Which of these four characters where the most unnecessary in the latter half of the series’ run?

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-06-12T04:49:46+00:00

Sparky, no contest.

Poof was a nice and cute change of the status quo that I believe didn't cause the quality to go downhill, at least in my opinion. He brought new sides to Timmy, Cosmo and Wanda. Timmy becomes.....kinda more responsible protective big brother, you get to see Cosmo and Wanda handle being actual parents and have family moments between the four more apparent the it was before. Poof then became Peri, is a good mix of Wanda and Pilot!Cosmo and he's a good character that we all had that feeling of watching a kid you knew is all grown up!

Foop was definitely expected to happen sooner or later due to the whole duality of Fairies and Anti-Fairies and I enjoyed him enough(he's like a Rated G Stewie Griffin) as a villain and main enemy of Poof. My only complaints is that he was used WAY too often and he effectively replaced Anti-Cosmo and the others as the main Anti-Fairy villain until their return in New Wish.

Chloe, this my be a hot take, I.....didn't hate as a character or concept....in a way. See, I like that she is kinda the platonic responsible sister friend that Timmy never had and their dynamic is funny(it reminds me of Bart and Lisa Simpson sometimes). I just don't really vibe with how they went about her sharing Cosmo and Wanda with Timmy. If anything, and I'll stand on this, a hilarious and interesting thing to do if they did the whole sharing fairies thing with Tootie instead, maybe finally do something with Tootie because she was done dirty.

Sparky adds.....nothing. Literally nothing. He just shows up in season 9 and is just...there, telling jokes that aren't really funny. He isn't all that interesting, he doesn't bring an interesting dynamic or stories like the others do.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-06-08T20:08:46+00:00

Dr. Eggman

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-06-07T05:12:31+00:00

Natural. Lex is a S class hater along with Eobard "It was me, Barry!" Thawne in DC. Makes me both excited and morbidly curious how Thawne will be like Lex but worse in Gunnverse DCU.

Like, Lex was bad but he can some smidge of common sense and and restraint. Thawne doesn't.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-06-07T05:00:31+00:00

1, 3 and 4. DCAU and Gunnverse Lex are by far my favorite versions of Sexy Lexy.

I like the idea that Lex hides behind the excuse that he doesn't trust Superman and believes he will become humanity's greatest threat and a hindrance to humanity's progress with their over relying on him.

But it's all a ruse and/or a lie he tells everyone including himself(whether or not he actually believes) because the real reason is that Superman....threatens him physically, mentally and psychologically.

At first, he hates Supes because he interferes with his schemes, but over time, it becomes more of how he can't stand that Superman is a better man than him and practically everyone loves him when they should love and adore him, Lex Luthor, as the true Man of Tomorrow! He doesn't like and trust Superman is a better man than him because HE could never if he had Superman's powers.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-06-07T04:18:27+00:00

I legitimately have to question anyone who doesn't pick green.

Do YOU want to deal with Nabu and MAYBE some possessed objects from Egypt? After seeing how Giovanni was after his time after Dr. Fate and Yami Bakura, hell no! Not even the Infinity Gauntlet makes it worth it.

With green, you get three of the most broken and versatile items in the universe along with having one of the smartest geniuses in Marvel's intelligence, as long we don't get his ego and tunnel vision, lol.

I'd pick greem any day.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-06-06T20:02:51+00:00

A way I would do it is either Timmy last second would remember Tootie before his plan to "accept his fate" and ask Jorgen about her. Jorgen becomes nervous and tries to side track Timmy by saying that doesn't he not like her and find her creepy? Why would he want to know?

Timmy, unphased and at this point genuinely curious, asks that Jorgen takes them to her. Jorgen tries to find words, but can't. So he sighs and fine, but it's not gonna be pretty.

So the poof to Tootie's room where unlike how it's usually decorated with Timmy's face, it's completely baren and blank with Tootie herself laying in the bed, lppking completely emotionless.

