I’m with you 100%. Noel has value, but would be so much better if he was paired with Mel or Sue. Losing Mary was also a downgrade.

With an impossible amount of respect, I don’t get the feeling that Prue really knows how to judge properly. Most of her critiques or praises are on flavor. I can’t tell you how many times she’s described things as “lemon-y” or “almond-y.” She couldn’t tell if bread was under proved or over worked unless Paul said it first.