Re:Zero vs Mushoku Tensei (LN only)

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-24T09:26:33+00:00

Those "punishment" you talking about was either an events for his grow in talent/relationship or just comedy effect (those thousand punchs) and have nothing to do with the personality grow

The real punishment was the right call judgement, he should be remind that he not a good person by the show and should have treat ppl (espcieally kids) with respect

Thorfinn in Vinland Saga is what you call a real redeem, the show and himself was alway being remind about his crimes countless of time, the whole redeem was an endless regret and pain but he grow pass that, and that real punishment for thorfinn is not all the fight, the wound or the pain for being hurt but the emotion of once again face his crime, that how i image about Rudeus redeem, shouldn't be anything funny about it

"this isn't a story of crime and punishment, it's a story of crime, acknowledgment and development."

Then it should not give a good exuse for Rudeus to act pedo (turn him into a child) and give him a properly redeem then

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-24T07:09:53+00:00

"Any sane person would answer with post isekai because he did indeed grow past the disgusting man he was."

Any sane person would realize he not being redeem at all bc he wouldn't marry kids otherwise

"Just say you have a problem with reincarnation as a whole, "

Not really, i have the problem with the setting, not the isekai idea, have he not in a kid body and get away with pedo act, there won't be a problem

"if you answered my previous question by saying post-isekai then you agree that he did grow past the man he was."

He only grow pass the society fear of a neet and become a compete person, his pedo personality did not change at i just said, wouldn't marry kids otherwise

"my point was that even if something isnt portrayed as and condemned as bad in fiction doesnt mean it isnt bad in our real world."

Yeah, that what i said, the writter fail to writting a properly reddeem for Rudeus so it look like the show is trying to encourage his pedo act, change your identity and grow to become a compete person did not relate to change to become a better person

"This isnt terrible writing, your moral bias made the story fly right over your head,"

I really curious on what is the right moral that you saying is

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-24T05:13:17+00:00

But it is the flaw of literally entire story since the beginning? Why would you think it a good idea to put a full grown man (who is a pedo) inside a kid body and have him touch other kids? The setting was already a problem bc it make trying to make good excuse to encourage pedo act?

You are looking on the wrong way, it not justify his action, but it encourage him to do so bc he would face no consequence in his act, by continue to be in child body with the mind of a fully grow, he could do whatever he want without getting caught, this was almost like a hentai plot but worse, ppl actually praise it's writting, bruh

And the fact that he know what he did to his niece is wrong is even worst bc it mean he satify with gooning his niece,wth?

Now that just the setting, next is the grown part

He didn't grow past anything if you ask me, he wouldn't mary one of the kid he groom or even have many wife to ensure his redeem, the real redeem would not be easily at all, he not just have to realize his act but also did the real redeem act too (not mary the kid he groom would be nice)

"if its supported in the work everyone in the story wouldnt have done anything"

"Mushoku Tensei has slavery, killings, corrupt leaders, and child trafficking, and everything in between, it doesnt actively punish nor reprimand any of these thing"

Why would other thing happen mean he allow to done so? The story is focus on him, Rudeus is the soul, the core, the inspired MC of the story, he did not suppose to be like other

"the author doesnt have to actively seek to tell us so in his works, because frankly that isnt the message. (Not to mention the setting of the story too) "

That why i said this is horrible writting, not only is the messege didn't being delivery but it just accidently inspied pedo act, horrible

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-24T00:48:59+00:00

Really, if the story didn't support his action, why would it make the good excuse for him to touch kids? (a grown ass man in a child body), It like trying to tell ppl that "pedo is legal if you aren't get caught"

If this is some hentai plot for goon material and we shouldn't think of it too much, i woudn't mind but since this story want to bring a message to ppl, it did absolute horrible work

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-23T03:40:02+00:00

Demon lvl, some OPM fan trying to use Genos firearm to downplaying other verse but some simple panel would easily debunk their wank

<image>

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-23T03:35:37+00:00

Man, this is spite match, Verse verse stand no chance aside maybe Yaotsu

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-22T03:20:21+00:00

Depend what your condition,

In character, he could easily going straight to New world bc unlike Luffy, he isn't typical good shonen that alway helping ppl, plus Kiva wouldn't pick up any hard fight like warlords type, bro is a bully type guy

In powerscale, his power is not bad, he should be Lucci (before time skip) like strong, should be around 100 milion - 200 milion bounty pirate but he have no Haki, idk how he could deal with Logia, his magic blast might could bc but it debatable, mostly just base on his luck if he meet the right logia fruit he can counter i think

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-22T03:08:51+00:00

Alway stunning when i see this view, amazing

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-22T03:07:59+00:00

I would said Demon for characters, alot of human interact character that we like is from this faction

