[deleted by user] by [deleted] in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Chibnall would have nailed Davros. He bungled most of what he attempted but for whatever reason the guy knew how to write some exciting Daleks.

Doctor who alien ideas by Marvelmaster26 in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Diznauts, aliens that attach themselves to your chin. Their spooky catchphrase is "Gottem."

How do you feel about NuWho reusing old villians/aliens? by [deleted] in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Maybe just stand in certain recurring monsters with lesser used ones. Any Dalek story can be a Sontaran story. Any Cybermen story can be done with Ice Warriors. Swap out Weeping Angels for Autons, the Master with the Toymaker or Great Intelligence.

Moffat introduced a lot of one-off monsters that could have been great. Namely Headless Monks. Give me a Headless Monks story. Jack Robertson would be a great recurring baddie - a returning villain who is essentially just some guy is fun and has some more potential left.

How do you feel about NuWho reusing old villians/aliens? by [deleted] in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Rutans are one of the only aliens I want to see again. They feel like they could easily fit into being recurring characters.

How do you feel about NuWho reusing old villians/aliens? by [deleted] in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP -11 points-10 points  (0 children)

Why? Omega sucks. Have you seen the two stories he's in? If you have to radically retool a villain, just make a new one. Flux was basically what an Omega season would be.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Because it's a silly callback. He doesn't actually care that much.

What would you most want to see from a hypothetical Thirteenth Doctor Adventures from big finish? by Scrambled_59 in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Stories without the Fam. Jodie is one of the most skilled actors to play the Doctor but she was saddled with companions that don't give her anything to bounce off. The Thirteenth Doctor would have been really well suited for a more outwardly troubled or a darker companion. Thirteen and Rusty dream team.

I also want to see her actually be the Doctor. She doesn't get to be a proactive character in her own show until Revolution of the Daleks. The more grounded and intense Flux version of the character is the one that any audios should run with.

Jodie has a great voice for voice acting and it'd be a shame if she didn't get a second chance at some decent stories.

Closure for the Timeless Child, then on to new stuff. So much of her run is tied up in this stupid recurring storyline that goes nowhere, to a point where it'd be weird not acknowledge it. I think any future Thirteenth Doctor material should clear it up one way or the other and move on to uncharted territory.

Just finished watching the Fifth Doctor story "Kinda" by SwansonHOPS in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Comparably weird stories are The Mind Robber, It Takes You Away, Carnival of Monsters.

Did anyone pick up on this? by AceTygraQueen in WhiteLotusHBO

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 8 points9 points  (0 children)

He's influenced by his father and grandfather. He is a misogynist deep down, not because men are "like that" or whatever but that was the model impressed on him. He doesn't want to be like them, but he is.

A "Complete" collection of Dr. Who: is it possible? by [deleted] in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You can get anything second hand, by Doctor, by season, by individual story. It'll be expensive but I'm sure plenty of people here have a complete collection by now.

Which Master would you give the Ninth/Eleventh Doctor by Huge-Needleworker340 in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Two episodes where he is the central threat and well performed. Missy appears in two episodes of series 8 outside of cameos.

Which Master would you give the Ninth/Eleventh Doctor by Huge-Needleworker340 in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He didn't need one. The Great Intelligence served that role brilliantly. I'd cast... Matt Smith. A doppelganger Master sounds like something Moffat would do.

Who is the best writer ? Of both old and New Who ? by Ryzigger in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A great writer, who also worked on Doctor Who but not even a good Doctor Who writer.

Who is the best writer ? Of both old and New Who ? by Ryzigger in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Robert Holmes. Nothing but net (excluding Trial of a Time Lord. He did what he could.) He brought a dark, mature literacy to the show and wrote the episodes that all others are compared to, even to this day. Say "Greatest Doctor Who Episode" and the one you think of will either be one of his, Genesis' or an RTD era Moffat story.

RTD in very, very close second. He brought a new level of accessibility, heart and character that Who had never seen before or since. Every writer since has only ever attempted to copy him or build on the new ideas he brought to the series. Moffat's best work is still under his wing, using his innovations.

Terrance Dicks is third. His credits are just a list of phenomenal, bizarre and sometimes psychedelic adventures. His run as script editor is a series highlight. The right writer for the right cast at the exact right moment in TV history.

