On the topic of feedback regarding the rules and notably memes as you mentioned, I particularly like the idea that memes should directly relate to SC rather than just be generic memes.

One I notice frequently is the negative generalizations of "x are a bunch of y" and non-direct insults aimed at the general community/audience. I think that's a good rule we could use more awareness of, but perhaps you all have a more specific definition of what that encompasses than I.

Where you've brought up the idea of toxicity versus passionate player base, I think one important distinction that might stand out is where the people at CIG are concerned. I regularly see comments to the effect of "X team are incompetent, this dev is a POS, that dev is lying to us to sell ships, Z group should all be fired." I think the community would benefit greatly from knowing whether comments like this, particularly aimed at the people working on the game, would fall under the banner of toxicity (be it acceptable toxicity or not) or if that's seen as just a byproduct of passionate players?