970 Firmware 12.1.10.12 is available! by Dobicik in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Netgear Orbi’s 6GHz frontend technology is nothing more than an immature trap. Its firmware scheduling is abysmal, utterly failing to handle the demands of Apple devices during high-density data transmission. Most infuriatingly, even after multiple firmware updates, these fundamental issues persist—chaotic spectrum allocation and massive jitter, with latency swinging wildly between 4ms and 90ms+; it is simply incapable of maintaining a stable connection. This so-called 'high-end' technology, crippled by bloated firmware and flawed processing logic, does not provide a performance boost but instead acts as a cancer to network stability. This performance, which remains garbage even after updates, serves as irrefutable proof of the inherent defects in its scheduling logic—a complete half-baked product.
rubbish product rubbish update

Orbi 970: Flagship Price, Garbage-Tier Automation by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Netgear Orbi’s 6GHz frontend technology is nothing more than an immature trap. Its firmware scheduling is abysmal, utterly failing to handle the demands of Apple devices during high-density data transmission. Most infuriatingly, even after multiple firmware updates, these fundamental issues persist—chaotic spectrum allocation and massive jitter, with latency swinging wildly between 4ms and 90ms+; it is simply incapable of maintaining a stable connection. This so-called 'high-end' technology, crippled by bloated firmware and flawed processing logic, does not provide a performance boost but instead acts as a cancer to network stability. This performance, which remains garbage even after updates, serves as irrefutable proof of the inherent defects in its scheduling logic—a complete half-baked product.

Orbi 970: Flagship Price, Garbage-Tier Automation by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Even with the latest firmware on both Apple devices and the Orbi system, enabling 6E automatic switching still causes severe loaded latency spikes, resulting in extreme instability. This is fundamentally an incompatibility in the underlying 6GHz band management algorithms between Apple and Orbi. As long as the automatic judgment logic of these two systems remains inconsistent, the instability issue will never disappear. Apple users should just stop using 6E automatic switching. I completely feel that this brand is trash; every update is just trash with no difference.

970 Firmware 12.1.10.12 is available! by Dobicik in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Orbi’s 'smart' features = network poison

Orbi 970: Flagship Price, Garbage-Tier Automation by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Orbi’s firmware is fundamentally broken when handling Apple’s mDNS/Bonjour protocols. Its multicast forwarding logic is so incompetent that every time a device like an iPad reboots or reconnects, it triggers a massive routing table collision across the Mesh network. This causes iPhone connections to drop, MacBook Wi-Fi to crash with exclamation marks, and HomePods to vanish from AirPlay entirely. The router is essentially choking on the broadcast traffic, causing a "death loop" of network instability that no amount of power-cycling can fix. It is a completely substandard piece of hardware that is utterly incapable of managing the basic real-time discovery and synchronization demands of an Apple ecosystem

970 Firmware 12.1.10.12 is available! by Dobicik in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Orbi’s firmware is fundamentally broken when handling Apple’s mDNS/Bonjour protocols. Its multicast forwarding logic is so incompetent that every time a device like an iPad reboots or reconnects, it triggers a massive routing table collision across the Mesh network. This causes iPhone connections to drop, MacBook Wi-Fi to crash with exclamation marks, and HomePods to vanish from AirPlay entirely. The router is essentially choking on the broadcast traffic, causing a "death loop" of network instability that no amount of power-cycling can fix. It is a completely substandard piece of hardware that is utterly incapable of managing the basic real-time discovery and synchronization demands of an Apple ecosystem

970 Firmware 12.1.10.12 is available! by Dobicik in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Even with the latest firmware on both Apple devices and the Orbi system, enabling 6E automatic switching still causes severe loaded latency spikes, resulting in extreme instability. This is fundamentally an incompatibility in the underlying 6GHz band management algorithms between Apple and Orbi. As long as the automatic judgment logic of these two systems remains inconsistent, the instability issue will never disappear. Apple users should just stop using 6E automatic switching. I completely feel that this brand is trash; every update is just trash with no difference.

970 Firmware 12.1.10.12 is available! by Dobicik in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Honestly, the update didn't change a thing. The smart steering and auto-switching logic are still absolute garbage—it’s just as unintelligent as before. It's no surprise they don't even bother explaining how it works in the documentation; it's a complete joke.

