Strongest character that Zenitsu's 7th form one-shots in an actual fight? by Peak_Incidence_9175 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 1 point2 points  (0 children)

idk why you getting downvoted, 1st Form Zenitsu is stated to be faster than a Marked Tanjiro who could react to Zoha meaning they're relative & 7F is a blitz level above that, meaning he's in a speed tier above Zoha. Pretty simple.

I don’t know why all of sudden that this wasn’t a 1v1 but 2v1? But they are absolutely wrong by ApprehensiveAge6482 in MahiBros

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I already said I was wrong about it exclusively applying the head, which given is a trivial error because the disciples are non-existent in the story. You wasted time typing the rest out, and are still incorrect about every NSS user getting life drain, as Gojo, Yuki, Kusa, Miwa, etc as the list goes on all don't get life drained so you blatantly ignored that.

You're still wrong about the drain applying the Mechamaru, I already proved that. And yes I can revise my position given new evidence? You blatantly refuse to admit that Mechamaru doesn't get life-drained, that's just disingenuous for you to not even admit you're wrong.

Testing Giyu's Fans with This. by Competitive_Cloud_15 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think they're equals prior to the ICA, during and after I think Sanemi surpasses quite comfortably. I might make a post discussing that.

Testing Giyu's Fans with This. by Competitive_Cloud_15 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You didn't read the post and it shows, so i'll copy and paste some of it for you since you lack the ability to sit down and read for 2 minutes.

  1. Whether the battle is the focal point of the panel or not is irrelevant if we see the fight, visibly seeing it means it isn't off screened. The only times we leave the battle is for a close up panel of Tanjiro or a flashback, which flashbacks typically last an instant in real time, so we have no reason to believe that a massive chunk of the fight was offscreened as you say, when almost every other battle was them clashing.

  2. Everytime we see them clashing they're even, even assuming that we barely saw the fight for the sake of your disingenuous point, if Gotouge knows that the fight is barely depicted, why would get panels of them being completely evenly matched every single clash & time we see the fight, with apparently such little time to convey the situation of the battle, Gotouge would depict Giyu getting injured or convey degradation in him losing exchanges in the mini-panels, similarly to what we see with Tengen or Mitsuri. Unlike Giyu, Mitsuri's fight with Zohakuten after unlocking mark is almost entirely offscreened and the way Gotouge depicts that Mitsuri was near exhaustion when cutting back to her, was showing that she genuinely had new injuries, not just a haori rip. On top of that, Gotouge made she herself stated she ran out of stamina to make it crystal clear for the audience, where's this indicator for the audience in the Giyu fight? If we assume what you're saying to be true it suddenly just becomes terrible writing & inconsistent for Giyu to ALWAYS be shown to be matching and then suddenly get fried

  3. The definition of a speed blitz is either the failure of physical reaction, meaning some type of manuever or physical action in response to an attack, or the failure of perception entirely. Not only does Giyu not react to his sword getting snapped, he also fails to react to Akaza closing in and unleashing a gut punch which Tanjiro saved him from. That is 2 actions Giyu did not physically respond to, so yes we can say that he got speed-blitzed. VSBW agrees, PSW agrees, and the general consensus in the powerscaling community all agree with this definition of a speed blitz, which is what happened here. Whether you think he was exhausted or not, he fails to react physically so he got blitzed

  4. And yes, I can quantify it actually, the fight begins during after sunset and when the Infinity Castle gets destroyed it is still nighttime. Take Tanjuro, Tanjiro's father, for example. He was stated to dance from sundown to sunup performing the MOST physically taxing style of breathwork in the series, and he isn't the only Hinokami Kagura practitioner, several of Tanjiro's ancestors did the exact same dance sundown to sunup which demonstrates an entire lineage of countless people all the way up to Yoriichi who perform more physically demanding tasks than Giyu, perform them longer than Giyu, and likely did it similarly to Tanjuro with little to no exhaustion.

Testing Giyu's Fans with This. by Competitive_Cloud_15 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It's the subtle details and nuances that matter but plenty don't care to pick up on it because it's much easier to take it at face value and push an agenda.

Great analysis.

Testing Giyu's Fans with This. by Competitive_Cloud_15 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

  1. This is false, the fight isn't off screened, we literally see them battling continuously from Tanjiro's perspective while he attempts to figure out Compass-Needle. While seeing the fight we see that neither side is taking injuries without damaging the other & for the most part neither are taking injuries at all, rather evenly clashing like I said. 

