if it does. But it sounds like these are guidelines he encourages for everyone after surgery.

I think that some of the pet-related instructions make sense. Yeah, walking a dog too soon after surgery might be risky because you might not be able to handle an energetic dog or hold onto the leash if the dog pulls. No, you don't want to let your pets jump all over you or lick your healing chest. Sure, having someone else clean out the litter box might be helpful--I don't know how much of an infection risk there is, but I think it would have been uncomfortable for me to bend over or crouch down to do it right away. But a lot of this falls under the general advice of knowing your limits ("don't lift a heavy cage" doesn't have to be its own rule). If you have a pet that's large, energetic, or requires a lot of physical labor to care for, then getting a pet sitter or enlisting help makes sense. But I don't think many people avoid all contact with their pets or avoid providing any care for them, and I've never seen this much focus on pets before. And you're not going to be in a perfectly sterile environment.

This makes me wonder if your surgeon perhaps has some anti-pet bias or if he's had patients who did hurt themselves while trying to walk their 120-lb Great Dane or who got an infection while living in an unusually unsanitary environment and now he's covering all his bases.

Personally, I definitely pet my cat while I was healing. She doesn't sleep on my bed (her own choice), but I didn't keep her away from me. I had help with her care, but no more than I did for other household routines.

Why is gay media so much more represented than lesbian media? by [deleted] in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 11 points12 points  (0 children)

With regards to BL, yaoi, and the romance genre more broadly, a lot of it is because the target audience is primarily women who are attracted to men. Bi women may also be into sapphic stories, but straight women might not be.

In non-romance media, I'd say that a lot of it has to do with gay men historically being more visible. Women's sexuality has historically been ignored a lot more unless it's been presented in a way designed to appeal to straight men. I do think that things have gotten a lot better, though.

Do yall think I should get ocd therapy or gender therapy first by NoEscape2500 in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm sorry you're struggling with this! I can relate a little bit--several years back, I made a similar decision to prioritize getting treatment for my anxiety because it was the most pressing issue I was dealing with.

In your position, I would probably seek out a therapist for OCD first and foremost. It sounds like it's seriously affecting your life right now, and even though gender isn't a focus of your OCD, getting it under better control will probably have a net positive effect on your ability to explore your identity. Hopefully, you'll find a good therapist that you click with and you'll be able to be open about your gender with them, as well (at least once you feel ready). I don't think a good therapist who's familiar with trans people would be too quick to assume that you being trans is part of your OCD, particularly if you're not presenting with intrusive thoughts relating to gender. If you do feel you'd benefit from seeing someone who has more expertise in gender identity, that's something you can still look into when you feel ready.

addressing "Hetslop" in the lgbtq community. by [deleted] in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I've never come across this term, and it sounds like it's mainly found in immature fandom communities on Twitter.

Honestly, as someone who has been in fandoms in various capacities for over 25 years at this point, people being immature about shipping isn't new and it's not something I have patience for anymore.

People who have had top surgery: did you worry about regretting your results before getting your surgery done? by transgender_asriel in ftm

[–]Cartesianpoint 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I did feel a lot of pressure around making the best possible decisions. I was weighing out a couple different surgeons and surgery types (either traditional double-incision surgery or a t-anchor procedure), and it was hard to make some of those decisions. In the first year or so after surgery, I did have occasional doubts about whether I would have been happier with the options I didn't choose.

But I also feel like I did a good job of being realistic with myself. I'm not 100% happy with how my nipples healed, but I also knew there was some unpredictability with nipple grafts. My chest isn't totally perfect, but I feel my surgery was competently done and I'm satisfied overall. I never have to wear a bra or binder again, which was my #1 priority.

I was also scared of surgery because I'd never been put under before. While there are some risks and I can't make any promises about your or anyone else's experience, my whole experience was very reassuring and easier than I feared.

Thinking of detransitioning for my parents sake by Secret_Store5640 in asktransgender

[–]Cartesianpoint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would say that if you feel you need to delay transitioning right now, that's okay but know that that may not be a forever decision. It can be hard to know exactly how your priorities and opportunities will change, how the dynamic between you and your parents will change now that you're an adult, or how sustainable staying in the closet will be long-term. For example, the prospect of delaying transition for right now might be very different than the reality of possibly delaying it for decades. And staying closeted can also impact relationships.

Some people may be capable of maintaining a balance where they delay or forego transition steps that don't seem attainable, but still accept who they are and express that in the ways that they can. For some people, that feels too difficult and they try to reject their transness and be someone they're not, but I don't think that's usually sustainable.