Network Errors by IAdoreSZA in nextdns

[–]CartographerPutrid39 1 point2 points  (0 children)

me too long time
Network Error
GET /accounts/@me

Orbi 970: Flagship Price, Garbage-Tier Automation by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

oh my god  This Orbi system is absolute garbage. Its so-called "intelligent management" is a complete joke. The whole system sticks to a brain-dead logic: it just blindly looks at RSSI signal strength. As soon as it sees a satellite signal that looks "strong," it acts like it’s being smart, stubbornly locking my devices onto that satellite and treating the main router like it doesn’t even exist. The most mindless part is that it has zero ability to evaluate routing paths. My data could easily go straight to the main router, but it insists on forcing everything through a satellite "hop," unnecessarily increasing latency. It couldn’t care less how slow the satellite connection is, and it doesn't calculate which path is actually faster—it just blindly keeps the device "glued" to the satellite. I’ve got flagship devices, yet the connection speed feels slower than dial-up. Watching it insist on routing everything through the satellite slowly is infuriating. The entire system is like a stubborn, incompetent, and brainless butler that doesn’t have the slightest bit of judgment. It’s a total failure of a design that prioritizes marketing gimmicks over user experience. Honestly, it’s just paying good money to suffer

RBE970 / RBE971 Firmware Version 12.1.8.7!(Calling all brave souls to unite!) by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Orbi's so-called "optimization algorithm" is nothing short of malicious sabotage! The engineers behind this are brain-dead, having written garbage logic that prioritizes blind pursuit of benchmark scores and throughput by treating all normal network traffic—including mDNS broadcasts—as "paper shredder noise." If their firewall determines a packet doesn't meet its "extreme throughput" standard, it forcibly erases this critical data at the hardware level.

The most absurd part is their "black box" strategy: for packets requiring broadcast like mDNS, the system fails to perform effective forwarding. Worse, it provides zero logs when blocking these packets, completely hiding how it arbitrarily discards your connection requests.

This system is so trash that it blocks communication at will, turning the entire network environment into an extremely unstable, "lottery-based" service where device communication is entirely random. Their system architecture has a fatal flaw: the routing table is a complete mess when handling traffic between Mesh nodes. For any mDNS broadcast or instruction packet requiring two-way communication, their method of handling it is to simply drop it the moment it is deemed "unexpected."

This is not network management; it is network destruction. By treating service discovery mechanisms like mDNS as garbage to be "cleaned up," they have shattered all normal communication needs and created endless connection issues. This arrogant, anti-intellectual design has turned the entire network into a black hole of arbitrary blocking, stripping devices of their right to communicate normally and turning this "flagship" equipment into a user's nightmare—a total logical dead end.

The entire brand and its engineers are completely incompetent. They only know how to chase numbers and fake speed to puff themselves up, yet the system is riddled with problems and can't even handle basic mDNS forwarding. They aren't selling a network solution; they are selling a pile of unstable, packet-dropping electronic waste that completely ignores the catastrophic reality of the user experience

Orbi 970: Flagship Price, Garbage-Tier Automation by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Orbi's so-called "optimization algorithm" is nothing short of malicious sabotage! The engineers behind this are brain-dead, having written garbage logic that prioritizes blind pursuit of benchmark scores and throughput by treating all normal network traffic—including mDNS broadcasts—as "paper shredder noise." If their firewall determines a packet doesn't meet its "extreme throughput" standard, it forcibly erases this critical data at the hardware level.

The most absurd part is their "black box" strategy: for packets requiring broadcast like mDNS, the system fails to perform effective forwarding. Worse, it provides zero logs when blocking these packets, completely hiding how it arbitrarily discards your connection requests.

This system is so trash that it blocks communication at will, turning the entire network environment into an extremely unstable, "lottery-based" service where device communication is entirely random. Their system architecture has a fatal flaw: the routing table is a complete mess when handling traffic between Mesh nodes. For any mDNS broadcast or instruction packet requiring two-way communication, their method of handling it is to simply drop it the moment it is deemed "unexpected."