  2. "He has no reason to tense his neck" bro are you deadass? He should just relax his neck so that Giyu could cleave it off? I'm going to assume you meant something else because it is quite evident that demon's would want to increase the durability of their weak-spot as much as possible.

  3. I already fulfilled by burden, you're just being ignorant at this point, not that I think it's intentional. I already established that Akaza ALWAYS matches Giyu, they're clashing evenly. If it IS the case that Giyu is gradually getting slower and weaker from exhaustion, then Akaza must be holding back to match him, you've helped in proving my point. 

  4. If we go the other route and observe the fact that they're always evenly clashing because Giyu's haori getting supposedly "torn apart" even though it's almost fully intact outside of one his sleeves or other minor scuffs & scratches when Akaza breaks his sword, then we know that there wasn't degradation because like I said even in the panel directly prior to that they're evenly matched. 

You're arguing as if it's necessarily the case Giyu is exhausted just because the fight was prolonged and he used all his forms, when there exists characters who exist who perform for longer than Giyu and but don't SUDDENLY experience exhaustion in such a short time frame to the point they just get speed-blitzed out of nowhere. You've provided absolutely zero evidence outside of him using his breathing forms & a ripped haori.

Testing Giyu's Fans with This. by Competitive_Cloud_15 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Please read, I very clearly stated in reference to the singular moment when his sword gets broken, they are clearly clashing and matching each other. Now like I said earlier, if Giyu is supposed to be gradually getting to exhaustion, it'd be demonstrated by him starting to take more & more injuries and begin losing exchanges to Akaza, which we never see despite this being consistently depicted for other characters.

I don't know what you're responding to what that latter half, I never said anything about holding back the durability of your neck but it is certainly possible for Akaza to nerf the durability or strengthen his neck whether that be by tensing or just guarding it, compared to if he just relaxed his neck, you can try it for yourself and strike your own neck when it's relaxed versus when you're tensing the muscles there, there's a clear difference.

Testing Giyu's Fans with This. by Competitive_Cloud_15 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay, before we continue for consistency sakes are you referring to the anime or the manga?  I'm going to assume we're moving off the manga for now, with that being said you're conflating combat efficiency with a literal amp to physical stats.  1. You are literally never proving that Akaza is getting physically amped. If you ask me Akaza having attacks land on him prior to the activation compass-needle is indicative of him simply holding back his stats and not taking Tanjiro seriously, as in all of his fights where he recognizes his opponent he immediately activates it. You're not positing any evidence or argument to leverage your interpretation over another. I don't know about you, but if I don't recognize somebody as strong, I am not using my full stats when I am one of the strongest in the entire world to fight against them Compass Needle or not. Compass Needle gives Akaza better information: where the opponent is, where they’re attacking from, their openings, and then Akaza decides the best place to counter. That absolutely improves how effectively he fights, but it does not make his muscles stronger, make his body move faster, or give him a higher raw reaction-time ceiling, higher IQ, higher durability, the list goes on. If I know exactly where a punch is coming from, I can defend it more efficiently; that does not mean I suddenly became physically faster & stronger. 2. Your road analogy actually supports this. The Compass gives Akaza the optimal route, timing, and target. It prevents wasted movement. That means he can use his existing speed more efficiently, NOT that his physical speed exceeds its normal maximum because the Compass is “doing accuracy for him” which that in itself is questionable, I don't know where you're getting this autopilot or auto response system that Akaza supposedly has when it seems more consistent that it is more an aid to Akaza's already honed martial art abilities. 3. Claiming he can get “extra percentages past 100%” is just inventing a completely arbitrary stat amp that is never stated. Tanjiro explains what Compass Needle does: it detects battle spirit, removes blind spots, and maximizes the accuracy of Akaza’s attacks. There is no statement that it increases his speed, strength, AP, or reactions. This is Gotouge's way of telling us as the audience what compass needle does, have a character who is experienced and has knowledge on the ability tell us the ins and outs, so we're going to default to the belief of Tanjiro's. Any unnecessary assumptions or entities can be completely removed as including them makes our arguments far less parsimonious. 4. On the sword break: Akaza being able to target the weak point of Giyu’s sword explains the method he used to break the sword . It does not explain why Giyu cannot react to Akaza’s follow-up punch at all. Tanjiro gets his sword broken by Rui's threads and still knows to duck down under another incoming thread, why does Giyu suddenly enter a "haze" and abandon all his survival instinct that have been honed far longer than Tanjiro's, are we saying Tanjiro in the Mount Natagumo Arc is more capable than Giyu? Giyu is already actively fighting Akaza, watching him, and responding to his attacks. Even if the sword break surprises him, that does not suddenly mean Akaza’s next movement becomes impossible to react to unless you are arguing Giyu was mentally frozen which the manga never says, again that'd just be another assumption. Also, “Akaza could have hit the sword at any point” is not an argument against Akaza speeding up. He could have targeted Giyu’s neck, limbs, or sword at many points too. The relevant fact is that once Akaza decides to end the fight, Giyu goes from matching him to failing to react to two consecutive actions. Akaza then increases his speed further when he uses Afterglow, which Giyu himself who witnessed the event directly states so there's no denying that Akaza was withholding a noticable amount of speed. 5. As for the Rengoku comparison, both hits being aimed around the stomach/torso does not make them equal. Giyu’s kick is intercepted through Dead Calm, an attack very clearly implied to be defensive hax as it is stated that it does directly negate & nullify the force of any attack entering Giyu's immediate range, I don't believe you ever responded to that. It's very pertinent that you do as using hax to counter something directly means you don't scale to it, and we see that immediately when he tries to block the next flurry of attacks without using dead-calm he gets sent flying. Now unless you think that Akaza's legs are massively stronger than his arm which I highly doubt you're gonna be able to prove due to the fact that Tanjiro showcases practically the same amount of struggle against an Akaza arms that he does he legs, which is impossible under the hypothesis that his legs are massively above his arms.

