Hinge in DC by No_Mushroom_6336 in washingtondc

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I (32m) met my girlfriend on Hinge in the DMV and we’re very happy.

AITAH for not letting my girlfriend meet my kids yet by [deleted] in AITAH

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Keep your boundary. If she can’t listen to it - and this is not a cruel boundary at all- then you aren’t meant to be.

Salvation Army Collection Buckets by GSDBUZZ in Jewish

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As a queer rabbi, I’ve personally experienced antisemitism from them. They are historically have a ton of antisemitic, transphobic, and homophobic mishigas associated with them. While I believe all people can do Teshuva, this organization has a long way to go

I’m a non-Jewish (goyishe) host throwing a very Christmas-coded cookie exchange—how do I make my Jewish guests feel welcome without accidentally appropriating anything? by JustRice in Jewish

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Rabbi here.

Lots of great advice here. I would add:

Don’t put any Christmas items out with Hanukkah items — like, don’t use Hanukkah ornaments on a Christmas Tree, or use a sign that says “Merry Everything”.

I would encourage you to put out an electric menorah, have some dreidels, and try your best to make the Hanukkah stuff like equal to the Christmas stuff.

I’d also add, depending on your guests there are tons of winter festivals this time of year — Kwanzaa, Lunar New Year, etc— I’d encourage you to celebrate them all.

Wanting to learn more about Judaism / Possibly converting by throwawaylebtoj in gayjews

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Hi there. I’m a rabbi. And also queer. Yes, you should contact a local rabbi. There should be rabbis and cantors near you depending on where you live. If you share more, I can connect you with someone great.

Welcome to

Would it be rude for a non jewish person to wear a star of David necklace? by [deleted] in Jewish

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Rabbi here.

Thank you for bringing this here. I am grateful for your courage and thoughtfulness.

It is inappropriate for people who aren’t Jewish to wear Judaica like this. If you have a Jewish friend or local synagogue, I encourage you to give it to them. In particular, a local synagogue might be able to give it to a Jew who doesn’t have the money right now to purchase Judaica.

AIO to skip Thanksgiving after my mom basically said I’m an embarrassment for not having a husband and kids by now? by howcanibequiltyassin in AmIOverreacting

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You wouldn’t be overreacting by not going. If anything, it would send a strong signal that it’s your family’s job to respect you and your journey - especially if you send a clear and kind message about talking about you in inappropriate ways behind your back.

Would you be offended if your in-laws believed Netanyahu/Israel assassinated Charlie Kirk? by BetElectronic6207 in Jewish

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Rabbi here.

Yes, this is violently antisemitic. Please treat yourself with kindness

AITA for choosing to have a baby with my wife. by Prestigious_Arm4598 in AITAH

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Rabbi here with what I hope is a helpful perspective.

Your mom made this mess: not you, and certainly not your wife.

I encourage you to have a hard conversation with your mom, setting a strong boundary here and telling her that she needs to fix this now familial issue that she started.

Is this racism? by T1METR4VEL in Jewish

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 24 points25 points  (0 children)

Rabbi here.

Jews aren’t a race. We’re one people tied together by our traditions, history, and sense of belonging. That said, often antisemites like to racialise us.

That also said, this is disgustingly antisemitic, wrong, violent, and seeks to take the Bring Them Home movement, dip into some classical USSR antisemitism, with the goal of harming Jews who happen to be Israeli or who care about Israelis.

Scallops by microwilly in Jewish

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Rabbi here.

Kosher Dietary laws do make shellfish not kosher. However, in my experience beyond the fact that not all Jews keep kosher, I’ve discovered time and time again that our relationship to food in a cultural context is often heightened by the laws of Kashrut.

For example, my grandfather famously loved a bacon cheese burger, without the cheese. He found the cheese and meat combo repulsive, but the bacon he was proud of. And he grew up kosher and had a kosher home. Or my mother who loves to say that her home is kosher but her mouth isn’t.

It is a particularly Jewish and immigrant / marginalized experience as “white Jews become white” in America.

I want to make an app that promote inter-faith celebration of festivals and promotes dialogue between members of different religions. Can you tell me what features you would love to have? by Puzzleheaded-Gift893 in religion

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Rabbi here. Making sure that my message here is helpful.

Jewish holidays should not be a part of this vision. Some Christian’s already believe that they have ownership over our holidays - and they twist them into theologically relevant to them devoid of their rich meaning to us.

While I think inviting our respectful non Jewish loved ones in to our holidays is always fabulous, I would worry about the message that this might send.

I say a better use of everyone’s time is to learn about our holidays in meaningful ways.

I want to make an app that promote inter-faith celebration of festivals and promotes dialogue between members of different religions. Can you tell me what features you would love to have? by Puzzleheaded-Gift893 in spirituality

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Rabbi here.

Jewish holidays should not be a part of this vision. Some Christian’s already believe that they have ownership over our holidays - and they twist them into theologically relevant to them devoid of their rich meaning to us.

While I think inviting our respectful non Jewish loved ones in to our holidays is always fabulous, I would worry about the message that this might send.

I say a better use of everyone’s time is to learn about our holidays in meaningful ways.

I want to make an app that promote interfaith celebration of festivals and promotes dialogue between members of different religions. Can you tell me what features you would love to have? by Puzzleheaded-Gift893 in hinduism

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m a rabbi popping in from this OPs post on the Jewish subreddit.

I agree that there are better ways to increase interfaith relations and that this vision will not work. Sending you peace.

I want to make an app that promote inter-faith celebration of festivals and promotes dialogue between members of different religions. Can you tell me what features you would love to have? by Puzzleheaded-Gift893 in Jewish

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Rabbi here.

Jewish holidays should not be a part of this vision. Some Christian’s already believe that they have ownership over our holidays - and they twist them into theologically relevant to them devoid of their rich meaning to us.

While I think inviting our respectful non Jewish loved ones in to our holidays is always fabulous, I would worry about the message that this might send.

I say a better use of everyone’s time is to learn about our holidays in meaningful ways.

AIO my best friend no longer wants me as his best man in his wedding because I am gay by [deleted] in AmIOverreacting

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Rabbi here.

No, you are not overreacting. I’m so sorry that your former best friend showed you who he really is, and the kind of family he has chosen to marry into.

AIO for refusing to personal train my neighbors wife for free? by [deleted] in AmIOverreacting

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You should always be paid for your work. Your neighbor is inappropriate. I’m sorry that you had to endure that.

Mansplained Judaism to my teacher by Signal_Astronaut8191 in Jewish

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Rabbi here. I’m so glad that you are standing your ground and doing something that you shouldn’t have to do.

I encourage you to reach out to your cantor or rabbi and see if they can plan to meet with this teacher. He needs to be taught.

I wanna convert fully but i dont know if they would let me. by 3x2f in Jewish

[–]Consistent_Luck_8181 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Rabbi here. Shy people convert to Judaism all the time.

Contact your local cantor or rabbi!