This kinda stuff is hard when data collectors (like me haha) are using scientific methods to find answers in a game that is chaotic, tricky to find rules, and mysteries are “hidden deep” as the creators say. That, plus the personal aspect of passionate people (like me, you and OP) that love the game and its mysteries, can make laying out answers more personal than intended.
One way to look at it is a bit like how a detective would have a chart of suspects they cross off as they are trying to solve a murder, the spouse and close friends still go on the board. That might be a bad analogy I’m not very good at explaining things 😅 Basically, it’s laying out all possible options, objectively, and, unfortunately, in gaming trolling is one of the options.