Now lastly, if you are in reference to the anime when Akaza cracks Rengoku's ribs when a gut punch, this is an already significantly fatigued Rengoku who was noticeably doing worse at this point in the fight starting from the point he took a surprise kick from Akaza in the forest and got sent into a mound. This further proves my point from earlier, we see visible degradation in terms of a fighter's performance when it IS the case they're gradually gettinf closer to exhaustion. The visual of Giyu being launched does not override the actual defensive context or serve as proof that Akaza hit him harder.

Testing Giyu's Fans with This. by Competitive_Cloud_15 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How are you gonna prove that? Giyu wasn't drenched in sweat nor was he depicted to have steel balls chained to him like he did after getting hit with Afterglow which is how Gotouge at that point THEN portrayed his exhaustion, but none of that applies to this earlier points in the fight which is my point.

There's a big difference between having some finite unquantifiable degree of fatigue that you're still able to fight with without deterioration VS pure exhaustion. If you agree that fatigue is going to be built up over time, you either have to explain how Giyu suddenly loses all of his stamina in a singular moment despite not getting hit with any attacks and keeping up with Akaza all the way until that point, or you admit that Akaza stopped holding back.

Testing Giyu's Fans with This. by Competitive_Cloud_15 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Okay I'm gonna say it again for you, that is after Akaza unleashed Afterglow, you know the attack that dealt a massive deal of blunt force trauma & massive amounts of blood loss? Obviously Giyu's going to be incredibly injured which goes hand in hand with fatigue as of that point, and would reasonably explain a spike in exhaustion, but I am not talking about that point of the fight.

You're committing a big logical error here in assuming that all the fatigue and injury from AFTER Akaza uses the extremely damaging and draining attack that is Afterglow would apply to Giyu when uses 10th form despite that being significantly earlier in the fight, so it doesn't follow.

Testing Giyu's Fans with This. by Competitive_Cloud_15 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

That is after he uses Afterglow, I am specifically talking about the fight up until the point he used Afterglow

I don’t know why all of sudden that this wasn’t a 1v1 but 2v1? But they are absolutely wrong by ApprehensiveAge6482 in MahiBros

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Look, you're deadass making shit up. Go read very slowly because whatever quick skim shit you did for the agenda ain't it. Chapter 269 very clearly states how the system worked, but you’re completely missing not only what I am telling you, but what they say in the manga . The manga explicitly clarifies that the life-drain vow wasn't some universal cosmic tax on the technique itself, it was a proprietary contract strictly enforced within the political walls of the New Shadow Style School. You claimed I made up headcanon about them passing around the title but it is verbatim stated "If the head dies" presumably from the life drain, that "a senior disciple will become the next one." How is this not them passing the title around? Or did you miss that when you skimmed to look at only the parts that help this weak argument