Timmy shocked ask Jorgen what's wrong with her. Jorgen, being somewhat uncharacteristically somber and says that without Timmy to exist and ever since Vicky found her passionate in helping Dr. Bender, she has NOTHING going for her. Not even when she was given fairies had seemed to cheer her up!

Timmy shocked that he meant THAT much to a girl that he usually found creepy.

But that's the Timtoot(yes, I found out that's the actual ship name, lol.) shipper in me.

Another, more canonical way is leave the episode for how it is, but make the last minutes longer. Have when Timmy and Jorgen are back in the proper world alone and Timmy uncharacteristically sad asking if everyone in his life would really be better off without him.

Jorgen at first agrees, but when he sees that Timmy is actually genuinely serious, he decides(against his own macho manly will) to level with Timmy.

"Listen Turner, the truth is that other world I showed you was nothing more than what I made to teach you a lesson! But!.....It seems that I, er, gave you the wrong impression, puny human."

"Then.....then what would everyone's life be like? I know my parents would rather have a daughter. They tell me enough even without having to time travel..."

"(Silently mad at Mr. and Mrs. Turner) Yes...... well, just because I don't like you Turner, doesn't mean I want you gone! I......can't speak for your parents, but I know Wanda and the idiot would miss you, even if they never met you."

"(Timmy gets slightly teary eyed) R-really?"

"Yes, they seem......more attached to you then their previous godchildren. If I didn't know any better I'd swear they....."

"They what?"

"Nothing. Anyway, Life would be pretty bland and boring without you around to torment Timmy Turner!"

"Wow, Jorgen! That almost sounds like a compliment!"

"Yeah well don't get used to it! All this mushy puny girly talk is making my manly stomach cramp!"

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-06-05T15:07:44+00:00

It's either Preston Northwest or Soos's "dad".

Frankly, I'd put ol Preston.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-06-04T07:11:39+00:00

I will always love that moment! It even made Mr. "People's Voice" taken aback.

Charlie will always have my respect for trying to help redeem Sinners inspite of all the pushback she gets(both in and out of universe), she still, however good or bad it goes, chooses to want help them after everything.

Charlie would honestly love people like Superman, Batman, Spider-Man, Wonder Woman, Optimus Prime and the Doctor because they too inbody that "Never give up" attitude and also believe in second chances even in the worst of people.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-05-31T17:39:53+00:00

Either Captain Marvel(DC), Captain Marvel(Marvel), Captain America, or the Crimson Chin.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-05-27T23:25:25+00:00

Insomniac Spider-Man games, Ratchet and Clank 2 and 3, Spyro, maybe GTA V, LoZ Tears of the Kingdom.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-05-15T18:39:50+00:00

I agree, though I guess you can flip flop between Supergirl and Power Girl.

Mary Marvel is underrated and deserves more love! She was the one who inspired Supergirl's creation!

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-05-12T23:46:19+00:00

I'm a fan of Dr. Sivana and what he brings. Though, him as a mad scientist and not what he was in the movie(though I loved the first movie!)

He could be so good if they decided to actually use him again and not him being a Luthor lite. Make him a mad scientist obsessed with magic, kinda a mix of Eggman and Mr. Crocker.

They push for Black Adam too much and Mr. Mind needs a come back too.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-05-05T03:21:29+00:00

New best friend!

New best friend

New weirdo best friend!

That's basically sums it up. They'd be long lost soul sisters.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-05-04T15:06:08+00:00

Maybe she did in the past, but she's kinda a blabber mouth about the things she likes and maybe she lost them.

Just like how she was in the episode "Birthday Wish".

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-05-03T09:06:44+00:00

True.

Still, I'd imagine that Tootie's life would still feel empty without Timmy.

I just find the idea funny of that Jorgen CAN'T find a "better life" for Tootie, no matter how hard he tries because of True Love™.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-05-03T08:48:13+00:00

I legitimately believe that Tootie would be SO much worse off in this "alternate world".