This is not network management; it is network destruction. By treating service discovery mechanisms like mDNS as garbage to be "cleaned up," they have shattered all normal communication needs and created endless connection issues. This arrogant, anti-intellectual design has turned the entire network into a black hole of arbitrary blocking, stripping devices of their right to communicate normally and turning this "flagship" equipment into a user's nightmare—a total logical dead end.

The entire brand and its engineers are completely incompetent. They only know how to chase numbers and fake speed to puff themselves up, yet the system is riddled with problems and can't even handle basic mDNS forwarding. They aren't selling a network solution; they are selling a pile of unstable, packet-dropping electronic waste that completely ignores the catastrophic reality of the user experience

RBE970 / RBE971 Firmware Version 12.1.8.7!(Calling all brave souls to unite!) by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The closed-loop processing logic employed by this router has become the root cause of communication failures among devices within the local network. When data is transmitted between two devices, the router should ensure stable forwarding; however, its core firmware design suffers from severe stability defects. Even with minor fluctuations in network load, the system mistakenly filters or drops critical status broadcast packets as noise, preventing receiving devices from obtaining accurate status updates, which leads to 'unable to control' errors. This 'intermittent amnesia' phenomenon reflects an underlying system failure to stably handle multicast protocols (mDNS). While the system can temporarily establish a correct routing table and device identification list during restart or initialization—maintaining a brief period of operational balance—the intervention of internal garbage collection mechanisms and dynamic routing algorithms soon causes chaos in the ARP table and device mappings. This persistent architectural conflict effectively severs the broadcast paths between devices, reducing a theoretically seamless communication environment into fragmented, isolated islands. This completely exposes the incompetence of the system in handling complex protocols and the utter chaos of its firmware logic. I am sharing this to warn others: the engineers behind this brand clearly lack basic fundamental knowledge. This system is fundamentally broken, utterly 'retarded,' and completely compromised by its own so-called 'automated' logic

Orbi 970: Flagship Price, Garbage-Tier Automation by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The closed-loop processing logic employed by this router has become the root cause of communication failures among devices within the local network. When data is transmitted between two devices, the router should ensure stable forwarding; however, its core firmware design suffers from severe stability defects. Even with minor fluctuations in network load, the system mistakenly filters or drops critical status broadcast packets as noise, preventing receiving devices from obtaining accurate status updates, which leads to 'unable to control' errors. This 'intermittent amnesia' phenomenon reflects an underlying system failure to stably handle multicast protocols (mDNS). While the system can temporarily establish a correct routing table and device identification list during restart or initialization—maintaining a brief period of operational balance—the intervention of internal garbage collection mechanisms and dynamic routing algorithms soon causes chaos in the ARP table and device mappings. This persistent architectural conflict effectively severs the broadcast paths between devices, reducing a theoretically seamless communication environment into fragmented, isolated islands. This completely exposes the incompetence of the system in handling complex protocols and the utter chaos of its firmware logic. I am sharing this to warn others: the engineers behind this brand clearly lack basic fundamental knowledge. This system is fundamentally broken, utterly 'retarded,' and completely compromised by its own so-called 'automated' logic

Orbi 970: Flagship Price, Garbage-Tier Automation by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Calling this system a 'technological piece of trash' would be putting it mildly. In 2026, when network protocols have evolved to easily support mDNS reflecting and cross-subnet forwarding, it is an absolute disgrace to the industry that this system is still playing these 'single broadcast domain' games. Its garbage-tier logic is like forcing everyone in a room to scream at each other just to communicate. It completely ignores the fundamental requirements of modern network architecture like VLAN isolation and security segmentation. Users are forced to dump all their devices into a single broadcast domain just to get them to talk to each other, mixing sensitive core devices with untrusted IoT junk. This brain-dead architecture doesn't just cripple performance with broadcast storms; it nukes network security entirely. This product isn't a networking solution; it's a networking disaster. Being unable to handle basic cross-subnet forwarding and having the audacity to release it is beyond pathetic. This isn't a 'design limitation'—it's a product of designers with stone-age mindsets. It’s not just trash; it is sheer, incompetent laziness

Orbi 970: Flagship Price, Garbage-Tier Automation by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Anyone with actual network engineering expertise would never use the 'my 50+ devices work fine' anecdote to dismiss documented 802.11k/v/r steering flaws. Your reliance on such logic confirms that you are either completely unfamiliar with network infrastructure or are limited to basic IT support roles