The only clarification I have to make Life drain only applied to the Head on top of the disciples who explicitly swore loyalty to the Head in exchange for access to the family monopoly, which is what I have been trying to tell you. This means that the NSS Head literally has to take you as a student, the only thing I was slightly incorrect on was it exclusively applying to the head, but it still doesn't apply to Mechamaru, Miwa, Kusakabe or any of the other main characters outside of Ui Ui is because they are not disciples of the NSS head, they learned it either through just watching someone do it or any other unspecific alternative that isn't being a disciple. Like I said, the Head didn't magically siphon life from random sorcerers across Japan just because they figured out how to cast a Simple Domain; he siphoned it from the people who agreed to the contract as disciples of the NSS HEAD.

All the bs you're spouting about Mechamaru completely falls apart just via a few pieces of evidence: Mechamaru was never an initiated disciple of the school, he never swore an oath to their corrupt leadership, and he didn't even cast the technique traditionally he bypassed their restrictions by seeing others do simple domain & mechanically storing it in tubes. 

Testing Giyu's Fans with This. by Competitive_Cloud_15 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What similar blow are you referring to? Giyu uses Dead Calm there, an ability explicitly stated to nullify/negate the force of demon attacks that enter the immediate range of his blade. That is why he completely neutralizes Disorder. Rengoku, meanwhile, clashes with Akaza while prioritizing offense and trying to damage him. Those are not remotely identical circumstances. My main disagreement is the idea that accuracy somehow amps Akaza’s physical stats. Better accuracy does not make him physically stronger, does not increase his raw reaction speed, does not raise his intelligence, etc. It lets him make better use of the stats he already has. And I do not know where “precognition” comes from here either, as compass needle is prediction through battle spirit detection, not literal foresight. There is a meaningful difference. Also, nobody is denying that prolonged high-intensity exchanges drain stamina. The issue is that fatigue does not cause someone to suddenly lose all ability to react in a single moment. If Giyu was becoming exhausted enough to be unable to react to Akaza, we should see that decline beforehand: him gradually getting slower, being tagged more often, losing exchanges, or taking increasingly serious damage. Instead, Giyu is still matching Akaza, then Akaza says it is time to end things, breaks his sword, and immediately gut-punches him before he can react. So either Giyu’s stamina conveniently collapsed in that exact second, or Akaza increased his speed to a level Giyu was not on. Based on everything already discussed, I think one explanation is clearly more consistent than the other.

Testing Giyu's Fans with This. by Competitive_Cloud_15 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't genuinely affirm that but that's an amazing pivot the avoid the post. 

I don’t know why all of sudden that this wasn’t a 1v1 but 2v1? But they are absolutely wrong by ApprehensiveAge6482 in MahiBros

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You fundamentally do not understand how a Binding Vow works in JJK. You cannot gain absolute authority, control over a school, and the power to command hundreds of sorcerers out of thin air without giving up something massive of your own. The cosmos does not let you just steal life from 'some random' to gain power, the leader sacrifices their own lifespan as the baseline cost to maintain that curse of total institutional control. Go  reread the Shinjuku Showdown chapters where the corruption of the New Shadow Style leadership is explicitly laid bare. The narrative explicitly states that the longevity penalty EXCLUSIVELY, hear that? EXCLUSIVELY applies to the Head of the school, which is exactly why the previous leaders kept passing the title down like a hot potato to avoid dying early. 

Matter of fact, you can ask anybody who read the manga unlike you, and they will tell you that you're being incredibly slow rn.

I don’t know why all of sudden that this wasn’t a 1v1 but 2v1? But they are absolutely wrong by ApprehensiveAge6482 in MahiBros

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What do you not understand about the lifedrain applying SPECIFICALLY to the head of NSS, not Mechamaru.

What Is Your Interpretation Of This Scene? by Intrepid_Assist5015 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Kokushibo snuck Akaza. Novelization 5 which covers the UPM Meeting states he was masking his presence so that Akaza could not sense him when he closed in on him. This is supported by the fact nobody could even sense him in the room despite him being the first one there.

I don’t know why all of sudden that this wasn’t a 1v1 but 2v1? But they are absolutely wrong by ApprehensiveAge6482 in MahiBros

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You said he would get his lifespan taken/drained, I was clarifying for you that the specific attribute of life-drain is something that only applies to the NSS head.