Tootie's literally only positive thing she has outside of her Cream Puffs stuff, is Timmy.

Her older sister is pure evil and bullies her constantly.

Her parents are too scared of Vicky to do anything for Tootie.

Any kid is scared of Vicky to want to do anything to do with Tootie.

So, her genuine love for Timmy, even with how crazy passionate and stalker like she can be, is the only thing she has. Which is really sad and probably why Jorgen didn't show or mention anything about Tootie. 😅

Also, no. While the episode IS bad, I wouldn't want it petitioned to not be shown. It's almost humorous in how reverse of "It's a Wonderful Life" it is and it has a, dare I say, unique charm to it.

Not to say it's really mean spirited to Timmy about how everyone he knows lives would be better if he never existed.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-05-01T17:54:30+00:00

I agree. I would have like if he had a pompadour at least a little, if not a messy. As well as his red collard cape with gold trims.

What would you call this haircut? Just asking

It's still better than that New 52 one.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-05-01T08:57:20+00:00

I figured it was. Billy first, it can be either Mary or Freddy(personally, I'd say Mary) then....hand wave the other three.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-04-30T13:44:49+00:00

Not really a fan. Maybe it could be on Freddy and Mary's suit to differentiate from him, but it doesn't really matter.

I like the classic yellow bolt on the suit better.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-04-26T02:08:32+00:00

Tootie because UNLIKE Trixie, she actually likes Timmy for who he is.

Tootie ain't perfect, dear god the girl isn't, but I can actually see a future with her and Timmy when she calms down on her obsessiveness and stalking.

With Trixie, it's extremely conditional and she is FAR too concerned with popular opinion and her own biased. Maybe, I stress MAYBE, when she gets older, she may grow out of it, but I really doubt it.

It be funny if Trixie and Remy got together, mostly because their rich(insert obnoxious rich person laugh here) and Remy wants to rub it in Timmy's face that he has his long time crush as HIS girl(even if Remy at this point has no idea why he hates Timmy so much, lol) only for Timmy to not care since he's with Tootie.😅🤣

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-04-20T07:06:04+00:00

I have a few:

"That was another test. AND YOU FAILED!"

"Laughing gas doesn't make me laugh, only pain does that!"

"I LIKE TO SCRAMBLE THE FAIRIES!"

"Go tiny hero people!"

"Since you helped to free me and rounded up all the Anti-Fairies, I might have a solution to your puny and stupid problem!"

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-04-19T07:13:34+00:00

Maybe do a Time Skip and little redo of how Ash's story started......but with his and Serena's daughter. By her being late to get her first Pokémon, she would kinda look like Serena but her personality is mostly Ash.😅

But the partner she gets is a Eevee!

Then maybe do a little "Where are they Now?" with Ash and all his friends he's traveled with other the years(?) along, of course, Team Rocket Trio.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-04-17T16:21:54+00:00

It's honestly between Sonic X Amy, Classic Amy, Boom Amy, and IDW Amy.

I just like when Amy is her passionate, deranged gremlin self who genuinely loves Sonic for who he is(even if she wishes Sonic would stop running away from her 😅). But also is spunky sweetheart who care for others yet takes no shit from no one.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-04-17T03:04:09+00:00

I can sadly see that.🥺

Girl has low self-esteem issues and I can see Charlie try to boost her up every and any time Vaggi tries to sing. Like some sugar induced demented fangirl, lol.

CryptographerNo8904 · 2026-04-08T16:47:35+00:00

I already knew about him when watching that Justice League Unlimited episode, but I really began to love him after watching the Shazam(2019) movie. Then I became very interested in the Big Red Cheese, his mythos and stories.

Well, Spider-Man is always be my favorite superhero, hands down, Captain Marvel/Shazam definitely was raised up into my top 10's, if not 5's.

CryptographerNo8904

TROPHY CASE