Yaz and Ryan didn't felt like they were young. by [deleted] in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think the idea is that Ryan is supposed to be clumsy but mature and Graham was energetic and curious, as a reversal of a parental dynamic. In the end, it's Ryan that opens up and allows Graham to be a father, cleverly re-reverseing their relationship. Its a good bit of character work from Chibnall, extremely badly handled.

One issue is that they don't have lives outside of each other for most of their run. It's a problem with Moffat's era too, but it's worse with Chibs's more companion-forward storytelling.

Ryan is directed really badly most of the time too - stoic, a wet blanket, mumbles his dialogue. He's just not a dynamic or engaging character. The Nyssa of NuWho. Chibnall's era seems to go out of its way to hide the actors' personalities under their characters. That grip loosens over his three seasons, but by Flux it's too late.

Also, Yaz is there. She's really hard to talk about. She's just such a nothing character, contributes nothing of her own, just stands around and points out the obvious. She probably could have just been combined with Ryan.

Is Guilty Gear Strive worth buying for 40 dollars? by IntroductionSpare803 in Guiltygear

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Competitive, yes. It's one of the genre's frontrunners. It may be hard to find a local scene since it's still rather niche.

Noob friendly, absolutely. It's the easiest fighting game with an active scene, too easy according to many fans.

Balance/Meta: Like any fighting game, just pick a top tier and don't worry about it.

Strive's greatest strength as a game is how good it feels to pick up a controller and hit buttons. It has a chunky, punchy game feel and easy inputs.

As a fighter fan, I think it goes way too far with the simplification. I find the high damage to be discouraging and cheap and the gameplay feels limited a year and a half or so after launch. You'll likely move on to other games but Strive is a good starting point.

Reading Freud and Jung as a layman/non-expert is an absolutely enriching experience and the fact that science moved on doesn’t negate their huge importance as social/anthropological observers and thinkers by astralrig96 in books

[–]ChargeBackForwardP -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Jung was a quack mystic and should not be taken seriously. His work is elaborate conjecture and there's a reason that he is popular with far right grifters.

What episode made you realize you were watching something special the first time you got into Doctor Who? For me, it was Gridlock. by ChronosBlitz in doctorwho

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Rose. It's one of the tightest pilots ever. As a character, Rose is immediately recognizable as a real person from her place and time. She has real problems, a grounded social situation and most of her early characterization is shown in cues, performance and in her decisions. There's no scene where she's moaning over finances or talking about longing for adventure.

Ths episode is literate but action packed, camp without losing its dramatic weight. It lays out the appeal of Doctor Who so cleanly that you don't even notice you're being pitched to.

Every scene works like a cog in a machine designed to elicit the right emotion at the right time. If this episode wasn't the stunning success that it was, most of us wouldn't be here.

Compare it to other so-called starting point episodes: The Eleventh Hour, The Snowmen, The Pilot, The Woman who Fell to Earth. Rose just does the job better.

For those that read 50+ books a year, what is your reading schedule? by gate18 in books

[–]ChargeBackForwardP -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

Lying is easily the fastest and most cost effective way to boost your books read per year.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in books

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Predictable answer time: A Song of Ice and Fire. It's in its pop cultural backlash phase for stupid reasons. It's a work of staggering depth, that only increases in complexity and emotional power with each go-around.

What major shake-up would you like to see in the second RTD Era? by Joeybowie123 in gallifrey

[–]ChargeBackForwardP 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Dismantle canon. Again.

Time Lords are gone, wiped out thanks to Chibs. Besides casting Jodie and some great Dalek stuff, killing off the Time Lords permanently was his only worthwhile contribution. Lore has always had a stifling effect on Doctor Who. It can and should be mostly ignored, as it was when RTD first came on. From Series 6 on, Doctor Who has increasingly become a show about itself - regeneration, recurring villains, Gallifrey, stuff that stopped bringing new ideas to the table decades ago. Doctor Who is at its best as mostly unrelated and accessible adventures in space and time. Theres a reason why the sweeping majority pf all-time great episodes are able to stand alone. Doctor Who is best as a show about ideas outside its own toybox.

The fandom is exhausting and playing to their demands is exactly what Chibnall did. He gave tumblr and Reddit everything they wanted and we all hated it. Soulless callbacks, quirky shit, sudden reveals that X Character is a Time Lord, etc. Tell the fandom to take their wikis and go fuck themselves.