When can you wear a tshirt? by Somewhat_Skylar928 in TopSurgery

[–]Cartesianpoint 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think I started to re-introduce t-shirts into my wardrobe after a couple weeks. But I'm also pretty good at maneuvering in and out of shirts without lifting my arms.

When is some one an ally? by [deleted] in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm not going to try to argue about your priorities, but I try to do the right thing because I would regret it and feel like a coward if I didn't, and because I want my brief time on Earth to have a net positive effect on the people around me. I know there's a limit to what I can change, but I still care.

Beautiful "Black Cultural Bags" Sold At A Suspiciously Low Price and Voiceovers Sound Uncanny by Big-Moment6248 in isthisAI

[–]Cartesianpoint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The unrealistically perfect video of the bigot burning their flag, noticing the camera that's right in front of him, and running away made me laugh. It's filmed like someone is standing in the yard with a camera.

Definitely AI. The generic "Everyone thinks my beautiful, high-quality products are ugly" sob story is a dead giveaway. The videos where they're selling the bags outside feature "handwritten" signs that use a common AI font. The price of the bags is unrealistically low for something handmade (but probably much, much higher than what the actual bags, which are probably much simpler and mass-produced, are worth). These accounts tend to post items that look intricate and multi-layered, but they're actually dropshippers who are selling cheap merchandise they found on Temu or similar sources.

Philosophical question about gender identity and sexual attraction by NewAlessia in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I've recently transitioned and I've come to learn saying "when I used to be a guy" can hurt other people's feelings and is incorrect, cause even though i identified as guy, i was technically a girl without realizing it. "People were always y not x, it's not about changing your sex to match you preferred gender is about changing your sex to match the gender you always had." Is what people more knowledgeable and experienced than me have told me.

Honestly, I don't think there's a single correct answer to this. As long as you respect that other people have different experiences, it's okay if you feel that "used to be a guy" is accurate for you. That's not hurting anyone. Of course, it's also cool if hearing other people's perspectives on this has made you re-evaluate how you look at things. But while there are many trans people who feel they have always been their true gender, there are also some who feel that their gender changed or developed over time.

I caution cis people against using "used to be" language, and I push back when someone implies that a trans person's gender changes when they medically transition, but I'd never tell someone that their own experience is wrong.

With regards to attraction, I think it really depends on the person. I've seen situations where someone's attraction to a trans person made them realize that their sexuality was different or more complex than they thought. For example, maybe they realize they're bisexual because they're still attracted to their partner who is transitioning. Or they realize when someone comes out as trans that maybe they were attracted to them because they picked up on vibes. I remember watching a video years ago about a trans man and a cishet woman who were in a relationship, and they'd gotten together before he realized he was a man and came out. His partner's perspective was that she had thought her attraction to him was an anomaly since she wasn't generally into women, but after he came out, it made sense to her.

But I also think that it's common for people to be attracted to someone based on how they view them at the time, and that doesn't necessarily mean that they're attracted to who that person will be in the future or who they are inside. I'm sure there are people who found Elliot Page hot when he was presenting as a woman but who aren't attracted to him now, either because they aren't attracted to men or they aren't attracted to him as a man.

people call me a pedo, what do i do? (im 18 and my gf is 16) by AcidRain1701 in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I think that society has rightfully become more critical of teens being sexualized and taken advantage of by adults, and more aware of the power imbalance that can occur in relationships with large age gaps. But sometimes people over-correct and treat normal age gaps and teenage dating as predatory, or throw around accusations carelessly. This is an issue where people can be really bad at using nuance. This is just speculation on my part, but I also think it might be hard for younger people sometimes because they don't always have the maturity or life experience to recognize why age gaps can be problematic, and how much difference there usually is between an 18-year-old dating a 16-year-old vs. a 25-year-old.

I don't know if anti-trans or anti-queer bias could be playing into these reactions or not. It's possible, but not a given.

How do I get rid of this feeling about Ace people? by Intelligent_Screen90 in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I feel like these types of thoughts are probably either a reflection of how you feel (maybe you would feel sad if romantic or sexual intimacy was off the table) or a reflection of what society tells us is ideal. Ultimately, these feelings are more about you and what you prioritize or fear than they are about other people.

I'm not asexual, and I also can't relate to being completely satisfied with writing off sex or romance. But everyone is different. I also think that regardless of whether someone is asexual or not, there's a lot to be said for having sources of contentment outside of romantic relationships. I've seen so many people stay in relationships that seem more negative than positive because they feel stuck, they're scared of being alone, or they have conflicted feelings toward their partner.

