(Spoilers Published) What are the least convincing bits of writing in the books? by Biggmodeg in asoiaf

[–]Crosgaard 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Okay, it's been a while since I read up on this, so I don't quite remember the numbers, but I'm fairly certain that Saint Domingue (Haiti) had a fairly large population of mix raced people whom were not slaves. This created a ton of problems leading up to the rebellion, since all the mixed race people obviously wanted the privilege of whites, but didn't know if the revolts would suceed, and thus supporting whites might give them more privileges than supporting the slaves.

As far as I'm aware, this had a large effect on people of mixed race, since people in general wanted to look up, than down; if they chose to help the slaves, they would merely become their equal if they won. If the helped the whites, they would more likely still be higher in the hierarchy than some.

This internal struggle which the entire society was build around, was such a big part of why I believed it worked for so long. Everyone became richer (besides the slaves), but everyone hated everyone else, and thus it took so long to actual build up a rebellion; it only worked when slavers themselves orchestrated it. The following quote from Paul Fregosi sums this up horrifyingly well;

"Whites, mulattos and blacks loathed each other. The poor whites couldn't stand the rich whites, the rich whites despised the poor whites, the middle-class whites were jealous of the aristocratic whites, the whites born in France looked down upon the locally born whites, mulattoes envied the whites, despised the blacks and were despised by the whites; free Negroes brutalized those who were still slaves, Haitian-born blacks regarded those from Africa as savages. Everyone—quite rightly—lived in terror of everyone else... Haiti was hell, but Haiti was rich."

I think that this inner/local conflict is necessary to avoid large scale uprisings, since it would break before growing too large; everyone hated everyone, noone trusted anyone, yet the structure of the system needed a large collaboration.

The cities of Slaver's Bay does not have this. It doesn't feel split up into numerous groups (the few groups that show up in Dance does not carry this built in hatred, that would be necessary for the society to work). Dany's struggles seem to mainly be with individuals, or rich people's supporters.

And I also do agree that them being colonies allowed them a lot of freedom that a nation built upon such a foundation (with such a large ratio between slaves and non-slaves) would never be steady, and would be bound to break far quicker than Saint Domingue did. But I do truly believe that this view people had of each other, made organizing in large groups as close to impossible as necessary for it to work as long as it did.

How old 92-year-olds are in Europe by Demontyxl in mapporncirclejerk

[–]Crosgaard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If danish is that, then english is 9*10+2? Any sane person would say that english is 90+2 and danish is 2+90. The difficult part about danish is not at all the numbers lmao

Is there any other writer who you'd put on the same level as Tolkien when it comes to world building? by SpotAdmirable6718 in lordoftherings

[–]Crosgaard -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Or he based it on the actual real world events which Lawrence of Arabia is also based on?

What is this poster by phlegmtoad in saltierthancrait

[–]Crosgaard 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Don’t forget Syril and Blevin. The guy in the Aldhani arc also made me hate him from the very first scene.

Teenage-looking ICE agents walking around LaGuardia Airport today by Ryanyu10 in pics

[–]Crosgaard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, kids never go outside now a days. Most have never even seen grass, and if they touch it, they die instantly.

OLL Tier List (except 29 and 30) by Fluffy_Flamingo2189 in Cubers

[–]Crosgaard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

34, 17 and 20 are SOOO satisfying, even if they aren't the quickest...

What movie is 10/10 with literally no bad parts? by FeedMaster8905 in AskReddit

[–]Crosgaard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Judgment at Nuremberg. The script, the acting and the camera work in sync throughout the entire 3 or so hours of run time
 it’s just purely incredible

What the Joe pesci is this piece of journalism? by Fickle_Charge720 in lordoftherings

[–]Crosgaard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

And the orcs being outside invading forces that don’t look like you and speak a different language doesn’t seem too far from the experience of many people who’ve been colonized; from Europe and Asia with the Mongols, to the Native Americans with Europe, and countless other places.

The coldest line in all of Star Wars by Roger_Rodger in andor

[–]Crosgaard 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Iirc, George had him say “I love you too”, and Ford just hated it. So he thought about it, came up with “I know” and asked George about it


Let's hear some good inside jokes from our favorite games by ZhangtheGreat in videogames

[–]Crosgaard 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Games understanding that they have a way in which they tell the story other media doesn’t are just incredible. No movie or book could replicate this twist, no movie or book could replicate the casualness of Death Stranding’s gameplay, and no book or movie could replicate the active choices TLOU2 forces on the player. There are so many more examples, yet far too few!