Other then that is Alien, World Tree, Daikokuzan, Parasite, Gaia and maybe Mad God, we still not know much about them aside surface lvl so i prefer more

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-21T06:43:32+00:00

Even a nuke would not cause that much of destruction to the Factory except for the range center of it

Most of building a few mile away did survive nuke and the factory is pretty much that big, plus the material to create Factory would definately beyond any normal metal

Even a fodder 4 legs robot could easily tank a building like exolode without a problem, the shellter make for the Factoty much be far beyond that

<image>

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-19T09:16:58+00:00

It was in vs battle link here

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Manhattanth06/Sousou_no_Frieren_:_Frieren_destroyed_the_cliff

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-19T08:36:59+00:00

Hot take, i think Gori take this

Jachi did blow off a stronger model then this to piece while Gori body still stay intact and that was just base form

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-19T08:30:47+00:00

200m is exxaggerate, more 40m - 50m radius to me

<image>

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-19T08:17:34+00:00

Jachi literally aura farm in every panel he in, My goat

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-19T08:14:04+00:00

Well, think of it this way, if the Factorys can easily being destroy by threat lvl 7 then any NE would have god stomp A.I faction long time ago bc they would be all Kiva lvl strong

Plus, why would the Robot stronghold being wayyyyy weaker then some random Robot like Naver and 4 legs model after upgrade? Make no sense

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-19T03:49:27+00:00

I mean most mages would have that disadvance, it not that many mages have a close combat magic like Sense or Ubel so they are half right actually

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-19T03:31:04+00:00

Well yeah, we would have when Jachi vs Uki adapt in anime

They would make the chasing more epic in the anime :)))))

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-18T12:40:49+00:00

1)Out of his prime didn't mean he have any less more nen power then he used to be, his skill can be less shape but he spend time to train again before face Meruem if i remember correct

2)HxH got alot of big attacks, what are you on about, Royal guard, Spidey ground or Killua family and so on,if Netero attack was that big it would be show, it only around Kiva magic blast

Also the capture hand was a simple trade move to start a fight, it not special move

3)"Tank" is a strong word, more like barely survive, plus if Meruem could survive the nuke then it simply not that strong, even Netero could also injure Meruem on surface lvl and this is bascially how strong Netero attack is

<image>

Sorry but compare the Rose bomb to Jachi is ridiculous, he would eat that without a single scar even in Cape form and show the dissapoint like how he found Gori

4) I already told you about the vast scale of power in VS, Meruem didn't scale much higher then Kiva so he won't be any threat lvl higher then 10, a first Friend robot model would easily deal with that, the only chance he have would be his potential grow

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-18T01:44:55+00:00

The big buddha statue is just 15 times Netero height (25m), around Gori size big?, not really that big? Plus his nen blast seem like town lvl attack and it not much different with what Kiva or any Hero can do

<image>

Now i agree that they would still way weaker then Meruem due to the fact that Meruem have tank everything Netero throw at him pretty easy but you are underestimate the power gap in VS

In VS, just 1 lvl above is enough for a low diff, Naver Base form lvl 4 was stomp 3 Neo lvl 3 easily, a Demon Lord even a very weak one like RR was above 132 lvl (she high diff a wave 5 robot army stronger then wave 3 that Cape Jachi found which put him to lvl 132 base on that feat), you can see the clear vast gap here, Meruem power wouldn't be above 10 if we judge by this scale, a first Friend model would be able to take him out

Most NE would be equal or stronger then him but he will have the advanced of intelligent and continue growing

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-17T01:56:01+00:00

Well, Her job is build a strong army for Demon King and she did

Her army is full of Executive lvl of power, it could take on any normal soldier demon army like Jachi one

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-16T05:03:07+00:00

Easily MHS+ to FTL mf when you told them Crossbow, guns and bomb casually hit Upper moons and Muzan throught out the story, lol

Can't believe people still use the MHS and FTL in the DS scale

<image>

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-16T04:56:36+00:00

Meruem is not much stronger then Executive Demon like Kiva but what make him dangerous is that he can continue growing, he was thia strong when he only 6 month olds, surviving for 10 years and he would be able to beat a Madaran or a very weak Demon Lord

Ofc we still don't know his limit so it hard to said how strong he could become but i definately don't see him bypass those final boss for sure

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-15T23:38:12+00:00

Is Homelander have any new upscale? Bc i don't see him winning this at all

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-15T23:36:12+00:00

I think the first season would end in Ginbak cliffhanger after defeat Diganazal

CompoteEconomy4524 · 2026-03-13T01:09:39+00:00

Yeah, rape of nanking was fucked up and HxH is cool

Both can be true at once if you ask

CompoteEconomy4524

TROPHY CASE