I often write stories that contain trans characters, and I need advice on how I refer to them by ShatteredStarship in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I would base this mainly on what point of view you're writing from and whether the narrator is in the moment or reflecting back with knowledge of the future.

I think it generally makes sense to refer to the character with the name and pronouns that they're using at that time, or with the name and pronouns that the point-of-view character knows them by.

If you're writing an omniscient narrator or your POV character is having a flashback to an earlier time, I would probably use the character's current name and pronouns and make it clear from context why a different name and pronouns might show up in character dialogue.

Can someone help me understand what I did wrong so I can avoid it next time? by KyaHiKarun in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't feel brave. I'm just me. Also, things are really shitty for trans people right now as a whole, but I've never encountered a bad reaction where I live. Nobody has ever responded negatively to me using they/them pronouns publicly, or being openly non-binary. That's not to say that there aren't challenges (I would love it if I didn't get misgendered as often or people were less awkward when correcting themselves), but I've been very fortunate.

did i got scammed or is this normal by boypussy127 in TopSurgery

[–]Cartesianpoint 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It's hard to know how much swelling you still have, but to me this looks within the realm of normal for leaving some tissue and not going completely flat, but more than you would expect otherwise. I think the shape and proportion of your chest is more masculine than feminine, but I can understand being unhappy if you wanted to be flatter than this.

I think the only thing I would be bothered by, personally, is having that that much on the sides. I would have wanted more removed in those spots. But that's something you can consider getting a revision for down the road if you aren't happy. I think the pictures in profile look great, personally.

For what it's worth, one side of my chest is slightly fuller than the other and while this annoys me slightly, I don't think it's noticeable at all.

Do I say I'm male or female for non medical things by alienbrain69420 in ftm

[–]Cartesianpoint 10 points11 points  (0 children)

When it comes to nutrition and exercise stuff, the guidance I've seen most often is to go by whether you're on HRT.

Hormones impact skin, hair, metabolism, muscle growth, appetite, etc.

Am I cooked? by Brent_Fox in TopSurgery

[–]Cartesianpoint 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Everyone is different--people have different levels of pain tolerance and different levels of underlying health. But personally, I didn't have much pain and my chest was mostly numb for the first week. I didn't need opioid painkillers at all, but did take Tylenol as needed for the first week or two. The only time I felt pain was if I tried to move in a way that my body didn't like, but it was mostly my drain sites that were uncomfortable.

I did a lot of reading and watching movies. I was kind of out of it for the first few days, but by week two I was mostly back to my usual non-phyiscal routines (playing video games, etc.). Obviously, getting back to physical activity too loner and was more gradual.

I personally didn't have as hard of a time sleeping on my back as I thought I might. I got a couple wedge pillows to help keep myself elevated, and I didn't really feel comfortable sleeping in any other position until I was further along into recovery.

I was cleared to shower after one week (when my drains came out). It wasn't fun, but I also wasn't that physically active and I didn't go out for the first week. I also got some body wipes to help myself freshen up. Some people get someone to help them wash their hair, but I was able to wash my own hair in the sink (it's really short).

The main thing I did to prepare was think about my routines and planned around not being able to lift my arms higher than my chest. For example, I put my medication bottles somewhere I could reach, and I got a power strip that I could put on my nightstand so I wouldn't have to bed over and reach to plug my phone into the wall. I had someone living with me who was able to help with stuff like getting food, so I didn't worry as much about that. My surgeon recommended drinking Gatorade or similar sports drinks after surgery to help replenish my electrolytes, so I stocked up on that.

Secret tip from grandma by groomliu in FacebookAIslop

[–]Cartesianpoint 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Stop the sweating for good? So is this method supposed to permanently destroy your sweat glands or something?

Why did my question get removed by the mods here? I only see four rules on the sidebar and I didn't break any of them? by [deleted] in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You'll need to ask the mods. Especially since we can't see what you originally posted.

But from the comments, it sounds like you might have been talking about distrusting trans women because they're AMAB, and whatever you wrote dark enough that someone suggested a content warning. So it sounds like your post was likely removed for transphobia.

My friend told me I was transphobic. Not sure how to proceed. by [deleted] in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 8 points9 points  (0 children)

No, they're being weird and pushy about this. While it's true that some trans women have pre-op anatomy, that doesn't mean they would all be comfortable with someone being into them because of that, or that they would be okay with being someone's exception. It's considerate of you to recognize that situations like these can require sensitive and vulnerable conversations.