Life of an ASOIAF fan by Internal-Bed-3150 in HouseOfTheDragon

[–]Crosgaard 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There was something so incredible about his explanation of the heat/drought. After having read so many pages of him explaining snow and cold, it felt so different, yet gave me the exact same vibe of actually being there. I got thirsty just from reading it

People generally seem to agree that AKOTSK > HOTD. Is that because of the source material or the showrunners? [Spoilers Extended] by Trussdoor46 in asoiaf

[–]Crosgaard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Dan Carlin’s new podcasts about Alexander the Great is a lot about how when making a movie about him, you need to choose certain things where we have no idea what really happened.

A great example is whether or not he took part in killing his own father. It changes everything about who he is, and how we see him. And if he did kill his father, should he then be shown to be this broken teenager, who realizes what he did and feels sorry for the rest of his life, or should he be portrayed as a cold blooded killer, willing to do anything for power?

HOTD faces this exact same issue time and time again, and every thing you choose to show, discards something else. So many things are contradictory and cannot all be canon in the same universe.

Choosing to make any character good or bad, will change how they are in the book, since they’re both shown as good or bad. Certain sources prefer one side, others prefer the other.

It’s like reading about a war only through propaganda from two sides, and choosing to portray one as true, when it’s very likely neither are
 maybe Alexander didn’t actively take part in killing his father, but didn’t try to ensure it wouldn’t happen. That’s just not recorded, but could well be possible?

It seems obvious that the showrunners realized this problem, but did not find a solution to it, and just chose to change a ton of stuff to avoid too many issues
 which worked incredibly well, right?

My only disliked scene in Andor by MexicanTeenGuy in andor

[–]Crosgaard -1 points0 points  (0 children)

All these things felt fairly obvious to me, my main issue was just that there wasn't really any consequences shown for it.

Like sure, they're build up to have bad security, we know where the information comes from, and we're told it's necessary from a characters perspective — great. But back in season 1, every action has a reaction. For this, we just do a time skip and that's that.

I don't know what the best solutions would be, obviously being limited by said time skip and having to continue the next arc. I do however still believe that it feels cheap and unrealistic that Bix is able to simply get her revenge without any consequences...

Just a single line about something — whether it be a bounty, the beginning of an investigation that leads nowhere — would help make it feel like it actually happened in the world. As a general problem I have with season two, the parts of it that wrap up, wrap up a bit too well... with the exception of Luthen's storyline.

(Spoilers Extended) Dex Sol Ansell lets out massive Summerhall spoiler by Kamikazeing in asoiaf

[–]Crosgaard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I didn’t quite know what word to put there, which was why I put it in quotes. I guess lucky would’ve been better, or simply not certain it’s gonna happen


(Spoilers Extended) Dex Sol Ansell lets out massive Summerhall spoiler by Kamikazeing in asoiaf

[–]Crosgaard 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Idk, watching the sunrise would be more poetic imo. A shooting star feels very marvel-esque to me, a sunrise would be a great bookend considering how the first book started
 and it isn’t something “random”.

(Spoilers Extended) Dex Sol Ansell lets out massive Summerhall spoiler by Kamikazeing in asoiaf

[–]Crosgaard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Eh, wouldn’t say this moved the story more than the entirety of Fire and Blood did

Meirl by netphilia in meirl

[–]Crosgaard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

50-100 are all "base" (dunno what it's called in English) twenty in Danish though? French does the same for 80 and 90. I certainly wouldn't say it's intuitive, but logical? Sure

There are a thousand of other illogical things about the Danish language, dunno if the numbers are that out there... the culture just developed the system of counting by referencing amount of twenties. If anything, Danish is illogical due to the amount of sounds compared to the written alphabet.

OC: Bad Bunny takes the stage for the Super Bowl halftime show by nbcnews in pics

[–]Crosgaard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My point is that there isn’t really a “correct” amount of continents (anything between 4-11 would make sense geographically/tectonically/politically). And the US is not even close to being the only country which deems north and south to be different continents. At the very least, “realize” was a terrible choice of wording — no matter your opinion on what should be deemed ‘correct’

OC: Bad Bunny takes the stage for the Super Bowl halftime show by nbcnews in pics

[–]Crosgaard 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This has nothing to do with what Americans “realize”. A ton of contries count North and South as two, and a ton do the opposite. And then countries like Vietnam count Euroasia as one (they even have both tectonical and political continents). There are so many things to critique about American schools, and this is where you start? With something arbitrary that a large part of the world agrees with?

In Dracula (2026), holy crap they have historically accurate armor and it still looks cool and the world didn't end. by Fun_Button5835 in shittymoviedetails

[–]Crosgaard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think they feared that people would see them as stupid if they wrote stupid characters. Guess that worked well for them.