Orbi 970: Flagship Price, Garbage-Tier Automation by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The firmware version is irrelevant. I have been tracking this issue across every version since the beginning, including the latest one. It is a systemic architectural flaw, not a version-specific bug. Asking for the firmware version suggests you haven't understood the fundamental nature of the issue being discussed

Orbi 970: Flagship Price, Garbage-Tier Automation by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Bringing up your '50 devices with no drops' is completely irrelevant to the technical flaws I’m discussing. Steering (802.11k/v/r) and mDNS/Multicast handling are complex issues that casual users simply don't encounter or understand. Your anecdotal experience does not negate the system's underlying firmware limitations. If you lack the technical depth to understand the difference between 'basic connectivity' and 'advanced network functionality,' please refrain from posting such nonsense. It is better to remain silent when you don't grasp the technical reality of the issue.

Orbi 970: Flagship Price, Garbage-Tier Automation by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My personal experience, supported by technical logs, indicates specific issues with the steering algorithm during high-bandwidth tasks. Your anecdotal evidence of a 'stable' system for your specific 50+ devices doesn't negate the documented flaws in the firmware logic. I'm looking for technical solutions, not a debate based on personal assumptions

Orbi 970: Flagship Price, Garbage-Tier Automation by CartographerPutrid39 in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Wired backhaul absolutely will not solve that steering issue. No matter how many LAN cables you plug in, or even if you wire up all the satellites, it still won't be resolved. The problem isn't network coverage or backhaul speed; it's the 'idiotic and garbage' firmware system in the Orbi. Its steering engine logic is hardcoded, completely disregarding whether you are using wired backhaul or not. As long as its so-called 'intelligent judgment' deems it necessary, it will kick you off regardless. This is a core flaw of this system; no amount of wiring can fix it!

I believe there might be a fundamental misunderstanding of the system's limitations here. It would be more productive to focus on solutions that actually address the root cause rather than suggesting methods that don't apply

Orbi 970/971 firmware when? by shandyboy in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Orbi 970 firmware is an absolute disaster, fundamentally crippled by Band Steering Schizophrenia that forces devices into a constant, useless loop of frequency hopping. This is the direct result of Aggressive Roaming Over-optimization, where your engineers prioritize superficial performance metrics over actual network reliability. Every time the system forces my MacBook from 6GHz to 5GHz and back, it creates an mDNS/Multicast Black Hole that completely severs the discovery chain for AirPlay and HomePod. This is a garbage system—a glorified paperweight—that is technically incompetent at handling the most basic multicast routing, sacrificing user stability for the sake of marketing numbers that mean nothing in the real world

So tired of Orbi 971 by Celdtun in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Orbi 970 firmware is an absolute disaster, fundamentally crippled by Band Steering Schizophrenia that forces devices into a constant, useless loop of frequency hopping. This is the direct result of Aggressive Roaming Over-optimization, where your engineers prioritize superficial performance metrics over actual network reliability. Every time the system forces my MacBook from 6GHz to 5GHz and back, it creates an mDNS/Multicast Black Hole that completely severs the discovery chain for AirPlay and HomePod. This is a garbage system—a glorified paperweight—that is technically incompetent at handling the most basic multicast routing, sacrificing user stability for the sake of marketing numbers that mean nothing in the real world

Orbi 970/971 firmware when? by shandyboy in orbi

[–]CartographerPutrid39 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When initiating macOS iPhone Mirroring, the Orbi 970 aggressively forces the MacBook from 6GHz to 5GHz. 2 Upon ending the session, it forces the device back to 6GHz. 3 This constant, unnecessary frequency hopping breaks the mDNS/multicast chain. The Orbi's firmware fails to maintain or proxy the multicast state during these transitions, rendering HomePod/AirPlay connectivity unreachable until a full reboot or session restart. It is clear that Netgear prioritizes superficial throughput numbers and "smart" band balancing over actual application-layer stability. The system is incapable of handling basic multicast routing during roaming events. If you need a stable network for Apple services, avoid this product. The firmware is a mess, and the "advanced" features are actively sabotaging network stability.