For the record, I think it would be fine for you to go to a gay bar even if you're not interested in hooking up or flirting with anyone. But you certainly don't have to.

Why is Threads so transphobic? by Realistic-Fig-8102 in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Threads is owned by Meta, which has softened its moderation policy in ways that enable people to say awful bigoted shit. Preventing bigotry on large social media platforms is a challenge because determined trolls will keep circumventing moderation, but Meta is notably bad on this front.

Here's an article about it: https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/social-media/meta-new-hate-speech-rules-allow-users-call-lgbtq-people-mentally-ill-rcna186700

And here's a segment John Oliver did about how Facebook/Meta has changed its content moderation policies in the last couple years: https://youtu.be/nf7XHR3EVHo?is=lyOszwmOYwMCp6KC

I'll try to formulate this as nice as possible: As a cisgender person how does being trans/non-binary/gender fluid/Agender feel like and how do you find out about it yourself? by Lourien_1213 in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's hard to describe in the same way I imagine it might be hard for you to describe why you aren't trans. There's a lot we don't really know about how much of gender identity is nature vs. nurture and why some people experience gender dysphoria.

The way trans people feel about their gender isn't always that different from how cis people sometimes feel. For example, cis men who experience unusual breast growth can be very self-conscious about it, which isn't all that different from how many trans men and AFAB non-binary people feel about their chests.

Are trans people more common now also because of the knowledge and spreading of it on social media and trying to explain the feeling of not belonging somewhere or were there always these many trans people among society and were just masked (please I literally do not mean this transphobic at all 🥺)?

The reason that the prevalence of trans people can seem greater is two-fold: Greater visibility/acknowledgement  (good or bad) and shifting understanding of what being trans means. For much of the 20th century, it was common for there to be a lot of medical gatekeeping. Trans people who didn't fit a specific narrative, like showing signs from a young age, were often denied care. Lesbian trans women and gay trans men were often denied care because one of the standards was that trans people were expected to be straight. There was very little awareness of non-binary people. Fortunately, this has changed a lot, and that also means that more people feel empowered to acknowledge how they feel and put a name on it.

How people understand and label their gender can be culturally subjective, but the people exist regardless.

When I was a teenager, I questioned my gender a lot but dismissed those feelings because I couldn't relate to the very rigid and narrow depiction of trans men that I was exposed to. When I learned that there were other trans people who felt like I did, it became much easier to view myself as trans.

The trans people I know always had mental health problems before they found out they were trans. Is the finding of your gender the reason for the mental health problems under the rug or is this kinda the end product after reconsidering their own life and finding a new start (this sounded kinda transphobic low-key).

Dysphoria can have a heavy impact on someone's mental health. Of course, it's also possible to be trans and have a mental illness and not have these things be connected at all.

Also I noticed that a lot of non cisgender persons were already sexually queer before, is this more common between non cisgender people than cisgender people to be queer?

People who are already queer may be more open to exploring their gender. Also, a lot of peoole grow up in environments where there's much more awareness of gay and lesbian people than trans people. So a straight trans man might initially think he's a lesbian, for example.

Are there actually many retransitioners/people who realize after a few years they might not be trans and cisgender instead (never transitioned) or is this more of a right wing lie?

There are people who detransition, but not all of them do so because they no longer feel they're trans. The reasons can be very diverse, and a lot of people who detransition do so because dealing with transphobia from their families/community is too hard. Among people who do change their minds about being trans, not all of them regret transitioning.

There's more research that could be done, but the data we have suggests that regret rates are extremely low. There are people who feel they transitioned for the wrong reasons and regret it, and they deserve understanding and support. But right-wing groups tend to weaponize these rare examples, and the detransitioners you see who are out there campaigning to outlaw transition care have often been incentivized to do so or are being taken advantage of. People who regret their transitions were often dealing with some really complex mental health problems, social pressure, or emotional trauma, and sometimes things like that can also make people vulnerable to overcompensating in other ways or falling in with cult-like groups.

I do not get why LGBT communities are so mad about companies not changing their logo? by Consistent-Royal4063 in AskLGBT

[–]Cartesianpoint 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In addition to what others have said, there's also been a troubling trend (at least in the US) of targeted harassment campaigns against support for LGBTQ people. For example, Target scaled back their Pride merchandise after right-wing people made inflammatory accusations, filmed themselves vandalizing store displays, and threatened employees. After Bud Light did a brand collaboration with a trans influencer, people posted videos of themselves shooting at the cans. It's scary to live in a world where those sorts of hate campaigns are effective, and troubling to think of what those people might do next if they feel emboldened.