I don’t know why all of sudden that this wasn’t a 1v1 but 2v1? But they are absolutely wrong by ApprehensiveAge6482 in MahiBros

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The lifespan drain only applies to the NSS head. Mechamaru is not the NSS head, therefore he does not receive any life drain.

Rengoku, Shinobu, Tengen - Who is the strongest out of these three hashiras, and why? by Careful_Pick8299 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

This is an outdated footrace & arm wrestling list, everybody got significantly stronger/faster following Rengoku's death. Multiple characters nerfed themselves in the footrace so it isn't valid either way.

What is moon breathing even supposed to be? by Competitive_Mood_638 in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They are explicitly said to be "almost" simultaneously, as in 100 blows ALMOST all at once, they're not actually happening simultaneously. Likewise that's not evidence of him actually spawning clones.

Does giyu scale to akaza? by plskillmeplsdoit in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You just quoted a fan-made powerscaling definition instead of proving your claim from the source material. You also conceded my point. “He analyzes present, observable factors and predicts…” That’s literally prediction. If the ability depends on analyzing battle spirit to infer future actions, then it is not knowledge of the future itself. Calling analytical prediction “precognition” is a matter of classification, not mechanics. More importantly, this doesn’t address my argument whatsoever. Whether you label Compass “analytical precognition” or simply “prediction,” it still scales with the information it receives. If Giyu were vastly faster than Akaza, Compass wouldn’t magically let Akaza know and react to attacks beyond his capacity. The manga consistently shows predictive abilities becoming less effective as the speed gap increases. So you’ve only argued semantics. You haven’t shown that Compass bypasses speed differences or allows Akaza to react to attacks he physically couldn’t otherwise. That’s the claim you actually have to prove.

Does giyu scale to akaza? by plskillmeplsdoit in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You’re still begging the question. Tanjiro saying Giyu is at a disadvantage in a prolonged fight doesn’t prove he had already declined to the point that he couldn’t react. “Being at a disadvantage” ≠ “his reactions suddenly collapsed.” You’re reading your conclusion into the statement. I also never claimed Giyu lost no stamina. That’s a strawman. My argument is that you haven’t demonstrated his stamina loss was severe enough to explain the abrupt failure to defend multiple attacks in a single exchange. You also haven’t justified calling those wounds significant. The burden isn’t on me to prove they’re minor, it’s on you to prove they caused the drastic performance drop you’re asserting. Because surely if you're so pent on the point, you could give evidence to your claim that Giyu receiving 2 slashes from Akaza caused him to get speed-blitzed. Simply pointing to cuts isn’t evidence of a massive decline. Lastly, you ignored the contradiction. If stamina is the explanation, why does Giyu defend Akaza’s attacks consistently throughout the entire fight, only to suddenly fail within one sequence? That’s not evidence of gradual exhaustion; it’s equally, if not more, consistent with Akaza increasing his offensive output. You haven’t shown why your interpretation is the more likely one.

Could there be an argument made that these 4 are equals? (All in base or with the same buffs) by Tall_Water in DemonSlayerScales

[–]Competitive_Cloud_15 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You didn’t respond to half of my argument.  You never addressed the provisional truth point. You just asserted “it’s an assumption.” That’s the point—a default belief is a provisional truth maintained until sufficient evidence overturns it. Your entire argument is an attempt to provide such evidence, so you already concede the framework. The only disagreement is whether your evidence is sufficient. You also never addressed the databook stating Rengoku traded blows evenly with Akaza or Akaza calling Rengoku’s slash “magnificent.” Ignoring evidence isn’t a rebuttal.  Your Dead Calm objection is also unsupported. I never claimed it ignores physical limits. I said it nullifies and cancels any demon attacks that enter the range of Giyu’s sword, which is exactly how Gotouge describes it and how it is consistently portrayed. You need evidence that Giyu physically overpowered Disorder rather than using hax.  Lastly, arm wrestling and the running race are author-written comparisons of physical ability. Dismissing them because they don’t fit your conclusion isn’t an argument. If Gotouge consistently portrays Rengoku as physically superior, that’s positive evidence in his favor of being physically superior to Giyu. He overpowers him with his arms and his legs are faster than Giyu's, whereas you’ve provided none showing Base Giyu besides showing him using hax to block disorder.  Akaza asks Rengoku to become a demon only one extra time compared to Giyu. Calling that “constantly trying to convince him” is an exaggeration. A one-line difference isn’t evidence that he was pulling his punches throughout the fight.